By Jacqueline Emery
University of Nebraska Press (2017)
366 pages
Review by Farina King
In Recovering Native American Writings in the Boarding School Press, Jacqueline Emery assembles a collection of student letters, editorials, essays, and stories that not only provides access to these writings but also revises traditional understandings of Indian boarding schools and their students. While previous scholarship dismissed sources from boarding school newspapers, Emery argues “that all periodicals, including boarding school newspapers, are products of complex negotiations between editors, writers, and readers, and because of that they are objects worthy of study.” In doing so, she challenges the common binary of Indian boarding school history which argues that students either lost or preserved their Indigenous identity. She uses examples from the Indian school press to illuminate the debates and intricacies that a rising generation of Indian boarding school students and graduates faced.
Although the sources that span from the late 19th century to the early 20th century are from some of the most studied schools in boarding school history, one of the book’s great strengths is how it features diverse and unknown Native writers. For example, in 1896, Alonzo Lee, a Hampton student from the Eastern Band of Cherokee, critiqued how “the government is helping the Indians up with one hand and down with the other.” Because boarding schools gathered Indian students from different tribal nations, the schools’ writings expose readers to an array of perspectives, experiences, stories, and oral traditions.
The book could benefit from a reframing of its organization and transitions. The first section highlights “writings of boarding school students,” which Emery arranges by writing formats with subcategories of the student authors. The second part consists of writings from “Native American public intellectuals,” which Emery organizes by author. Some of the boarding school students were also “public intellectuals,” which complicates the author’s categorization. While the writings stand for themselves, Emery’s decisions to present them in this order and within this framework affect how readers understand these texts. Emery provides a brief biography of each author, but the context and authorship of the pieces could be developed and interconnected more thoroughly throughout the book.
This invaluable collection of Native American writings from the turn of the 20th century amplifies Indian voices and experiences during one of the most transitional periods for Indigenous communities in North America. Featured student writer Mary North noted how letters from her Arapaho family “would say push hard and learn all you can.” These writings offer a lens to the humanity, creativity, and intellectualism of boarding school students who navigated many issues, cultures, and settings, while representing their peoples and futures.
Farina King, PhD (Diné), is an assistant professor of history at Northeastern State University and author of The Earth Memory Compass: Diné Landscapes and Education in the Twentieth Century.







Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.