Leadership Reflections of Women Tribal College Presidents

Volume 9, No. 3 - Winter 1997-98

Abstract

This article is taken from a qualitative research study on the leadership roles of four American Indian women tribal college leaders: Dr. Janine Pease-Pretty On Top, president of Little Big Horn College, Crow Agency, Mont.; Dr. Verna Fowler, president of the College of the Menominee Nation, Keshena, Wis.; Tanya Ward, president of Cheyenne River Community College, Eagle Butte, S.D.; and Margarett Perez, vice president of Fort Peck Community College, Poplar, Mont. (former president of Fort Belknap College, Harlem, Mont.). The study, “Leadership Roles of American Indian Women Tribal College Presidents,” was conducted between August 1996 and June 1987. It examined the experiences of the participants as tribal college presidents and how they promoted success for their students, faculty, and institutions.

Introduction

Questions for the study focused on the presidents’ leadership roles, their visions for the colleges, the behaviors and strategies they used, and their perceptions and insights on leadership. The goal was to identify and characterize the presidents’ leadership roles and experiences and to gain an understanding of how they promoted success for their students, faculty, and institutions. This article focuses on their perceptions and insights on leadership and how their leadership style reflects their culture.

At the time of my interviews, Dr. Janine Pease-Pretty On Top, founding president of Little Big Horn College, was in her 15th year as president. Chartered in 1980 and accredited in 1990, the college served 268 students in the fall semester 1996. Degrees in vocational education and associate of arts were offered.

Dr. Verna Fowler, founding president of the College of the Menominee Nation, was in her fifth year as president. The college held candidacy status for accreditation and served 491 students in the 1994-95 school year. Degrees offered were associate of arts and sciences and technical college associate; a pre-college program was also available.

Tanya Ward was in her first year as president of Cheyenne River Community College. The college was chartered in 1973; prior to that it was an extension center. Application for candidacy status was being prepared in the spring of 1997. Enrollment totaled 237 students during the 1996 fall semester; the college offered associate of science and arts degrees.

Margarett Campbell (then Campbell-Perez) was the president of Fort Belknap College for 10 years (1987-1996). The college, chartered in 1984, became accredited in 1987 during Campbell’s term as president. In 1997 she became vice president of the Department of Community Services at Fort Peck Community College.

Procedure

I used an instrumental case study design to describe and characterize the participants’ leadership roles for two primary reasons. First, although bound by time, case study allowed for a detailed examination of the particular role (Stake, 1995; Creswell, 1994). Case study allowed for the women to tell their own stories. Second, the holistic approach of the case study provided an overall view of the complexities of tribal college leadership. In addition, the multi-case design gave the study more depth; the multiple perspectives were critical to understanding both the similarities and differences in the leadership roles. Kerr (1987) asserted that “case studies provide the only resource for understanding what makes achieving women extraordinary and how they overcame barriers they faced” (p.35).

Data included interview transcripts, observations of participants, a research journal, and documents: tribal college catalogs and faculty handbooks, self-study reports, meeting documents, position descriptions, participant dissertations and vitae, journal articles, and photographs. Data collection and analysis occurred simultaneously. Verification strategies included member checks, two forms of triangulation, and an external audit.

Background on women in leadership

In the past, leadership studies were generally studies of men; the overwhelming majority of college presidents were men. Despite a 7 percent increase in the number of women presidents between 1975 and 1995, only 453 of 2,903 institutions (16 percent) had women leaders (ACE, 1995). Independent two-year institutions led with 27 percent (38 of 143) having women in CEO positions. The number of women leaders in tribal colleges, however, was higher.

In 1992, Ambler reported that women presidents led 10 of 28 (39 percent) of the American Indian Higher Education Consortium (AIHEC) member colleges; three served in acting capacities and an eleventh woman president was on leave. In addition to the college presidency, “Women serve[d] the tribal colleges in a variety of other expected and unexpected roles, as vice presidents, deans, vocational education directors, cultural studies teachers, and board members” (p.10). In 1996 the roster of AIHEC member colleges showed that 10 of 31 (32 percent) presidents were women.

The majority of tribal colleges are two-year institutions with characteristics similar to other community colleges; therefore, the number of women presidents in tribal colleges may be related to the similarities in institutional goals, organization, and level of prestige. DiCroce (1993) reported that “two-year colleges appear to be at the forefront in placing women in their presidencies” (p.80). She hypothesized that the higher percentage of women presidents reflects the gender composition of the student body and demonstrates a “strong commitment to the values of open access, diversity, and inclusiveness. On the other hand, the steadily rising number of women presidents in the community college may simply be a result of the institution’s lower hierarchical status in academe” (p.80). Although the reason for the higher percentage of women presidents in tribal colleges is not readily apparent, it is clear that they can provide perspective about the role of women and minorities in higher education leadership. Each of the four presidents in this study is a member of the tribe her college serves.

Tribal college leadership

Since the first tribal college began 30 years ago, tribal college leaders have assumed responsibility for addressing problems that included the lack of proper funding and facilities; political controversies; difficulty recruiting and retaining faculty (both Indian and non-Indian); student concerns such as finances, transportation, and childcare; and problems caused by environmental and weather conditions.

Tribal college leaders also have worked to lower the barriers that separate their institutions from mainstream society. Boyer (1995) described tribal colleges as “institutions that bridge two worlds. They are built on a foundation of tribal culture and values but teach the knowledge of both Indian and non-Indian communities. In this way they are cultural translators, sitting on the fulcrum between two very distinct societies” (p.15). Tribal college presidents control that fulcrum; they are responsible for identifying the direction and setting the course.

Badwound and Tierney (1988) wrote, “The struggle for tribal community colleges is to understand their organizations from their own perspective, as well as that of the dominant society” (p.9). To gain the respect of their communities and colleagues constituents, tribal college leaders must demonstrate appropriate leadership qualities, including wisdom and spirituality. Wisdom is attributed to those “who have consistently demonstrated adherence to Indian values and who possess visionary qualities to lead”; spirituality is “a condition that is neither learned nor certified, but is attained through the workings of a higher power or being” (p.12).

According to information gathered by the Carnegie Foundation, “In the early years the tribal college presidents were frequently people committed to tribal development but with little experience running a college. They tended to view the tribal colleges as tools to help provide economic and social parity with the Anglo community. Increasingly, presidents today are strong leaders with a background in education or administration” (Carnegie, 1989, p.32). Becenti (1995) reported that only three presidents of the 30 AIHEC member institutions were non-Indian.

Fowler (1992) found in her study on tribal college leaders that tribal college leadership had three aspects: leadership in general, the vision, and the leader’s personal characteristics  (p.160). “Leadership in general involved the ability to respect and cooperate with tribal governments and individuals, to delegate, to reflect the values and morals of the tribe, to be accountable, to be knowledgeable, to be consistent, and to be a positive role model. Leadership vision addressed…the ability to communicate direction and clearly portray the vision….The personal characteristics needed by the leader were honesty, fairness, kindness, energy, creativity, thoughtfulness, strong work ethic, strong spirituality, and good health” (p.161).

Becenti (1995) profiled the leadership of five American Indian higher education institution presidents. The participants (four male; one female) enumerated institutional goals that related to stabilizing the financial status of the institution, providing educational opportunities for tribal members, and establishing campus facilities (pp.91-92).

Working with tribal boards comprised of both highly educated individuals and tribal elders with little or no formal education called for presidents to “be competent in complex organizational theory, and at the same time [to] maintain competence in tribal culture, language, and theory” (Becenti, 1995, p.93). Becenti concluded, “The tribal college presidents are the driving forces behind the success of the tribal colleges” (p.98).

Participants’ reflections on leadership

JANINE PEASE PRETTY-ON-TOP

Janine Pease Pretty-on-Top says a leader in the Crow context needs to be a seeker of advice. Photo by Kyle Brehm

The quest to identify leadership “qualities” has led to numerous definitions of leadership, “but no clear and unequivocal understanding exists as to what distinguishes leaders from non-leaders, and perhaps more importantly, what distinguishes effective leaders from ineffective leaders” (Bennis and Nanus, 1985, p.4). For purposes of this study, the participants delineated their own beliefs, perceptions, and insights regarding effective leadership during interviews.

Janine Pease-Pretty On Top: Pretty on Top believes that the institutional mission has to be protected. “I have to see if something fits within the mission of the institution. And I have to always protect the institution.” Good leadership also must have the “discipline to stay within the resources that you have.”

Leading the college is not something that can be done alone, “but I have a central role that I can’t lose sight of.” Leadership is a “process of building consensus.” She consults a cadre of advisors and takes time to consider the action before making decisions. “A leader in the Crow context needs to be a seeker of advice. You don’t always have to use it, but you have it. It broadens your ability.”

VERNA FOWLER

Verna Fowler believes that leadership involves the ability to reflect the values and morals of the tribe.

In Pretty on Top’s estimation, leaders must be perceptive about their effectiveness. “There’s no amount of song and dance that can make people accept you. If they think you are a person of good judgment, they will already know it, and they’re not frivolous. You’ve long earned that respect…it isn’t shallow.” In a tribal community, the reputation of the individual provides the credentials for leadership. According to Pretty on Top, “If people wish to be led by you, they will be.”

Verna Fowler: Fowler described her leadership role: “First and foremost, I see myself as one who has a vision and has a direction worth heading. My job is to persuade the others to follow me in that direction….I have to develop that direction and vision by being in tune to and listening to the faculty and the staff and the community…I have to be able to listen well enough to…fashion that vision that these people can buy into.”         Fowler looks for high standards, high ethics, and a value system in her leaders, all of which she tries to maintain herself. She emphasized the importance of being willing to listen to people.” She believes that the role of an administrator is to enable faculty to provide students with skills to find answers. “You’re not the head dollar, you’re the servant of the faculty because their role is teaching. Our primary mission is teaching.” Sometimes that means Fowler has to “pitch in” and do whatever needs to be done. She does not expect others to do what she is unwilling to do herself.

TAYNA WARD

Tayna Ward prefers that faculty grab the bull by the horns -- right or wrong.

Tanya Ward: Ward believes faculty need to be “empowered” and involved in decision-making so they develop ownership. She delegates responsibility and extends to her faculty the right to make choices with the expectation that they will utilize that prerogative. She prefers that faculty grab “the bull by the horns–right or wrong,” and when appropriate, admit being wrong. “There’s nothing wrong with that.”

Ward does not see her position as glamorous or prestigious: “I view it as being the old work horse to accomplish a big task– get accredited.” Her leadership provides “consistency” and “continuity” for the college. Education, “the salvation of the Indian people,” is a vehicle of improvement. Education enables people to make choices, an ability that comes with knowledge. “It gives you a better understanding of who you are and what you are and what you choose to be. It gives you better choices. That’s what we need out here: The ability to choose what’s right for us.”

Margarett Campbell: Campbell stressed focusing on the college mission. “Everyone has to know the mission, believe in the mission.” Leaders are change agents. “And in order to do that, you need to be open to learning and open to respecting a wide array of values and opinions.”

MARGARETT CAMPBELL

Margarett Campbell says leaders must be open to respecting a wide array of values and opinions. Photo by Kyle Brehm

She believes that participation facilitates change and described her leadership style as “inclusive and participatory. I try to involve a broad base of opinions, values, and expertise.” Individuals need to know they are respected. To weigh someone’s leadership, she suggests looking at whether subordinates feel as if “they’re valued members of the team, feel that their skills and values are respected, and understand and buy into the mission.” Campbell defines leadership as “the ability to enable other people to maximize their skills and energy in a common direction for a common reason.” She wants her leadership to be judged by “how well other people working with me function.”

“One of the key characteristics or factors of leadership is decision-making.” Making decisions means being able to defend those decisions; making decisions also means being able to admit mistakes, and Campbell admits she has made some. “Once you admit you’ve made a mistake, people seem to respect you for that.”

Discussion and conclusions

Leader attributes of tribal college presidents may be as diverse and numerous as the tribes they represent. Consequently, existing leadership theories may not provide the necessary framework to contextualize tribal college leadership. They do, however, provide a foundation for identifying leadership characteristics personified by the four tribal college leaders in this study.

Models of leadership generally have common elements although the terms may differ. They define a leader as one who possesses vision and focuses on mission, serves as a role-model for others, and enables others to take action or perform their roles (Bennis and Nanus, 1985. Kouzes and Posner, 1987). The tribal college leadership studies of Fowler (1992) and Becenti (1996) also emphasized vision and mission as well as working with tribal culture, members, and governments. The style of participants in both tribal college studies was participatory and consultative.

The four leaders in this study emphasized the importance of having a vision and focusing on the tribal college mission. Fowler defined a visionary leader as “one who has a vision and has a direction worth heading.” Listening to others and synthesizing all the data helped her “fashion that vision” so that others endorsed its validity. Ward envisioned a college curriculum that incorporates Lakota thought and philosophy and focused on her vision and goal of achieving candidacy status for Cheyenne River Community College.

Pretty on Top emphasized that vision continues to change, “It’s like climbing to the top of one of the hills in the Big Horns. You climb the hill you see, but when you get there you see another peak.” Campbell stressed the need for everyone in the tribal college to “believe in the mission.”

Because the mission of tribal colleges is to “preserve and protect” the culture and language, tribal culture impacts leadership. To ensure that the focus of the institution remains centered on the mission, tribal college leaders must be knowledgeable about the culture of the local tribe. Tribal membership increases the probability of cultural knowledge and heightens personal credibility.

Badwound and Tierney (1988) stressed the importance of the values–beliefs defined by culture–to tribal college leadership. “The leader in the tribal college is a facilitator and promoter of group values and interests. Instead of maintaining autocratic power by virtue of position, the tribal college leader develops authority by demonstrating competence and allegiance to the values which underlie the organization” (p.13). Sergiovanni (1989) explained, “Leadership acts are expressions of culture. Leadership as cultural expression seeks to build unity and order within an organization” (p.336).

Fowler believes that a leader must have a strong value system and model a sense of pride for others. Campbell believes respect for others is important. Leaders work hard and function well with others; they “enable others to do the same.” Pretty on Top talked about the value of teamwork, utilizing the skills of others, and investing “confidence and faith and the resources” in others.

Pretty on Top gave credit to others for their achievements and the success of Little Big Horn College. “Ownership” and “voice” were words she used to describe the faculty role in decision-making. Fowler emphasized the value of “listening” to others, allowing people “the opportunity to give their viewpoints” and make their own decisions. Ward spoke of her desire to “actively involve the staff” and develop a sense of ownership. Campbell described her leadership style as “inclusive and participatory” and valued a “broad base of opinions, values, and expertise.”

Campbell admired a leader who was able “to make others believe in themselves.” Ward wanted her faculty to feel “empowered” and modeled task accomplishment through hard work like “the old work horse.” In the early days of her college, Pretty on Top’s responsibilities included janitorial duties; Fowler talked about her willingness “to tackle any kind of job” that needed to be done.

The higher percentage of women presidents in tribal colleges as compared to other higher education institutions may be related to cultural factors. Pretty on Top said leadership in education is congruent with the role of woman as care giver and nurturer. Further study may elucidate patterns to develop a theory of leadership specific to American Indian women or tribal college presidents. The purpose of this study, however, was not to build theory; the small number of participants precludes such a possibility. This study gives voice to the participants, enabling them to tell their stories in their own words, revealing their perceptions and insights on leadership.

Pretty on Top, Fowler, Ward, and Campbell indicate the complexity in leadership roles, characteristics, and styles of tribal college presidents. Their insights illustrate that tribal college leadership is not simply an act or a series of acts; it is not merely directing a process; it is not filling a position or playing a role. Tribal college leadership is the embodiment of a lifestyle, an expression of learned patterns of thought and behaviors, values, and beliefs. Culture is the basis of the institution; it formulates the purpose, process, and product. Tribal college leadership is inseparable from culture.

Bernita L. Krumm, assistant professor of educational administration at Texas A & M University-Commerce, received her Ph.D. in Educational Leadership and Higher Education from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln in 1997. She was a faculty member at South Dakota State University, Brookings, S.D. from 1989-1997, and a teacher at Flandreau Indian School, Flandreau, S.D., from 1980-1987.

REFERENCES

Ambler, M. (1992). Women leaders in Indian education. Tribal College Journal, III(4), 10-14.

American Council on Education (ACE). (1995). Women presidents in U.S. colleges and universities. (Pamphlet). Washington, DC:  Office of Women in Higher Education.

Badwound, E., & Tierney, W. G. (1988). Leadership and American Indian values: The tribal college dilemma. Journal of American Indian Education, 28, 9-15.

Becenti, F. D. (1995). Leadership profiles of tribal college presidents (Doctoral dissertation, Colorado State University, 1995).

Bennis, W., & Nanus, B. (1985). Leaders. New York:  Harper and Row.

Boyer, P. (1995). Tribal college of the future. Tribal College Journal, VII(1), 8-17, 45.

Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching. (1989). Tribal colleges: Shaping the future of Native America. Lawrenceville, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Creswell, J. W. (1994). Research design: Qualitative and quantitative approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA:  Sage Publications, Inc.

DiCroce, D. M. (1993). Women and the community college presidency: Challenges and possibilities. New Directions for Community Colleges, 89, 79-88.

Fowler, V. M. (1992). Leadership of American Indian presidents of accredited tribally chartered community colleges (Doctoral dissertation, The University of North Dakota, 1992). Dissertation Abstracts International, 53, DA9312402.

Kerr, B. A. (1987). Smart girls, gifted women. Columbus, OH:  Ohio Psychology Publishing Company.

Kouzes, J. M., & Posner, B. Z. (1987). The leadership challenge. San Francisco: Jossey Bass Publishers.

Sergiovanni, T. J. (19–). Leadership as cultural expression. In J. S. Ott (Ed.), Classic readings in organizational behavior (pp.335-343). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

Stake, R. E. (1995). The art of case study research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc.


Leave a Reply