One Voice: Why Acting as a Unit Is Vital for TCU Boards

Volume 34, No. 1 - Fall 2022

Working as a unit is a longstanding tenet of good college governance, yet much easier said than done. More often than not, the governing boards of tribal colleges and universities (TCUs), as well as those of non-Native colleges, struggle to work together communally to create culturally sensitive policies and goals that provide direction and vision for their respective institutions. Sometimes the difficulty comes from miscommunication or minimal communication with the community itself and sometimes from a tribal council’s lack of understanding regarding the true nature of college trustees’ bylaws and standards to act as a unit. Few tribal councils that appoint governing board members (sometimes called trustees, regents, or directors) truly understand that board members must cohere as a group and maintain allegiance, not just to their local community, but to the college and especially to students rather than the political entities that appointed them (Archambault & Allen, 2002).

At a recent governance leadership training with about 60 TCU trustees and presidents in Las Vegas, it was discovered through various exercises, activities, and assessments, that they were not “all on the same page” on some issues. Acting as a unit, in practice, means digging deeper into trustees’ perceptions of their roles and their connections and relationships with their tribal communities, among themselves, and, most importantly, with the college president.

To be truly effective, while generally representing their tribal communities, TCU trustees are required to focus on student success and the future growth and development of their tribal college or university, not personnel issues and the day-to-day management of the college. Trustees need to learn to act as a unit to be effective. This means fostering a solid relationship with the college president, keeping board votes confidential as needed, and getting along well with other trustees despite differences of opinion. Speaking with “one voice” is a cardinal rule of appropriate board behavior; other than the board chair, a single trustee cannot speak for the board. Alone, a single trustee has no authority; only as part of a unified board can trustees exert their power. When a “rogue” trustee goes off script, the teamwork of the board and service to the college is broken, impacting the stability, reliability, and image of the institution.

Relationship with the College President

The importance of boards having a healthy and collaborative relationship with their college president cannot be understated. A strong leadership bond with the board is the basis of a college administration’s ability to move forward in unison to foster greater student success and institutional effectiveness.

Significantly, board members display respect and trust to each other and to the president in all meetings and activities, both public and private. The president and trustees work in concert with each other and value the other’s roles, responsibilities, and boundaries to carry out the mission of the college. A board of trustees and the college president focus on the “big picture” for the well-being and development of the institution; they scope out the impact of the present on the future of the college, the students, and the community at large.  In collaboration with the president and keeping the college’s mission and core values in mind, an effective governing board approves the college’s strategic direction and supports and holds the president accountable for its implementation. 

Stability is one of the most important factors for regional accrediting bodies who assess the college’s governance. In addition to having a sufficient budget, getting along well with the board is one of the most significant factors for a strong, effective college leader. Presidents often cite dissension with their board as a primary reason that they move on or retire. All TCU governing boards have a major responsibility to support their college presidents especially when they are engaging with the community. All board members have a strong responsibility to advocate for their colleges and for their college president in their respective communities.

Relationships Among Board Members

After a discussion of board unity at the recent institute in Las Vegas, a longtime board member commented privately to me that much of the disunity had to do with dissension among board members themselves. Hard personal feelings often got in the way of the board’s harmony, which is so important to be effective as a unit.  Some members were appointed, not because of their interest in students and the college, but rather to undermine the current college leadership, or to promote a particular district or region’s point of view, or to exercise a personal vendetta. In other words, there were some board members with personal and political agendas that had little to do with what should be the primary focus of the board’s work—student success.

Most board members, however, came to the institute with a full heart and mind to learn to become more unified as a board. They demonstrated this unity by actively engaging with their board colleagues during work sessions. Indeed, those boards with full board and president attendance rated the materials and activities more highly than those with only partial or minimal attendance. Cohesion, collaboration, and lively open discussion were fostered over the two days of training activities, helping to develop board unity.

Boards have a responsibility to create a positive, respectful climate, and individual trustees should act accordingly. High-performing boards follow their bylaws and codes of conduct and adhere to the highest principles and standards of exemplary behavior, which include collegiality, confidentiality, and integrity. Effective boards know the difference between governing at the policy level rather than interfering with college business or micromanaging. Each year, boards should be reminded to review and update their bylaws and codes of conduct to refresh standards of behavior, especially for the benefit of newer trustees.

Relationship with the Tribal Council and Community

Boards of Trustees have a special role to play in the larger community. Because individual trustees were appointed by the tribal council to represent a particular region or agency, many trustees feel their allegiance is fractured. However, once on the governing board, their allegiance and focus need to be on students and the health and development of the college. Confidentiality regarding certain board business is paramount, particularly in executive sessions and regarding personnel issues. The board has one employee—the college president—and trustees must act ethically and avoid pressuring the president regarding hiring (or firing) family or friends. In fact, other than setting up the standards for the college’s personnel policies, the board should avoid even questioning the administration why someone was fired or hired. It is not their role; it is the administration’s role.

Instead, boards should keep focus at the policy level, not the day-to day management of the college. During public board meetings, community members may speak out in limited, allotted open comment times, but board members need to be reminded not to respond individually. The board chair may respond to close or open comment sessions when the time limit is reached so that they can get on with official board business.

Such decorum is particularly important when personnel issues are made public. Acting as a unit to not respond to such issues is critically important to protect the board, the college president, the students, the college itself, and ultimately the community. Tribal colleges are often small entities in small communities, and any public action by the board needs to demonstrate support of the college administration and not undercut the board’s and president’s trust. Trusting the president means there is good reason for their administrative action. In most cases, if the board has set in motion strong personnel policies, the president can ensure that the college administration has implemented those policies. That is all the board needs to know, otherwise they can be faulted for micromanagement.

Acting as a Unit

A single trustee has no authority; it is only as part of the board that a trustee’s power functions. Acting as a unit propels authority and action. It can be very difficult for many board members, but high-functioning boards maintain the standards and bylaws to serve their colleges. Nevertheless, governing boards often struggle with their unity. While differences in opinion are commonplace, how they are handled is of paramount importance. “To lead is to serve,” states Robert Martin, president of the Institute of American Indian Arts (Martin, 2022). Servant leadership for the benefit of students is critical for boards as well as presidents.

Most importantly, effective boards act as a unit when making board decisions. Developing, adopting, implementing, and monitoring outcome-oriented policy goals are among the most important contributions a board can make to its community and college. While the vision and mission are broad statements, policy goals define institutional outcomes and delineate the precise impact the college will have in mission areas, including access, completion, transfer, workforce development, diversity, equity, inclusion, skills development, and economic mobility. These policy goals emphasize the college’s responsibility and value to its community. As long as tribal governing boards stay at the policy level and act with “one voice,” they are doing their job.

Norma W. Goldstein, PhD, the former director of trustee education at the Association of Community College Trustees (ACCT), currently consults for ACCT, the American Indian Higher Education Consortium, and individual TCUs.

References

Archambault, D., & Allen, T. (2002).  Politics and the Presidency: Tribal College Presidents Share Their Thoughts. Tribal College: Journal of American Indian Higher Education, 13(4), 14-19. Retrieved from https://tribalcollegejournal.org/politics-presidency-tribal-college-presidents-share-thoughts/

Association of Community College Trustees. (n.d.). Board Roles and Responsibilities: An Overview. Retrieved from https://www.acct.org/page/board-roles-responsibilities-overview

Martin, R. (2022). To Lead Is to Serve. Tribal College: Journal of American Indian Higher Education, 33(3), 24-27. Retrieved from https://tribalcollegejournal.org/to-lead-is-to-serve/


Leave a Reply