Starting From Scratch: Bay Mills College is creating a medical curriculum by asking students what they want

Volume 5, No. 3 - Winter 1994

Perhaps no other field offers more employment opportuni­ties and is more urgently need­ed than health care. Statistics from the Michigan Employment Security Commission shows a clear need for health providers. Nurses, medical technologists, lab technicians and home health aides are in critical demand nationwide.

The Michigan Employment Security Commission states that hir­ing in the licensed practical nurse field is “fast,” with an average of 950 openings per year. The need in the Upper Peninsula, where the college is located, shows a growth rate of 21 percent. It should also be noted that less than one percent of the health providers in Michigan are Indian people.

Likewise, there are many oppor­tunities for health professionals on reservations. Letters from tribal health directors and administrators also reported that there are openings at their clinics, yet seldom did they find a tribal member with the neces­sary qualifications.

Recognizing the growing need, Bay Mills Community College established a pre-health career program for low income native Americans, with funding from the Kellogg Foundation. No health care degrees are offered; instead, students are prepared to transfer to state col­leges and universities. In addition, the college helps students select a health occupation and evaluates the effectiveness of its recruitment, retention and placement efforts.

Since, historically, 80 percent of students entering Bay Mills Community College need remediation in math and English, most enroll in developmental studies, or academic enrichment, the first year. Beginning the second year, students continue studies in general educa­tion and take courses that are pre­requisites for health care professions, such as biology, medical terminology and psychology.

During its first year, the college had two goals. It hoped to recruit fif­teen students into the health sci­ence transfer program and provide career exploration and counseling to twice that many.

But after just one year of opera­tion, it became obvious that the program would have to change.

Students simply did not want to go to the state schools. If we talked them into going, they dropped out before the end of the year. Most had never been away from their family support system. There were no mothers or grandmothers to watch the children. There was no network of lifelong friends and relatives to support them when they needed it. Classes were often large and stu­dents were hesitant to ask questions if they did not understand some­thing. Instructors were not readily available and appeared distant and uninterested.

We had previous experience with putting in a needed program, only to find that there were no students enrolling to take the classes. In 1987 we offered day care management. The tribes need­ed day care centers, young mothers at school needed day care centers, and the community needed day care centers. So it seemed obvious that we should offer day care manage­ment training. The first year twelve students enrolled, graduated and went to work. The second year, four students enrolled and dropped out. Why? There is no status in being a baby sitter and the pay is too low.

Of course, it would have been nice to have this information before we added the course of study.

With this lesson in mind, we have begun a comprehensive study to determine which health science curriculum would be most likely to succeed. The Kellogg Foundation agreed to support the research so that, this time, we can develop a new, terminal degree program. The study is not complete; we hope to begin our new program with the 1994-95 academic year. However, our initial findings have been sur­prising and have reinforced the importance of careful planning before a degree program is created.

This study, first, is looking at the marketability of heath careers: What health science careers have the most potential openings over the next five years? What health science careers are needed on the reservations and in their surround­ing areas?

Next, it is examining available college resources: What program can the college afford to add to its curriculum? Which accrediting associations, such as the MDA, will work with us to build a quality program?

Finally, it is considering the inter­ests of students: In which programs will students enroll? In which pro­gram are they most likely to com­plete the course of study?

For most of these questions, stan­dard research methods were used. Questionnaires were mailed to hos­pitals, health area providers and tribal health programs. Meetings were held with the Michigan Nursing Association and other groups. Indian Health Service and tribal manpower needs were collect­ed. The Private Industry Council, JPTA and MESC were consulted.

Preliminary findings are interest­ing. Although local dentists were extremely enthusiastic about dental hygiene and offered to teach and participate in the program, research showed us that there was not enough turnover to provide long term life for the program at the col­lege. The average hygienist worked for ten years in a particular office. Likewise, the Indian Health Service did not need more than one in our area. We decided that it would not be a practical addition, especially when the high cost of equipment was considered.

The LPN (Licensed Practical Nurse) is another possible program. The state nursing association— reflecting national trends—is pro­moting the bachelor of science in nursing as the preferred terminal degree. However, the Nursing Board says it understands why the college would want an LPN program and would support setting up an accreditable program.

However, initial research also shows that opportunities for employment are not as abundant as it first appears. Positions for LPN’s in eastern Upper Peninsula hospitals are limited. Those looking for work in nursing homes, however, would find employment easily.

All of these program would take a massive effort to establish, making this research process all the more important. Suppose we started another program that failed to attract students?

Looking for more innovative ways to get information, we have also experimented with new survey techniques. Tribal people are often reluctant to fill out a mailed ques­tionnaire. How could we get them to tell us what they wanted to do? We came up with a way to give the people direct input into the addi­tion of the new curriculum: a tele­phone vote.

Tribal newspapers go into 19,000 homes. We took out an ad bordered by the word “Vote”. Would-be stu­dents were asked to vote for the cur­riculum they would like to take by calling our 800 number. Those answering the phone take their vote, telephone number and address. Our intention is to contact them when the votes are in and recruit them for the program chosen based on their vote.

Martha McLeod is president of Bay Mills Community College in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan.


Leave a Reply