Menominee and Maya: Indigenous cultures and their forests inspire and support each other

Volume 17, No. 2 - Winter 2005
MENOMINEE CHILDREN PLANTING TREES

TREES FOR TOMORROW. For generations, Menominee families have helped the tribe to replant trees, learning the sustainability tradition at an early age. Photos courtesy of Menominee Tribal Enterprises Forestry.

When entering the Menominee Indian Reservation in northeastern Wisconsin, everyone notices how the forest rises up from the surrounding farmland. The road to Keshena (a village on the southern end of reservation) stretches under the hot sun, past wire fences and grassy fields, and into the cool and scented forest of these indigenous people.

Visitors are awestruck by the beauty, the simplicity, and the sense of an ancient presence in this place.

A delegation of scholars and forest rangers from Belize, Central America, visited the College of Menominee Nation (CMN, Keshena, WI) and its Sustainable Development Institute in June 2005. They cemented a partnership between CMN and Galen University of San Ignacio, Belize.

Dr. Verna Fowler (Menominee), president of CMN, and Dr. Nancy Adamson, vice president of Galen U, signed an agreement to foster collaborative research in sustainable development and to assist the Maya and Garifuna (both indigenous people of Central America) in their sustainable development projects. The agreement also creates faculty and student exchanges between the two institutions.

Two forest rangers, Saleem Chan and Anasario Cal, represented the Sarstoosh-Temash Institute for Indigenous Management (SATIIM), a non-profit organization for Mayan communities in southern Belize. Chan and Cal came to learn more about the Menominee’s sustainable forestry practices.

Historically, indigenous people usually lived in a sustainable economy, making a living from the land in a way that didn’t destroy the ecosystem. Today, the market economy is driven by the demands of consumers, and supplying their demands is taking a toll on the environment.

The world is beginning to see the bottom of crude oil wells as geologists search the oceans for more oil. The winds are shifting from their predictable paths. Greenhouse gases are warming the climate. Ice caps are melting. Water levels are rising in some places and disappearing in other places.

“The issues of sustainable development are becoming more and more pressing. Everywhere we turn today, we’re faced with issues about the world and how we’re developing. Are we going to destroy (the Earth), or are we going to sustain what we have into the future?” Adamson asks.

Marion Cayetano (Garifuna descent), vice president for planning at Galen U, says the idea of “man over the Earth” is a notion of control and destroy, a notion that has developed relatively recently, in the last few hundred years.

“I don’t think that’s a good world view. We can’t protect the environment over and above the benefit of humans. Similarly, I don’t think we should protect humans over and above the protection of the environment. These things have to benefit from each other,” Cayetano says. “The best of kind of development is one that is conscious of the environment and of people,” he adds.

Menominee Balance Preservation, People

The Menominee are in a unique position to model and teach the world how to live harmoniously with their environment. The CMN Sustainable Development Institute bases its mission and research upon the experiences of the Menominee to balance preservation of their forest with the needs of their people, the pressures of modern society, politics, and technology.

Adamson says the Menominee have given hope to the indigenous people of Central America for recovery of their languages, culture, and traditions as well as their land and their sovereign powers.

The people of Belize are a mixed population of Garifuna Indians, Maya, and other indigenous peoples living alongside Asians, Europeans, and Africans (many of them descendants of Africans shipwrecked there while being transported to slave markets in the United States).

They have a tropical paradise, which they want to keep, while finding a way for their communities to thrive. Developing a sustainable economy is the best way for them to do both.

“Sustainable yield” foresting is the pride of the Menominee people. For well over a century, they have kept their forest practically pristine while harvesting timber and other raw resources for sale.

Under the guidance of Chief Oshkosh, the tribe chose this forest as their reservation in the May 12, 1854, treaty, according to David Grignon (Menominee), director of the Menominee Historic Preservation Office.

“This is a pine and hardwood forest. It wasn’t valuable to white settlers at the time,” Grignon says. “But it became very valuable to the Menominee people,” he adds.

When the settlers needed timber to build their houses, railroads, and cities, they looked again at the Menominee Reservation. “Chief Oshkosh said, ‘There must be a way to harvest timber without cutting it all down,’” according to Grignon.

The chief instructed the people to start on one side of the land and cut what needed to be cut: “By the time we get to the other side, it will be time to start over again.” This practice brought about their concept of sustainable yield, Grignon added.

Beginning in the 1860s the tribe’s timber harvests created jobs and contributed to their economic development. They logged the dead and downed logs and sent their harvest down-river to markets in the settlements and emerging cities. (The Menominee Logging Museum preserves seven log buildings and more than 20,000 artifacts from the logging industry of that time. The museum’s holdings are one of the most complete collections of logging artifacts in the nation.)

In the early 1900s, the U.S. Forest Service built a sawmill in Neopit, a village on the northern border of the reservation. Revenues from their forest and the sawmill created jobs and supported a hospital, a clinic, schools, and social programs for the Menominee people, according to Grignon.

However, their programs and thriving businesses were dismantled after the Menominee Termination Act (Public Law 83-399) was enacted by Congress in 1954. The federal approach to American Indians during this era was terminating tribal governments and their special relationship with the federal government and privatizing their assets, including their land.

As a result of termination, the Menominee people fell from self-sufficiency and modest prosperity into poverty and despair. Many of the Menominee interpreted termination as meaning they were no longer “Indians,” and they suffered from a loss of identity and loss of cultural pride. The community became one of the poorest in Wisconsin.

Rights Restoration Inspires Maya

Remarkably, the Menominee won restoration of their sovereignty after 19 years of economic hardship and fighting for their indigenous rights. In December 1973, President Richard Nixon signed the Menominee Restoration Act. This law provided full federal recognition of the Menominee and the return of their reservation lands and assets.

“The Maya are inspired by seeing other people successful in taking on a huge government like the United States,” Adamson says.

BELIZE FOREST RANGERS

TAKING THE LONG VIEW. Belize forest rangers Seleem Chan and Anasario Cal visit the world-famous Menominee forest with CMN graduate Chris Caldwell. Photo by D. Kakkak CMN

The country of Belize used to be British Honduras, a colony of Britain. After winning its independence in 1981, the country struggled to recover from colonialism. The British had cut down the forests, taking out all the mahogany and other old-growth, hardwood trees. The British also had tried to impose their culture upon the indigenous people of Central America, according to Adamson.

Consequently the Mayan people, who have been there for hundreds and hundreds of years, feel a kinship with the Menominee. They share many of the same issues — treaties, land claims, recognition as a sovereign nation, and defining their relationship with the government, she says.

“To have your status taken away, and then to be restored, to have that kind of victory… and to see that people, not just Menominee, but many of the Native American cultures are saving their languages, and their children are learning them… that has given hope to the Maya. There are just so many lessons and ideas to be learned and goals to be adapted (from the Native people here),” Adamson says.

Belize is still heavily forested. “When the British took out most of the hardwoods, they did not replant,” she says. Nevertheless, there are still a lot of trees in the forest there. “So thinking about how to preserve it is important,” Adamson says.

The tropical forest of Belize and the rain forest it borders are going to be important in the future for medicine. Scientists are finding out about the traditional remedies of the indigenous people. Preserving their tropical forest and learning to manage a sustainable yield of their plants, trees, and other resources will help the people create a sustainable economy.

Forest Gardening Reaps Hope

The Menominee are recognized internationally as champions of sustainable economic development. They were the first people awarded the “United Nations Award for Sustainable Development” in 1995. A year later, they also received the “United States Presidential Award for Sustainable Development.” Most people don’t realize that the Menominee forest has been harvested 2.5 times because it still looks natural and pristine.

The Maya call it “forest gardening,” according to Adamson. “So, you don’t just let a forest grow wild and anything happens. But, just like we would tend a vegetable garden, they tend the forest as a garden,” she says.

When people are working and living in a forest, it becomes a part of their life. They tend it because they depend on it for food, for recreation, for medicine, and for ritual. The forest has so many parts.

“The Maya harvest in a sustainable way. They don’t cut everything down at once. They replant. They have a plan, as the Menominee do here,” Adamson says.

During the agreement signing, CMN President Fowler said the poverty and living conditions that she saw during her January 2005 visit to Belize reminded her of her childhood on the reservation. “I look back at our own village of Neopit, and sure it was a sweet and nice place, but still there was tremendous poverty,” she said.

Knowing how much conditions have improved for her own people during her lifetime gives her hope. “The people of Belize have a bright future when you look at what the Menominee people have been through.”

She looks forward to opportunities for CMN students to study in Belize and gain world experience from another culture and another country. “Come back with new ideas that can further advance the Menominee tribe,” she told the students at the ceremony.

Sherrole Benton (Oneida/Ojibwe) is a freelance journalist who writes about Native American issues. She has journalism awards from the Native American Journalist Association and the Howard Simons Fund for American Indian Journalists. For more information about the CMN Sustainable Development Institute, see www.menominee.edu/sdi/home1.htm.


One Man’s Vision of the Forest’s Future

One graduate of the College of Menominee Nation (CMN) has a vision for the future of sustainability in Wisconsin. A tribal member, Chris Caldwell grew up in Neopit, a village on the northern end of the Menominee Reservation.

After graduating from CMN in 2001 with an Associate of Arts & Science Degree in Sustainable Development, Caldwell transferred to the University of Wisconsin in Madison, WI, and earned a Bachelor of Science Degree in Natural Resources.

When Caldwell later worked at the USDA Forest Products Lab, he saw parallels between his tribal heritage and the new forest research. “I had only looked at managing the trees when they were standing in the forest. One thing they were researching in the lab was the forest products we can get from those trees. (This way) we sustain those trees by using every little bit that we can, instead of just taking the good parts and throwing the rest away,” Caldwell says.

Instead of just selling the raw material, the Menominee are finding ways to further process their wood. “The Menominee sawmill now has a value-added area where they’re making tongue-and-groove board. That’s a step in the right direction,” he says.

Caldwell wants to return to the reservation and help research and develop more value-added products. He has specific ideas of how to utilize a tree with little market value, hemlock. “Each step you add in processing wood, you’re making it that much more of a valuable product,” Caldwell says.

He felt the vision at the USDA lab demonstrated the same vision as the Menominee Forest Management Plan. “It’s like looking toward the future knowing that your resources aren’t infinite,” he adds. — SB


Leave a Reply