Tribal Colleges Helped Shape Kellogg Agenda for Major Initiative

Volume 8, No. 4 - Spring 1997
DR. HENRIETTA MANN

Dr. Henrietta Mann. Photo courtesy of the Kellogg Foundation

In 1994, the W.K. Kellogg Foundation first approached the tribal colleges in the American Indian Higher Education Consortium (AIHEC) with an offer they–presumably–could not refuse. Kellogg was determined to make a significant improvement in Indian education. To do so, the foundation wanted to fund a few model institutions in the consortium and asked the tribal college presidents for their suggestions. Chronically underfunded, most tribal colleges live hand to mouth and, one would assume, cannot afford to balk at any offers of help.

Nevertheless, Kellogg’s offer was met with questions. At the first meeting, Dr. James Shanley (Assiniboine) asked the Kellogg program officer, “What’s the splash?” The president of Fort Peck Community College for the past 14 years, Shanley had seen too many instances when foundations have tried to solve major problems with a couple of million dollars.

At the next meeting Sinte Gleska University President Lionel Bordeaux objected to Kellogg’s plan to fund only “model” institutions. “It’s all of us or none of us,” he said. Kellogg representative Valorie Johnson argued that the colleges should not turn their backs on this opportunity; Kellogg was not going to fund all 29 American colleges, she said.

Bordeaux could have assumed that his institution would be a likely candidate as a model institution. Nevertheless, he repeated his statement, “It’s all of us or none of us. That’s the way we have always done it.” Bordeaux clearly spoke for the group, which had relied upon equal distributions to maintain relationships amongst the sister institutions over the 24 year history of AIHEC and the nine year history of the American Indian College Fund. Told Kellogg had $25 million to $30 million in mind, the college presidents said planning would be necessary if they were really trying to reform Native higher education. Kellogg doesn’t fund planning, said Valorie Johnson (Seneca/Cayuga), Kellogg program officer for youth and education.

The Kellogg Native American Higher Education Initiative could have suffered a still birth that day. Typically foundations have approached American Indian communities just as the federal government has approached them, saying, “I’ve got the solution, what’s your problem?” Such generic ideas do not suit the individual circumstances of tribes. Nor does the community feel committed to a project if the foundation’s name is the only one over the door. As a result, many such imposed solutions fail. Only recently have a few foundations changed this approach.

Aware of the dismal record of philanthropy in Indian Country, Kellogg was ready to listen. Although Kellogg had funded three relatively small tribal college projects in the past dealing with health or leadership, Kellogg had rejected many more tribal college applications. Before Kellogg approached AIHEC as a group, the annual Kellogg board trip included two tribal colleges–Salish Kootenai and Oglala Lakota–in June 1993. The board returned, enthusiastic about the tribal colleges. Kellogg set up a staff task force on Native and Hispanic issues, which concluded that education should be the first priority. Kellogg wanted to provide strategic funding, not a band-aid. The foundation hired more Indian staff and consultants.

Despite Kellogg’s commitment, Valorie Johnson felt hesitant about carrying Bordeaux’s message seeking support for all the colleges. “He reminded me of our Native values. I knew his message was right so somehow I found the courage to ask Dr. Mawby,” she said later. Dr. Russell Mawby, then Kellogg’s chief executive officer, listened to Johnson’s report and decided to abide by their wishes. All of the colleges would be funded. In addition, they would receive planning money to determine the best strategy. Today, the Kellogg model has stimulated interest from many other foundations interested in Indian higher education, who have been calling to find out more about the initiative.

Phase I involved over a year’s planning. Tribal college and mainstream university representatives came together at three networking conferences where they developed the mission and goals of the initiative with the guidance of two tribal elders, Dr. Henrietta Mann (Cheyenne) and Fred Leader Charge (Sicangu Lakota). Some tribal colleges held planning retreats of their own with universities, tribal elders, federal agencies, and private industry to chart their own Kellogg initiatives.

Kellogg CEO Dr. William C. Richardson addressed the participants in February 1996, saying he hoped tribal colleges and mainstream institutions could learn from one another to the benefit of Native students. Although 80 percent of Native college students attend mainstream institutions, their graduation rates are far too low. Only 17 percent of Native Americans attend college; only 4 percent graduate with a four-year degree, according to Kellogg figures. Tribal colleges understand what Native American students need to succeed, he said.

Meanwhile, Kellogg was training its own staff, most of whom had not worked with Indian communities before. Rather than creating an Indian desk to handle the initiative, Kellogg wanted to utilize agriculture staff for agriculture projects, early childhood staff for early childhood projects, etc. Kellogg brought in speakers, researched literature, and sent the staff to visit tribal colleges.

At times, the process faltered and threatened to self-destruct as differences in values and traditions surfaced. One Kellogg staff member questioned providing equal grants. “That’s not life. There are not enough resources for everyone. They should compete with each other,” the person said. Another visited a tribal college and said, “They’re operating on a shoe string. They’re never going to be able to use this money.” Individuals from tribal colleges and from Kellogg occasionally clashed. At the networking conferences, the tribal college participants and the mainstream institution participants sometimes saw one another as competitors and questioned the planning process.

Ultimately, the spirit of cooperation prevailed. In December 1996, the Kellogg board voted to provide $22.2 million over four years to implement Phase II. The money will go to the tribal colleges and to three organizations–the American Indian Higher Education Consortium (AIHEC), the American Indian College Fund (AICF), and the National Institute for Native Leadership in Higher Education (NINLHE). AIHEC Central is the headquarters for the consortium in Alexandria, Va. Based in Denver, AICF is a non-profit fundraising organization for the tribal colleges. NINLHE promotes the professional development of Native American Program Directors at four year colleges and universities. It is coordinated at Stanford University and Dartmouth College. In March 1997, at press time, the tribal colleges were applying for the Phase II grants. In another innovation, AIHEC will be managing a major segment of the Phase II initiative.

Already Phase I had changed the tribal colleges’ perspective on their future. At a meeting about Kellogg, Lac Courte Oreilles Ojibwa Community College President Dr. Jasjit Minhas was asked why his college had not developed relationships with other colleges in his area before. He said, “If there’s no light at the end of the tunnel, you don’t do anything. If it is dark everywhere, you just sit there.”

Dr. Betty J. Overton, director of higher education at Kellogg, said, “This initiative is about strengthening institutions and mobilizing resources. It is tailor made for Kellogg. Kellogg doesn’t make changes, we look for agents of change and help them help themselves.”

Marjane Ambler is editor of the Tribal College Journal. For more information, see the Winter 1994-95 issue of the Journal on “Philanthropy” and “Governing Underfunded Tribal Colleges” in the Summer 1996 issue.


Leave a Reply