Native American Students Define Factors for Success

Volume 7, No. 4 - Spring 1996

Introduction

Despite federal efforts to assimilate Native Americans, to terminate their nations, and even to exterminate them, they have tenaciously and sometimes perilously held on to their distinct ways of life (Campbell, 1992). Native American students throughout the United States have experienced school failure in educational systems that are organized, administered, and controlled by members of a predominately white society. Problems arise when Native American students try to maintain their cultural customs and values in educational systems that do not recognize the customs and values of the Native American culture. We ask Native American students to walk in both worlds, maintaining their belief systems while meeting the expectations of white society; thus, Native American students frequently fail in predominately white educational institutions.

Educational failure is regarded by white Americans as the natural consequence of the minority group’s inherent inferiority, which sometimes leads to blaming the minority for failure. This victim-blaming is legitimized by pointing at high rates of alcohol abuse, poor hygiene, and lack of middle-class child-rearing practices, all of which are viewed as manifestations of the minority group’s deficiency. The process of blaming the minority group for its failure effectively screens from critical scrutiny the way in which the educational system causes school failure among minority students (Cummins, 1992).

Failure, however, may not be defined for Native Americans as it is for white Americans. Anglo American students may see failure as a low grade, not being at the top of the class, or not having enough money to be one of the social elite. Native American students on the other hand may see failure as not being attentive enough to family values or practicing family customs; consequently, they may choose to fail in school in order to be successful in demonstrating family values. Webster and Garrod (1990) found an inner conflict within several Native American students who did not want to leave family to continue their education for fear of offending parents by rejecting traditional ways; yet not attending school also meant losing an opportunity. Failure is in the eyes of the beholder.

Rarely do we read about the educational successes of Native American students. Too often we get bogged down with negative aspects and overlook positive experiences. We forget there are many Native American students who work very hard to obtain an education and are successful individuals. Many examples exist of those who leave the reservation for the first time to live on a university campus, support a family of five, carry a full-time credit load, and are very successful!

The purpose for this article is to consider some possible reasons why Native American students at a predominately white university have been successful students. In this paper, we will describe how Native American students, who are participants in a Native American Secondary Teacher Education Program, have learned to accommodate their cultural needs within a Caucasian higher education institution. First, we will briefly explain the Native American Secondary Teacher Education Program, then share student perceptions of their own success as participants in the program. Finally, recommendations will be made for similar educational programs.

Native American Secondary Teacher Education Program

In late fall 1993, the United States Department of Education approved a three-year grant proposal for a Native American Secondary Teacher Education Program at North Dakota State University, a land grant institution in North Dakota. The purpose of the project is to prepare Native Americans to become teachers in reservation schools. The North Dakota State University office for multi-cultural students reports a Native American population of approximately .16 percent and a total minority population of 4.8 percent. The three-year project provides tuition waivers, a book allowance of $150 per semester, and a living stipend of $375 per month for 15 program participants. Program participants were to have an Associate of Arts degree from one of the North Dakota tribal colleges, a 2.50 GPA for admission to teacher education, evidence of being an enrolled tribal member, and the desire to become a secondary teacher.

The original program participants were selected by the project director and the academic deans of the North Dakota Tribal Colleges. Fifteen program participants were selected; nine began classes fall semester 1994. Two more students joined the program at the onset of the spring semester 1995. From the eleven 1994-1995 program participants, one student decided not to return for personal family reasons; one withdrew herself because of a low grade point average as well as “needing some time out”; and two students were withdrawn from the program because of low grade point averages.

Ten students began fall semester 1995 classes; seven of those are returning students.  Of the seven returning students, five are married with children (two are husband and wife), and the remaining two students are single with no dependents. Five of the students would be considered nontraditional age students.

Finding success

During their first year at North Dakota State University, the Native American students, much to their own credit, experienced many successes. This can be attributed to their ability to “walk in both worlds,” balancing cultural values with the rules of white society. Native students may not come to school with the same expectations for success as their non-Native peers (Tharp & Yamauchi, 1994); their perception of success does not necessarily align with the non-Native American student. Many students in the program expected to be treated like other students in classes, but that was not always the case. Native students were faced with discrimination in some classes and on campus. For example, students encountered what they perceived to be racist comments against Native Americans in a few of their classes and in some instances felt they made the class instructor feel uncomfortable because they were Native American students.

Students attributed their success to family support, former tribal college experiences, a program peer group, mentors, and university professors. After reflecting on their experiences, the majority of students indicated two key motivators of success: family support and mentoring. Several students have also attributed determination to obtain an education and keeping themselves focused on their education as important aspects to success. One student stated, “There have been and probably will continue to be obstacles of one kind or another; those obstacles have made me stronger and have increased my desire to strive harder, finish my degree, and be somebody.”

Family Support

Only recently have researchers looked at family and other personal factors that contribute to American Indian academic success (Davis, 1992). It seems that one indicator of student success is having a spouse or a family member who has encountered positive educational experiences and/or earned a college degree. One program participant, whose husband is a graduate student and physical education teacher, referred to her husband as, “a role model and source of support and encouragement.”  Another student explained, “Last year my relatives back home kept telling me that staying in school would be worth it.”  She continued to say, “All this support helped me to believe in myself.”

Students who began the program without family support either relocated their family to be with them or withdrew from the program. One student, who had a very successful academic year, returned to the reservation at year end to supervise and care for children at home. It is obvious that Native American students in this program have a very strong sense of family values and commitment. During a discussion about family, a student commented, “Even though I have long desired to get an education and become a teacher, if anything happened to a family member, I would leave in a second to be at home with them.”

During the program recruitment process, 72 possible candidates who desired to  become teachers were interviewed. The majority of those who met the program entrance criteria declined to continue because of family commitments. Dilemmas experienced by students ranged from feeling responsible for aged and ill parents, to keeping the family nucleus as stable as possible. The sense of family values held by the Native American students demonstrates a kind of success lacking in today’s society.  We often hear and read about the lack of family values in today’s society; perhaps we should seriously consider family values within the Native American culture as a role model.

One student interviewed for the program decided not to continue because she was responsible for caring for her preschool age son and ill father. She was afraid if she pursued her education dream, her father would not be properly taken care of and they would lose the family home. In yet another situation, a student with two young, school age children began fall classes, but two weeks later the student’s father developed cancer. Initially, the student attended her morning classes and then drove to a hospital located 75 miles away to be with her ailing father, returning to campus at the end of the day. After a month the student dropped out of school.

Mentoring

One intention of the project director at the onset was to ensure that students had at least one individual to contact for whatever reason. After traveling to the tribal colleges and talking with students, it became evident that students would need guidance and support from someone on campus in order to experience a successful transition to the university. At North Dakota State University, students cannot go to one office to take care of registration, financial aid, housing, parking stickers, and receive their books as they are often able to do at the tribal college. Those early semester tasks all take place in long lines, at different offices, on different floors, and in different buildings. In addition to those tasks, many students were concerned about day care, adjusting the family unit, and finding time to work as well as study.

Students need a contact person to find out where to go for what and how to get there. They need someone tell them, “Yes, you can do this!”  The program director and program coordinator try to fill those very large shoes. As the program has progressed, it is obvious that students feel very comfortable about going to either the director’s or coordinator’s office to discuss a concern, ask a question, or just check in. Additionally, students have felt secure enough to call the project director at home to inquire about an assignment or discuss whatever the student feels a need to discuss. For example, one Sunday morning a student called to discuss the philosophical base of a class assignment. It is also just as likely that a student will call to discuss a disagreement with a friend. While many of these examples are time consuming, all are very worthwhile uses of the mentor’s time.

Tribal College Experience

Some evidence exists that social integration is instrumental in decisions to persist or withdraw from college, although it may not be as strong a factor as academic integration. Some researchers have found that minority students at predominately white campuses often face overwhelming adjustment challenges (Voala, 1993); thus, the foundation Native American students build at tribal colleges is very important when making the transition to a university. The student participants in this program all had tribal college experiences and agreed that it was a valuable experience in making the transition.

The tribal colleges in North Dakota are two year institutions which offer associate of arts, associate of science, and associate of applied science degrees.  Experiences at the tribal colleges allowed students an opportunity to build the self-confidence needed to transfer to a larger institution. One student felt she had a very positive experience at Little Hoop Community College because the enrollment was small enough so teachers could allow more time with individual students. A Fort Berthold Community College student concurred by saying, “Individual involvement of instructors and staff was an asset.”  Tribal colleges afford students the opportunity to build the self-confidence needed to move forward.

Program Peer Group

The program participants met as a group every other week during the school year to discuss issues and concerns or simply talk about what was happening in each of their lives.  Some participants were very willing to demonstrate leadership during the group sessions while others sat back and followed the flow. Whether for friendship or as a means of survival, program participants in many cases formed bonds; students reached out to one another or to other groups on campus. Some students have found companionship particularly on athletic teams or being involved with the Native American Student Association, drumming groups, or local Native American programs.

Group meetings provided an opportunity for students to discuss concerns and successes.  Program participants as a group have perhaps filled the void that students feel during their classroom experience on a predominately white university campus. Students had the opportunity during those meetings to express their feelings about the racism they felt in classes and on campus in general. The atmosphere was open for student expression about racism and discrimination, opinions that probably would have benefitted all students had these discussions taken place in the classroom. In the process of empowering Native American students, it should be remembered that the objective is not to have students change their cultural beliefs and behaviors but to help them adapt to specific situations and acquire coping skills (Nel, 1994).

Professors’ role

The sense of alienation for non-white students should be a matter of concern for all academic institutions. An academic institution can promote success by providing Native American students with a non-threatening and accepting environment. Judging Native American students by white, middle class standards is inappropriate, and the classroom teacher must strive to understand and value Native students and their culture in order to make informed evaluations. It is not necessary for Native American students to give up their cultural attachment to achieve academically (Davis, 1992).

To be the only Native American in many classes can be an unnerving experience for a student, especially if she or he is unclear about teacher or peer expectations. Teachers can play an important role in reducing the sense of alienation that so many culturally different students suffer. Research literature indicates a high correlation between successful academic performance of minority students and teachers’ sensitivity, knowledge of cultures, and application of cultural information (Banks, 1987; Campbell & Farrell, 1985; Gollnick & Chinn, 1986).

One student commented about an education course professor, “She made me feel that I could do well; I attribute much of my success to the confidence that she helped me to build.”  Good teaching requires that teachers understand and respect the individuality of all students. Neither appreciation nor respect are possible without knowing the students’ cultural and environmental backgrounds (Garcia & Ahler, 1992). Students reported that developing a rapport with professors was important. About one food and nutrition professor a student commented, “She lets you know what is expected with no ifs, ands, or buts, and this was helpful because you always know where you stand.”

Summary

The goal of the university is to produce productive, knowledgeable, middle-class white American citizens; consequently, we in higher education often make the erroneous assumption that ethnic students desire educational experiences identical with that desired by white students (Tate & Schwartz, 1993). Student failure may be viewed differently from culture to culture; success for one may not be success for another. We believe the Native American students in the Native American Secondary Teacher Education Program have been successful. In a sense, even those few students not returning at this time are successful because the rest of us have gained from the experience of their presence.

Family support, mentoring, former tribal college experiences, a program peer group, and caring university professors all assist in student success, but family support has bridged the road to success the most. Family support is invaluable to Native American students because of the value students place on their family structure and relationships. In this program the project director and project coordinator have been mentors and advisors to students, yet mentoring is also present in the work of the administrators and faculty at the tribal colleges. The program participants themselves frequently act as mentors whether they realize it or not, and university professors have the opportunity to act as mentors as well as role models. It is vital that students have a caring connection to the university; there must be someone students are comfortable with and trust enough to ask their questions or to voice their concerns.

Recommendations

This manuscript describes reasons for successes of Native American students at a predominately white university. The number of program participants is small and could hardly be generalized to a large Native population. Additionally, students in this program represent several different tribes, and what is true about the culture of one tribe is not necessarily true of another tribe. There is little research, especially regarding positive findings, about post-secondary experiences of Native American students. In response to the literature and based on our experiences we offer the following recommendations to similar programs created to prepare Native American Secondary Teachers for schools hosting a major Native American population.

  1. It is important for post-secondary student retention to foster and if possible enhance family support for students. If students are not content or happy at home, obstacles on campus and in the classroom become much greater.
  2. There must be someone at the university who is familiar with the workings of the financial aid and housing offices, computer resources, library, curriculum, and even things which may seem simple like parking restrictions. When students transfer from a Native American institution which ranges in population from 200 to 500 students to a predominately white institution of approximately 10,000 students, Native American students will naturally experience a little cultural shock and feel a little overwhelmed by the enormity. Someone must be there to assist students in becoming acclimated to the new environment.

Like most students, Native American students enter the university to be successes, not failures. Additionally, the non-Native student is likely to gain a greater understanding of the Native American culture and thus have a richer educational experience.

Terri L. Wenzlaff is the director of the Native American Secondary Teacher Education Program and Assistant Professor in Teacher Education at North Dakota State University. She was formerly a high school principal and public school teacher in Wyoming.

Anne Biewer is the coordinator of the Native American Secondary Teacher Education Program and graduate assistant in Teacher Education at North Dakota State University. She was formerly a teacher at a Native American Boarding School in Wahpeton, North Dakota.

References

Banks, K. (1987). Multiethnic education. Boston:  Allyn and Bacon.

Bryan, W. (1985). Montana’s Indians: Yesterday and Today. (p. 90). Helena: Montana Magazine.

Campbell, B. N. (1992). Foreword. In J. Reyhner, (Ed.). Teaching American Indian students. (pp. vii). Norman, OK:  University of Oklahoma Press.

Campbell, R., & Farrell, R. (1985). The identification of competencies for multicultural teacher education. The Negro Educational Review, 35, 137-144.

Cummins, J. (1992). The empowerment of Indian students. In J. Reyhner, (Ed.). Teaching American Indian students. (pp. vii). Norman, OK:  University of Oklahoma Press.

Davis, J. (1992). Factors contributing to post-secondary achievement of American Indians. Tribal College Journal, 4(2), 24-30.

Garcia, R. L. & Goldenstein Ahler, J. (1992). Indian education:  Assumptions, ideologies, strategies.  In J. Reyhner, (Ed.). Teaching American Indian Students.  (pp. 13). Norman, OK:  University of Oklahoma Press.

Gollnick, D., & Chinn, P. (1986). Multicultural Education in a Pluralistic Society. Columbus: Merrill.

Nel, J. (1994). Preventing school failure: The Native American child. Clearing House, 67(3), 169-174.

Tate, D. S. & Schwartz, C. L. (1993). Increasing the retention of American Indian students in professional programs in higher education. Journal of American Indian Education, 33(1), 21-31.

Tharp, R. G. & Yamauchi, L. A. (1994). Effective instructional conversation in Native American classrooms. Educational Practice Report, (pp. 11). Washington, DC:  Office of Educational Research and Improvement.

Voala, L. (1993). Native students in a community college:  Perceptions of upgrading career students. Canadian Journal of Native Education, 20(1), 77-86.

Webster, J. B. & Garrod, A. (1990). Promoting attitude change toward Native American Indians through a graduate course in adolescent development. Canadian Journal of Native Education, 17(1), 15-22.


Leave a Reply