
Artist Lillian Pitt displaying her work at a show.
“My culture is a living thing. It is not a static dead way of life but an ever changing metamorphosis of adaption.” –Larry Ahvakana (Inpuiat) Glass Sculptor
An artist who happens to be Indian is burdened with the responsibility to maintain the integrity of his or her nation while producing an art form that is marketable. If an Indian artist ventures into commercialism, he or she must contend with the perception that creativity or culture has been compromised.
These barriers must be overcome when Indian artists attempt to market their wares. At the same time, artists, many with little formal training in business, have to contend with the competitive world of marketing, product development and fair pricing. Too often, artists do not recognize the value of their work or feel compelled to accept a low commission.
The talented artist must, then, also be a savvy businessperson. These considerations are best described in a hypothetical scenario:
Alice and Blanche are sisters from a long line of prominent traditional potters and each have received recognition fpr their work. To sell their creations, they travel to regional Indian markets and pow-wows. They also sell through one trading post in a nearby town when they need money quickly. During the tourist season, the trading post receives a steady flow of costumers. However, the pottery is regarded as high-end merchandise. Therefore, most people admire the pottery and move on to purchase a smaller, less-expensive memento of their vacation.
An art collector explained to the two artists that the large spectacular pieces really speak to people’s hearts. Yet the price is prohibitive for all but the most serious collector. Diversifying their product line by offering a smaller, less expensive piece may provide admirers the opportunity to purchase their fine art items, increasing the sister’s sales and improving cash flow.
Both Alice and Blanche value the process of making traditional pottery, but the effort is very time consuming. Each explore ways to diversify. They attend a class at the community college teaching the process of clay casting, enabling the artist to produce in multiples. This process would help them produce the inventory needed to potentially move beyond their regional area and into a national marketing arena.
About this time, the local newspaper prints an article written and presented by members of the tribal nation’s business council. The article denounces the use of cast pots because it is offensive to the cultural traditions of that particular nation. Alice and Blanche have great respect for the leaders in their community and the elders of their nation. Therefore, each considers the elders’ wishes carefully. But the bills are mounting and their children need new clothes.
Alice discovers that other Indian people are selling miniatures of their nation’s art forms as Christmas ornaments. Understanding that she, like many of her people are traditional and Christian, the concept of the ornaments wouldn’t affect her integrity in any way. Having reached a decision, she begins casting the ornaments to be hand-painted.
Blanche understands the reasoning behind product diversification. However, she decides not to diversify her product line due to current cultural concerns.
Alice develops a small inventory of the ornaments designed to reflect images of her traditional pottery. She realizes that if she expands her market, she will need to fervently consider her production ability and competition with the Japanese imitations which are selling at a much cheaper price. Alice feels her most valuable asset is that she presents her work with integrity in terms of her traditional values, and her products carry the Indian Arts and Craft Association authenticity logo.
The ornaments sell well at the trading post and at the markets she attends. Alice could sell more if she had the time to make more. At one market, she meets a buyer from a large upscale department store. The buyer presents an opportunity to distribute nationally, but Alice does not feel ready. Christmas passes; again, cash flow is a problem.
Without losing the cultural values so important to her, she designs earrings that resemble her traditional pottery. The earrings can be made quickly and they compliment her traditional full-size pottery. Her innovation creates a stir among tribal members. She is beginning to make a steady income and she is gaining recognition for her traditional pottery.
Traditional people have some reservations about supporting her efforts, but they see that she is becoming successful in a good way. She is retaining her cultural values and serving as a role model for other members of her nation.
Alice’s confidence and enthusiasm grows. She carefully considers the advantages of selling through a department store. She thinks about how much more time she will have to create her pottery and miniatures if someone else were selling her work and providing the customer service. Larger orders and the possibility of repeat orders would provide a more stable base of income. The store’s prestigious reputation would lend credibility to her name.
On the other hand, Alice recognizes some disadvantages in working with a large department store. She had heard that big stores often wait 90 to 120 days to pay for orders. She would have to sell at wholesale which would provide a lower profit potential (50 percent). Her production would have to remain high and steady to fulfill demands, even when she wasn’t feeling inspired to create. And, of course, there is the tough process of getting into the store and playing the high-pressure business game. Still, she decides to write to the department store buyer to promote her miniatures.
The buyers’ response to her inquiry is enthusiastic. The department store would like to see complimentary samples of each ornament and a pair of earrings, as well as a sample piece of pottery. Alice does not fully trust the buyer and views this request as being an imposition.
After some earnest and frank conversations with the buyer and subsequent negotiations, Alice decides to begin a steady relationship with the department store whereby they order from her and pay her quarterly. She sells to the department store at a non-negotiable wholesale price. In addition, the store agrees to have a promotional display which includes pictures of the history of her people.
It is Alice’s miniatures that captured the initial interest of the department store. However, by using one of the traditional pots as a centerpiece in a promotional display, it is discovered that there is significant interest in her large pottery. The department store begins ordering a few pieces of pottery at a time. Although she was getting only 50 percent (at wholesale price) of the money she would get by selling at a retail show, she is actually netting more money because she doesn’t have to pay the booth rental fees and travel expenses. In addition, she can spend more time creating and producing an inventory.
Although Blanche chooses not to diversify her product line, she does wants to broaden her market as well. She conducts some research at the local library about the wholesale industry and its standards. She realizes that her high-end pottery requires special promotion and placement in quality stores. She decides to find someone who is experienced at promoting fine art with marketing connections to the high-end stores and galleries.
Blanche finds a listing of art sales agents in a fine art trade magazine. She contacts a few to interview. Through this interview process, she finds that most agents take a 10 to 20 percent commission on top of the wholesale discount that retailers demand. This seems like a substantial cut from her profits, but Blanche’s pottery isn’t selling very well locally, so she decides to hire an agent on a commission basis.
The agent she chooses has contacts with reputable galleries in the country, as well as with a department store that is initiating a new fine art section in their store. Blanche negotiates a 14 percent commission for the sales agent with the understanding that if she does not reach an agreed upon minimum sales level, the commission would go down to 10 percent until the sales level is reached and maintained for three months.
Blanche is pleasantly surprised at the sales volume that the sales agent reaches within the first two months. She is chosen to sell through the same department store that Alice is selling through. Alice and Blanche talk about the recognition that they will receive showing together and their business arrangements with the store and the agent respectively. Blanche realizes that she is getting a smaller profit from the sale of her pottery than Alice is for the sale of her miniatures and pottery.
The Alice and Blanche hypothetical scenario identifies influences and obstacles that must be addressed when marketing one’s product. The considerations are difficult and endless. For instance, both artists accomplish set goals and are benefiting with added production time, but Alice finds she is spending more time producing her miniatures than her traditional pottery. Most important is that the women maintain traditional values according to their culture when trying to support themselves and their families.
If one concept is remembered from this scenario, it should the Indian Arts and Crafts Association authenticity logo. John Beheeler of the United Tribes Indian Art Expo says, “When you see an Indian theme product in a J.C. Penney’s [type store], look for the IACA logo. If it doesn’t have it, don’t buy it.”
Dennis Fox and Andrea Coron work for First Nations Arts in Falmouth, Virginia, which is part of the First Nations Development Institute. First Nations Arts helps American Indian artists build markets and holds regional workshops on marketing strategy.






Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.