The Utility of Scholarship: An interview with John Red Horse

Volume 4, No. 3 - Winter 1993
JOHN RED HORSE

Dr. John Red Horse

Dr. John Red Horse is dean of the College of Liberal Arts at the University of Minnesota, Duluth. His career as a teacher, writer and administrator has allowed him to see the important role scholarship can play in American Indian communities. But he has also observed how much of the existing research fails to meet the needs of native Americans. We asked Dr. Red Horse to discuss the opportunities and limitations of research. The interview was conducted by Tribal College Editor Paul Boyer.

Boyer: In some American Indian communities, permission is required before a researcher can conduct a study. Is it appropriate for tribes to control research in their communities? Can this ever become a form of intellectual censorship?

Red Horse: Several years ago, John Tippeconnic and I worked with tribes to develop an American Indian human subjects research committee. Our intent was not to organize intel­lectual censorship, but simply to build a bridge between tribes and the research community.

This effort, however, was misin­terpreted by non-Indians who feared intellectual censorship. I thought that this was an interesting response, particularly from faculty who represented disciplines which are well-versed in several types of review systems. These include human subjects review committees that are mandated by federal regula­tion to examine research protocols. It also includes referee panels which review the quality and determine the appropriateness of research sub­mitted for publication.

I remain convinced that tribes need to be involved in the decision-making about research. Universities and pri­vate think tanks have a host of research people who may have pure intentions. However, their work con­tinues to be extrapolated to American Indian behavior in general. It is not uncommon, for example, that research on classroom behavior among Cherokee Indians from rural north­eastern Oklahoma is used loosely by educators to explain behavior among Chippewa Indians in Minneapolis.

This tendency to generalize also affects popular perceptions of Indian culture. Carlos Castaneda’s writings, for example, has con­vinced more than one reader that peyote permeates every American Indian religion.

Boyer: How should scholars approach the study of American Indians? What can they do to improve the quality of their work?

Red Horse: It is important to be grounded in American Indian knowl­edge, attitudes and beliefs. This sense of grounding sometimes confuses non- Indians who assume that it implies personal experience as an American Indian. Personal experience helps in the development of germane ques­tions, of course, in the same manner that it helps Jewish scholars who had first-hand experience with the holo­caust. However, this grounding may be gained through several routes, such as gathering oral histories.

Boyer: How different is the research being conducted by the still small but growing number of native American scholars? Is there a fundamentally different research agenda?

Red Horse: American Indian schol­ars should, and are, changing how research is conducted. This is neces­sary because we simply do not fit readily into the existing disciplines.

Our political scientists pursue matters of sovereignty, which is not a topic of concern for the main­stream discipline. Our historians seek an authentic representation of Andrew Jackson, which is inconsis­tent with efforts of the mainstream discipline. Our archaeologists advo­cate repatriation of skeletal remains and religious artifacts in a manner that is unpopular with the main­stream discipline.

Boyer: These examples suggest that research by Indians is more utilitar­ian, more focused on providing solutions to recognized needs.

Red Horse: I certainly believe that research is driven by the needs of American Indian communities. Hopefully, we do not pursue research for abstract reasons, but with the intent to communicate with non-Indians and American Indian audiences.

American Indian scholarship has an immediate impact on tribal peo­ples. Our research must be respon­sive. This does not suggest that our research must skew data or dance around interpretations of data. It simply means that our research must not be trivial or inappropriately lin­ear and reductionist.

This is true in other academic dis­ciplines, as well. Indian scholarship differs from non-Indian research only by the type of research questions that are asked. Our historians, for exam­ple, may improve cross-cultural understanding through examination of treaty rights while non-Indian his­torians may improve international understanding through examination of newly found documents which sur­faced during the breakup of the Soviet Union.

Boyer: Is it possible for a native American scholar to meet the expectations of his or her academic discipline and also satisfy the unique research needs of American Indian communities?

Red Horse: It will face the same preju­dices and barriers that have confront­ed new paradigms throughout history. Copernicus challenged the ptolemaic system during a period when scholarly expectations were controlled by the established church. His work was banned and was not revisited until Galileo courageously popularized it one hundred years later.

There’s another example from the more recent past: chaos theo­rists faced similar barriers from established disciplines throughout the 1960s and 1970s. Their theory did not fit disciplinary protocols. They had difficulty obtaining research support. They had to orga­nize alternative conferences and programs to discuss development in chaos theory. They had to start sep­arate journals to get articles accept­ed for publication.


Leave a Reply