Will Students Succeed? First Nations School Evaluates Attitudes

Volume 8, No. 4 - Spring 1997

In 1985, the Blood Tribe conducted a survey in its tribal schools to determine the prevailing attitudes of three groups: the parents, teachers, and students. The results indicated discrepancies in their expectations of student success. The students’ own expectations of themselves were significantly higher than what the teachers expected. The students expected to successfully complete not only post secondary education but also attain a professional career. The parents had slightly lower expectations; they expected their children to graduate from high school and successfully complete college. The teachers had the lowest expectations; they reported these students would not even graduate from high school.

At the time of the survey, the Canadian government managed the school system on the Blood Indian Reserve in southern Alberta, without regard for cultural input into the curriculum. Since 1988, however, the Kainaiwa School System has been administered by the Kainaiwa Board of Education. (Kainaiwa is the Blood people’s name for ourselves.)

In response to the attitude survey, the Kainaiwa School Board carefully considered how to improve teacher expectations and performance to match the students’ higher expectations of success in school. Consequently, the school system hired more Native teaching staff. The percentage is now approximately 50 percent. Subsequent surveys, however, still indicated a significant variance between student and teacher attitudes. Educators had hoped that by increasing the number of Native teachers, we could improve the teachers’ attitudes toward their Native students. Various factors may have affected the results.

Much of the blame lies with teacher training programs, which are too generic and do not allow for much study in various cultures. Some teacher training programs have allowed intercultural training and courses in Native American Studies and/or Native Education. However, there is no guarantee that all the teachers take such courses.

A more critical question arises. For many, regardless of the number of courses taken, there can never be a complete change in attitudes given the different socio-economic backgrounds of the staff compared with the Native students. Many of these teachers have taught for many years within the system, and the attitudes survey included many of the long term staff. Perhaps other factors may have contributed to the survey results, such as discipline issues and a change in administration. In the future, the recent change from a K-6 to a middle school system may affect survey results.

Educators on the reserve believe we can improve the teachers’ attitudes toward their students over time. The Kainaiwa are primarily responsible for educating students on our reserve. We have four schools: two elementary, one middle school, and one high school with a total enrollment of approximately 1,200. Another 800 students attend other public and separate school systems off the reserve with transfer payments from the Kainaiwa School System.

We also have our own college. The Kainaiwa Board of Education has asked Red Crow Community College to establish a teacher training program on the Blood Reserve. We expect to improve on the current and prevailing attitudes held by teachers in reserve schools by implementing culturally sensitive and relevant curriculum in the teacher training program.

With the input of the Kainaiwa School system specialists and administrators, the teacher training program will train aspiring teachers and re-educate some of the existing teachers. The pedagogy of the tribe will be enhanced throughout the curriculum. The new approach will meet the needs of our students and our community in every aspect of education. Respected elders from the community will be consulted at every level during the planning and implementation to develop the “Kainaiwa Education: a Methodology Approach in First Nations Education.”

The Kainaiwa School System is still an exemplary Indian school system in Canada. It has many innovations and cultural programs that don’t exist in many other school systems. Ninety percent of the administrators are tribal members; 50 percent of the certified staff are Natives; and the school board is composed completely of Kainaiwa tribal members. The Blackfoot language, prayer, and other cultural areas are regular components of the school system, without external funding. The school board offers term contracts to all staff and is not bound by an external teacher union group, which allows for changing staffing. The province of Alberta considers it a private school system, and so it can make its own rules for hiring and replacing staff.

There is much hope here that with the strategic future planning of Kainaiwa Education, we will have high quality, culturally relevant education for all Kainaiwa children. The mainstream model of education has failed our children miserably. Only by aggressively developing the Kainaiwa culture and language content in the curriculum will it ever be meaningful. This must include teacher training. For our Native students to succeed, their teachers must believe in them.

Joyce Goodstriker, M.Ed., is superintendent of schools, and Deborah F. Pace, Ph.D., is director of special student services for the Kainaiwa Board of Education, Kainaiwa (Blood Tribe). Both are members of the tribe. This article is based upon six evaluations conducted for the Kainaiwa Board of Education between 1986 and 1996.


Leave a Reply