Implementing More Equitable IPEDS Race / Ethnicity Reporting Standards for Tribal Colleges and Universities

Volume 32, No. 3 - Spring 2021

Introduction

Tribal Colleges and Universities (TCUs) are unique among other higher education institutions, as they have a distinctive dual mission. Like institutions in other sectors, they educate students in preparation for the workforce or further education, but they also address the priorities of their tribal communities. Those priorities can include a wide range of needs such as economic development, reduction of unemployment, and the preservation of Native culture, language, and traditions (IHEP, 2007; Rainie & Stull, 2016). This unique nature of TCUs is already widely recognized by organizations across higher education, including the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES). Under the center’s Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) coding structure, which is based on Carnegie classifications, TCUs have their own distinct classification, even from other “specialized institutions.” Not even other minority-serving institutions (MSIs) are classified separately from the other nine Carnegie classifications used in IPEDS (U.S. Department of Education, 2018a).

In addition to a unique dual mission, the operational and administrative norms of TCUs are also distinct from other institution types, most notably in that the federally recognized tribes that charter most TCUs deal directly with the federal government as sovereign polities. Most TCUs therefore receive no support from a state government, and the resulting reliance on underfunded federal grant programs contributes significantly to the chronic underfunding of these institutions (HLC, 2013; Nelson & Frye, 2016). In addition, existing norms of data collection and use in higher education exacerbate the underfunding of TCUs by obscuring the actual enrollment and financial trends at the institutions. Relatively minor policy changes could lead to a more accurate reflection of TCUs’ enrollment and financial situations. This report specifically addresses NCES’s data reporting practices for TCUs and proposes a policy change that would better equip researchers and policymakers to address inequities in funding. 

Discussion

Large data sets are particularly problematic for Native students in multiple ways, one of which is the difficulty of representing accurate data for small populations (Faircloth, Alcantar, and Stage, 2015). Native Americans make up only 1% of the national undergraduate population and less than 1% of the graduate population. The result is that they are often left out of postsecondary data and research altogether due to small sample size (PNPI, 2018). Since IPEDS collects data in fulfillment of federal mandates and follows up on institutional non-responses, its overall response rate is extremely high, sometimes reaching 100% (U.S. Department of Education, 2017). However, the data set uses self-reported racial/ethnic data. Individuals may self-identify as any group they choose, and the American Indian/Alaska Native categorization is the most inconsistently reported group because of cultural and political complexities, as well as difficulties with multiracial reporting (Faircloth et al., 2015). 

In an effort to better serve Native students and their communities, the Tribally Controlled Colleges and Universities Assistance Act of 1978 (TCU Act), established federal funding to support core operating expenses. However, since it was passed more than four decades ago, the act has never been fully funded. As of 2019, the act authorized $8,000 per Native student, but TCUs actually received only $7,285 (NCAI, 2019). The negative effects of this per-student discrepancy are compounded by IPEDS reporting practices with respect to race/ethnicity. 

TCU Act funding for operating expenses is based on the number of enrolled full-time equivalent Native students at a TCU (Nelson & Frye, 2016). However, not all students at TCUs are Native American, nor are all the Native students at TCUs “beneficiary” students (those for whom the TCU receives TCU Act funding). To qualify for benefits under the TCU Act, an individual must provide proof of tribal membership or status as a biological child of a tribal member (25 U.S.C. § 1801(a)(7), 2017). Because IPEDS uses racial/ethnic data that is self-reported by students, some students who identify as “American Indian or Alaska Native” do not actually meet the requirements and/or do not provide adequate proof of tribal affiliation to receive federal benefits authorized by the TCU Act (McDonald, 2003). These “nonbeneficiary” students constitute a substantial portion of student enrollment at TCUs—16% on average, with the figure at several TCUs exceeding 40% (Nelson & Frye, 2016).

Educating nonbeneficiary students is costly; TCUs receive no federal support to teach non-Native or nonbeneficiary students, nor do they receive state funds that other types of public institutions would receive to teach the same students. The institutions themselves are left shouldering the burden of educating a large number of students for whom they receive no government support and very little tuition. As points of comparison, the average annual tuition at TCUs is only $2,937 (AIHEC, 2019b). Institutions in other sectors generate far more tuition revenue; the following were the average tuition and fees at public institutions during the 2018-2019 academic year, excluding TCUs: two-year, in-district averaged $3,660; four-year, in-state averaged $10,230; four-year, out-of-state averaged $26,290 (College Board, 2019).

At small institutions like TCUs, the effects are magnified. For example, more than a quarter of annual costs at Salish Kootenai College in Montana (which has an FTE of less than 700) have been attributed to educating nonbeneficiary students (Clement, 2009; U.S. Department of Education, 2018b). However, this burden is often overlooked by policymakers who might have the power to help alleviate it because the situation is misrepresented in IEPDS, “the most comprehensive database available on postsecondary institutions” (RTI, 2019, para. 5). As a result, researchers and lawmakers using IPEDS data are basing policy decisions (such as the consideration of utilizing state funds to help support TCUs) on the assumption that TCUs are receiving far more beneficiary funding than they actually do, grossly underestimating their funding needs.

Recommendations

First and foremost, NCES needs to implement a policy requiring numbers of beneficiary versus nonbeneficiary students in its IPEDS data on TCUs. These figures would not even need to replace the self-reported race/ethnicity figures; those can remain in the data system to maintain consistency across institution types and to be utilized in research or policy decisions where they are relevant. That distinction between beneficiary and nonbeneficiary students is unique to TCUs (as they are the only ones receiving TCU Act funding), and it is integral to their operations. In stark contrast to non-TCU institutions of higher education, federal funds constitute the vast majority of revenue at TCUs, averaging just under three quarters of total revenue (Nelson & Frye, 2016). Considering their reliance on federal funds, and that researchers and policymakers do not have access to accurate data, the results could be financially devastating for perpetually underfunded TCUs.

The significance of an accurate data system is emphasized by the entity that leads IPEDS—the Research Triangle Institute. The institute’s website states: “Key to the success of these tools as unbiased resources for students, parents, researchers, and decision-makers is the quality of the data collected, so IPEDS requires the highest standards of objectivity and accuracy” (RTI, 2019, para.4). Therefore, administrators of IPEDS need to add this measure to depict a more truthful, as well as culturally relevant situation of these TCUs. Feasibility should not be a significant obstacle, as all TCUs already update these figures every year in order to receive their federal funds—it is simply a matter of asking for them in data collection. 

Furthermore, IPEDS methods need to become more culturally relevant. Native Americans have faced nearly three centuries of fraught relations with the American education system, in which “[d]ecisions have often been made and implemented without the knowledge or consideration of the values of the native peoples themselves” (IHEP, 2007). Research of tribal communities, including their TCUs, must involve community participation at every phase, including approaches to data collection. Advisory committees of individuals from Native communities not only increase the accuracy and validity of the data but also improve cultural appropriateness and communication in the research community (Lavelle, Larsen, & Gundersen, 2009). While working individually with each of the tribal communities associated with TCUs across North America would likely be infeasible, NCES could reach out to organizations that already exist to represent and promote TCUs, such as the American Indian Higher Education Consortium (AIHEC). In fact, AIHEC already has an active government relations staff and lists federal underfunding as a key agenda issue (AIHEC, 2019a). The accuracy and relevance of IPEDS would be greatly improved by working with groups such as this, as well as with institutional researchers at TCUs with first-hand knowledge of Native students and the effects of underfunding.  

Finally, professional development for administrators of data systems, research groups, and any other bodies that create or use higher education data must incorporate explicit instruction in the ways they can avoid negative effects on TCUs (and other MSIs) due to misalignment of conventional metrics and the distinct missions of these institutions. As a parallel example, accreditation is also extremely difficult for TCUs, as peer reviewers rarely have a solid understanding of the ways in which TCU operations do not necessarily correspond well to Western measures of success (HLC, 2013). In response to this challenge, in 2013 the Higher Learning Commission (HLC; the regional accrediting body for more than 75% of TCUs) created the report Distinctive and Connected: Tribal Colleges and Universities and Higher Learning Commission Accreditation—Considerations for HLC Peer Reviewers. This document is a primer for professionals involved in higher education accreditation and includes relevant history and context to frame practical applications and considerations that lead to more equitable results in the accreditation process. It is exemplary for the way in which it responded to expressed TCU needs by creating a culturally relevant framework for evaluation with the assistance of advisors from TCUs. For example, the HLC president requested the report after the TCU community raised concerns at conferences. The commission relied on a team of leaders from TCUs and AIHEC in the creation of the document, which was also reviewed by presidents and other representatives from HLC tribal colleges before publication. The result is the inclusion of culturally relevant considerations on topics such as the role of elders in education and etiquette for HLC reviewers during special ceremonies (HLC, 2013).  

Like the professionals from higher education accrediting bodies, administrators from higher education data systems would benefit greatly from informed, accurate, equity-minded professional development related to Native communities and their institutions of higher education. Such considerations in data collection and research use are certainly feasible for NCES and could improve the ways in which IPEDS, as well as other data systems, represent TCUs.      

Conclusion

Severe, chronic underfunding of TCUs contributes to the educational attainment gap between Native and non-Native students and, by extension, between Native and non-Native populations as a whole (Nelson & Frye, 2016). While NCES is not directly responsible for allocating or distributing funds, IPEDS data reporting norms indirectly impact the way in which Native students and TCUs are represented to researchers and policymakers. Chronic underfunding remains obscured, unobserved, and unaddressed, thereby perpetuating inequities. A key solution to help bring these inequities to light is the addition by NCES of enrollment data for beneficiary and nonbeneficiary students to IPEDS. Furthermore, NCES and other organizations across higher education need to incorporate culturally relevant practices into their operations by soliciting input from the affected communities themselves. The end goal of the recommendations above is that the more accurate data sets will better inform researchers and key policymakers, helping ensure that TCUs receive all funds that are rightfully theirs. 

Emily Sharma, EdD, is faculty at Southern Methodist University.


References

25 U.S.C. § 1801(a)(7), 2017.

American Indian Higher Education Consortium. (2019a). Government Relations. Retrieved from http://www.aihec.org/what-we-do/govRelations.htm

American Indian Higher Education Consortium. (2019b). Who We Serve. Retrieved from http://www.aihec.org/who-we-serve/TCUmap.cfm

Clement, D. (2009). Growth by Degrees. In L.S. Warner & G.E. Gipp (Eds.), Tradition and Culture in the Millennium: Tribal Colleges and Universities (pp. 49-58). Charlotte, NC: Information Age.

College Board. (2019). Trends in College Pricing: 2018. Retrieved from https://trends.collegeboard.org/sites/default/files/2018-trends-in-college-pricing.pdf

Faircloth, S.C., Alcantar, C.M., & Stage, F.K. (2015). Use of Large-Scale Data Sets to Study Educational Pathways of American Indian and Alaska Native Students. New Directions for Institutional Research, 163, 5-24. doi:10.1002/ir.20083

Higher Learning Commission. (2013, June). Distinctive and Connected: Tribal Colleges and Universities and Higher Learning Commission Accreditation—Considerations for HLC Peer Reviewers. Retrieved from http://www.aihec.org/our-stories/docs/Accreditation/HLC_TCU.pdf

Institute for Higher Education Policy (IHEP). (2007). The Path of Many Journeys: The Benefits of Higher Education for Native People and Communities. Retrieved from http://www.ihep.org/sites/default/files/uploads/docs/pubs/pathmanyjourneys.pdf

Lavelle, B., Larsen, M.D., & Gunderson, C. (2009). Strategies for Surveys of American Indians. Public Opinion Quarterly, 73(2), 385-403.

McDonald, J. (2003). Non-Beneficiary Resident Students Attending Tribal Colleges in the State of Montana. Non-Beneficiary Tribal College Funding Initiative for the FY 06/07 Biennium: Discussion item for the Board of Regents. Retrieved from https://mus.edu/board/meetings/Archives/NonBeneficiarySKC.htm

National Congress of American Indians (NCAI). (2019). Fiscal Year 2020 Indian Country Budget Request: Winds of Change: Protecting Our Nations and People into the Future. Washington, DC: Author.

Nelson, C.A., & Frye, J.R. (2016, May). Tribal College and University Funding: Tribal Sovereignty at the Intersection of Federal, State, and Local Funding (Issue Brief). Retrieved from http://aihec.org/who-we-serve/docs/ACE-CPRS_TCU-Funding.pdf

Postsecondary National Policy Institute. (2018). Native American Students. Retrieved from http://pnpi.org/native-american-students/#

Rainie, S.C., & Stull, G.C. (2016). Reframing Return on Investments for Tribal Colleges and Universities: Aligning Analyses with Tribal Priorities and Educational Missions. Investing in Student Success: The Return on Investment of Minority Serving Institutions. Penn Center for Minority Serving Institutions, Graduate School of Education, University of Pennsylvania, PA, USA. 

Research Triangle Institute (RTI). (2019). Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS). Retrieved from https://www.rti.org/impact/integrated-postsecondary-education-data-system-ipeds

U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. (2017). NCES Handbook of Survey Methods [Technical report]. Retrieved from https://nces.ed.gov/statprog/handbook/pdf/ipeds.pdf

U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. (2018a). 2018-2019 Survey Materials: Glossary. Retrieved from https://surveys.nces.ed.gov/ipeds/Downloads/Forms/IPEDSGlossary.pdf

U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System. (2018b). Institution Profile: Salish Kootenai College. Retrieved from https://nces.ed.gov/ipeds/datacenter/InstitutionProfile.aspx?unitid=acb3abb1afb2


Leave a Reply