Although the practice of negatively stereotyping native Americans in the mass media can he traced back to the earliest European artists, writers and photographers, examples of the harmful practice abound today, even in the era of so-called “political correctness.”
Across the country, for example, high schools, colleges and professional teams bear the burden of mascots or logos that are derogatory toward native Americans. In spite of pleas and protests, the practice continues.
In Atlanta, fans enthusiastically employ the “tomahawk chop” during Braves baseball games. In Chicago, the Blackhawks hockey team skates on. In Washington, it’s business as usual at Redskins football games. The same is true in Kansas City where the Chiefs play.
If progress has been scarce on the professional sports level, some hopeful signs exist elsewhere. Some colleges and universities have dropped Indian logos and mascots, most recently Marquette University in Milwaukee, which changed its name from Warriors to Golden Eagles this spring.
Still, Gordon Regguinti, executive director of the 500 member Minneapolis-based Native American Journalists Association (NAJA), reported in a telephone interview that only two major daily newspapers in the United States had, as of that date, forbidden the publication of stereotypical team names like Redskins and Braves. They were the Portland Oregonian and the Minneapolis Star-Tribune.
Mainstream news media offer other reminders that insensitive stereotyping of native American is alive and well. In 1993, when a mysterious illness identified by scientists as a strain of Hantavirus killed a number of persons in the Southwest, including several members of the Navajo Nation, it was inaccurately dubbed the “Navajo flu” and the “Navajo disease” by such media giants as CBS News, the Chicago Tribune, the San Francisco Chronicle and others.
On April 28 this year, the day before more than 500 native American leaders were to meet with President Clinton in Washington, Tim Giago, editor and publisher of Indian Country Today wrote a column in USA Today in which he angrily pointed out a headline in the Miami Herald that read “Clinton to meet with hundreds of Indian chiefs.”
“Spare me,” Giago wrote, adding that the headline was “indicative of the cutesy-poo style of heads usually associated with articles about Indians, whether important stories or trivia.”
On the rare occasions when mainstream news media visit Indian nations, it is usually in search of negative or controversial news, and seldom positive stories. Indians are forever depicted suffering from alcoholism, unemployment and the like; they are seldom shown working to solve such problems. Their ability to deal with economic development made possible by the new casino gaming industry on many reservations is questioned. At times, the casinos are depicted as competition for white-owned businesses, and less than desirable for society at large.
Equally frustrating is the lack of coverage in most mainstream media of issues that are of special interest to native Americans. This propensity to overlook or ignore the important news in Indian Country has led to attempts to fill the void through the establishment of native American-owned and operated media in growing numbers.
Not even children can escape the stereotyping of native Americans. From games like “cowboys and Indians” to out-of-date and inaccurate textbooks in America’s classrooms, they’re exposed to it. Last September, High Country News reported that a “Native American Barbie” doll had been introduced by Mattel. A professor was quoted as saying the doll “boils down 400 tribes into a generic stereotype.”
The negative stereotyping of Indians in the motion picture industry has gone on so long that when recent sensitive films like Dances with Wolves and Geronimo: An American Legend were released, the media were moved to emphasize over and over again, in news stories and reviews alike, their political correctness. Progress in this field can be attributed to the use of native American consultants like Sonny Skyhawk who in 1990 founded American Indians in Film, an organization whose purpose is to improve the image of native Americans in motion pictures and television.
American Indian journalists, too, are taking it upon themselves to tackle stereotyping problems. The Native American Journalists Association has joined with similar groups of Asian, Black and Hispanic journalists in a national media surveillance campaign called News Watch. NAJA’s newsletter reported in January that the campaign will “examine the best and the worst of journalism—cases in which news organizations adhere to the finest standards of the professional reporting on communities of color, and cases in which their work is flawed by slurs, stereotypes, bias, insensitive and other problems.”
In addition, NAJA and the other groups announced they would conduct a workshop this summer on the mascot issue as part of their Unity ’94 meeting in Atlanta.
No less concerned about the stereotyping issue are the presidents of those institutions that compromise the American Indian Higher Education Consortium. A mail survey this spring of the presidents reveals that mainstream media stereotyping like that described here has not escaped their attention. The study, in which 45 percent of the presidents (14 of 31) participated, also confirms that member institutions are pitching in to help fight the problem in a number of creative ways.
Colleges Participating in Survey:
- Bay Mills Community College
- College of the Menominee Nation
- Crownpoint Institute of Technology
- Dull Knife Memorial College
- Fort Berthold Community College
- Fort Peck Community College
- Lac Courte Oreilles Ojibwa Community College
- Little Hoop Community College
- Oglala Lakota College
- Sinte Gleska University
- Sisseton Wahpeton Community College
- Standing Rock College
- Stone Child Community College
- Turtle Mountain Community College
Asked first to identify the various forms of stereotyping they had witnessed in the past year, nearly all the participating college presidents pointed to the unbalanced negative reporting about native Americans in the news media (13) and inadequate coverage of issues relevant to native Americans (12). Nine respondents said they had seen racist drawings (caricatures) in the news media, and the same number noted negative or inadequate depictions of native Americans in school textbooks. Six commented on racist language in news media and four on racists photographs. Only one respondent listed negative depictions in motion pictures, perhaps reflecting the apparent improvements being made in that medium.
Given an open-ended opportunity to describe in more detail those stereotypes they had found to be particularly offensive, respondents focused most often on the sports team logos and on the way in which reservation gaming has been reported. Karen Gillis of Fort Berthold Community College, for example, noted that the logos “serve insidiously as unconscious stereotyping of native Americans.”
Addressing the casino issue, Verna Fowler at the College of the Menominee Nations observed, “I find articles on Indian gaming and its resultant effect of reducing welfare rolls offensive. It implies that American Indians by drovers were simply living off welfare.” Vice President Cheryl Crazy Bull of Sinte Gleska University wrote: “The coverage of Indian gaming has primarily been negative as though tribes are illegally or immorally engaging in this effort. Accompanying this coverage are reports of the conflicts experienced among tribal peoples over the issue of gaming (i.e., among Mohawks and Onondagas).”
Asked specifically how stereotyping affected their schools, a number of survey participants pointed out that they were either ignored altogether by the mainstream media or treated as second-class citizens in the education community. “We never see media people on campus,” one wrote, echoing the comments of another who said, “Mainstream media does not cover tribal colleges and the positive things that are happening at them.” And Martha McLeod wrote: “No matter what happens at Bay Mills Community College, it makes the second or third page. The state college gets the headlines—even if it’s a minor event.”
Another respondents said their college “has grown from an affiliate institution to a fully accredited four-year institution hut is still referred to as a two-year, community transfer institution.”
A handful of examples on the local level were cited by respondents who were asked to identify instances of mainstream media coverage that pictured native Americans in a positive light in the past year. On the national level, two participants praised the coverage of prominent American Indians like Wilma Mankiller. One cited Tim Giago’s column, and another pointed to coverage of “the environmental concerns which cite native relationship with the earth and all of its life forms.”
Martha McLead at Bay Mills Community College was pleased with media coverage given a native American who had been named Michigan’s senior citizen of the year, and with positive coverage of some tribal economic situations. Sinte Gleska’s Cheryl Crazy Bull wrote: “Certainly the increased television exposure through Ted Turner’s and Public Broadcasting’s efforts has probably helped people’s historical viewpoint.”
There was no agreement among the survey participants when they were asked to compare the amount of native American stereotyping in the mainstream media today with that of five years ago. One said stereotyping had “increased noticeably,” three said it had “increased somewhat,” five viewed it as being “unchanged,” and four felt it had “decreased somewhat.” No one said stereotyping had “decreased noticeably.” Finally, Karen Gillis at Fort Berthold Community College cited a dichotomy, saying the problem had “decreased somewhat due to bringing it to people’s attention” but at the same time had “increased noticeably, probably due to my awareness.”
Those who detected a change in the amount of stereotyping were asked to explain why they felt it had occurred. Three attributed an increase in the problem of coverage of the Indian gaming industry, two of them citing “jealousy” of its success and the third noting, “The improved economic conditions of tribes has created an environment where the mainstream media must strive to recreate the status quo: “Can’t have Indians with power.”
Another factor behind increased stereotyping, said Gwen Hill of Sisseton Wahpeton Community College, is reporters “going up to reservations and looking for the negative.”
On the other hand, respondents who believe stereotyping has declined cite a variety of factors including films like Dances with Wolves, the “political correctness movement,” and increased awareness of native Americans that has created a consciousness.” One pointed to the fact that “tribes are making more money [and] that gives more respect for some reason.”
“How damaging do you feel ethnic stereotypes in the mainstream media have been to the social and economic advancement of native Americans?” respondents were asked. “Extremely damaging,” replied six, and three more said “very damaging.” Three others saw stereotypes as being “somewhat damaging” and two said they were mildly damaging.” No one checked “not damaging.”
The questionnaire followed with a list of ways in which stereotyping might adversely affect native Americans and asked respondents to check all that apply. Eleven of the fourteen presidents checked each of the following opinions, indicating that stereotypes “led to ridicule” of native Americans, “lowered public expectations” of them, “made it more difficult to obtain employment,” and “reduced ability to interact with non-native Americans.”
Eight respondents said stereotyping “created education hardships for Indians.” Two participants also checked “other,” one noting that stereotypes made it difficult for Indians to obtain housing in cities, and another arguing that native Americans were harmed in that “their very positive lessons and knowledge” were “not allowed to impact mainstream [society].”
Another checklist encouraged survey participants to cite the reasons to which they attribute stereotyping of native Americans in the mainstream media. “Ignorance” (thirteen) and “lack of sensitivity” (eleven) were cited most often. Often factors leading to the problem were “habit” (eight); “carelessness” (seven); and “Overt, purposeful racism” (five). One participant checked “other,” blaming “fiscal” factors for stereotyping.
When respondents were asked to rank the media forms in which the most stereotyping occurred there was no agreement. Nine types of media were listed—local newspapers, national newspapers, local radio newscasts, entertainment programming on television, national magazines, motion pictures, and school textbooks. Each received at least one first-place ranking, and none stood out from the others. The only logical assumption that can be drawn, then, is that stereotyping of native Americans occurs across a broad spectrum of media at both the local and national levels.
Survey participants were asked to describe how stereotyping in the mainstream media might be reduced. Education appears to be the best hope, according to five respondents, three of whom went on to elaborate.
Sinte Gleska’s Cheryl Crazy Bull called for “better education throughout the… system about who the native people are, what their rights and treaty relationships are, what injustices have occurred and continue to occur, and how they might be remedied.
She also called for more native people working in the mainstream media. Another respondent urged “multicultural training in educational programs for journalists and others involved in media.”
The third said we need to “re-educate America [and] get rid of college professors that teach what was taught to them by prejudiced old cronies.”
There were other suggestions, too, about how to reduce mainstream media stereotyping. David Archambault of Standing Rock College said, “America needs to do an assessment of its roots and beginning.” He added that the country “was founded not on freedom but violence. It is a contradiction that continues to be denied” and it had led to “racism, hatred [and] bigotry.”
Karen Gillis at Fort Berthold urged that stereotyping be brought to public consciousness. She also suggested the problem could be reduced “by not allowing people, companies and organizations to ‘to get away’ with stereotyping as we determine it.”
Another participant argued that “checking with the source” would help reduce stereotyping. Still another’s suggestion was to “send all immigrants to their homeland and start over.”
Gerald Carty Monette of Turtle Mountain Community College offered extensive commentary in response to the question of how stereotyping might be reduced. His comments would suggest that native Americans bear some of the blame for the existence of the problems and are reproduced here in their entirety:
This is a very difficult question. Some Indian people and tribes enjoy the stereotyping. It is a means by which they become recognized. Some of our people actually strive to live pre-thought and pre-conceived lifestyles. This allows non-Indians to more easily accept them because they are ‘acting’ like an Indian is supposed to.
Funding for Indian people, and their tribes, is made available to them because they are Indian. Funding agencies, public and private, have a pre-conceived image of what they expect an Indian or a tribe ought to be. Many Indian people themselves hold this pre-conceived ‘stereotyping.’
To be funded, our programs, proposals, etc., must satisfy this notion. It is somewhat ironic; probably each of the 300 plus Indian tribes ‘recognized’ as such are truly different. However, to an ‘acceptable’ degree, all tribes must be ‘alike.’
He concludes that” ‘acceptable’ and ‘alike’ [are] based on stereotyping, often times self-inflicted.”
Next the survey sought to determine how optimistic respondents are about the possibility that stereotyping in the mainstream media can, in fact, be reduced. Reactions varied.
One said he was “very optimistic,” eight were “somewhat optimistic,” two “slightly optimistic” and three “not optimistic.” No one checked “extremely optimistic.”
When the same persons were asked how optimistic they were that stereotyping could be completely eradicated, answers concentrated toward the lower end of the scale. No one was “extremely optimistic” or even “very optimistic” about that occurring. Four said they were “somewhat optimistic,” two were “slight optimistic” and eight were “not optimistic” at all.
Asked to put a time frame on the end of native American stereotyping in the mainstream media, eleven respondents checked “more than ten years down the road,” one adding a notation that said “fifty years.” Two said it will “never” happen. No one checked within the next five years” or “between five and ten years from now.” One respondent did not answer and simply wrote “bad question.”
The survey’s final three questions focused on what steps institutions comprising the American Indian Higher Education Consortium have themselves taken, and might take, to combat stereotyping in the mainstream media, as well as how effective such efforts might be.
What has your college, or its faculty, specifically, attempted to do to counteract media stereotyping of native Americans? Respondents were asked to review a list of actions and to check all that applied. Three efforts seem to stand above the others. Ten respondents said discussion of stereotyping has been incorporated into regular classes on campus, nine had reviewed textbooks for content, and eight had worked individually with mainstream media practitioners to increase their sensitivity to the problem.
Other less frequent responses: Participated in conferences about racial stereotyping (five); protested specific instances of stereotyping (four); offered organized seminars, workshops or classes to educate and sensitize mainstream media practitioners (three); published articles about stereotyping in professional journals (three); published articles about stereotyping in mainstream press (two); and served as consultants to motion picture producers and directors (two). Only one respondent said their college had done nothing with regard to stereotyping.
Answers varied when participants were asked how useful they felt it would be to organize community discussion groups in their locality to deal with the issue of stereotyping. Two felt it would be “extremely useful,” two “very useful,” five “somewhat useful,” and four “not very useful.” No one checked “not useful at all.”
The survey’s final question asked: If your college and its faculty were to become more active in trying to combat ethnic stereotyping of native Americans by mainstream media how optimistic are you that it would result in a significant improvement in your region? The largest number of respondents, eight, said they were “somewhat optimistic” that increased efforts would help. But only one checked “highly optimistic” and one selected “very optimistic.” At the other end of the scale, one said “slightly optimistic” and three said they were “not optimistic.”
Any attempt to base conclusions on a small sampling of opinions like those represented in this survey is fraught with uncertainty and open to criticism. None the less, it is common knowledge that stereotyping of native Americans goes back to the earliest forms of mainstream media. Equally clear is the fact that the problem is still very much in evidence at both the local and national media levels.
There is room for encouragement, however, in the actions of groups like the Native American Journalists Association, American Indians in Film, and other professional organizations and individuals who are fighting against stereotyping. The Minnesota-Dakotas Region of The National Conference of Christians and Jews, for example, produced a sensitive and useful handbook for mainstream media practitioners in 1991 titled The American Indian and the Media.
There is encouragement, too, in the steps already being taken on campuses comprising the American Indian Higher Education Consortium. Still, more could be done; for instance, greater emphasis might be given to preparing native Americans to work in the media, and continuing education opportunities for mainstream media practitioners might be expanded. The time has come for a more concerted effort among the colleges—one that would contribute significantly in the battle to end one of America’s most unwarranted and demanding practices.
Glenn Himebaugh is a professor of journalism at Middle Tennessee State University.
Suggested Readings
Articles
Charles, James P. “The Need for Textbook Reform: An American Indian Example.” Journal of American Indian Education, Vol. 28, No. 3, May 1989,p. 1-13.
Dippie, Brian W. “Photographic Allegories and Indian Destiny.” Montana: The Magazine of Western History, Vol. 42, No. 3, Summer 1992, pp. 42-57.
Gassaway, Bob M. “Press virus strikes Navajos,” Quill, November/December 1993, pp. 24-25.
Guildford, Andrew. “Interpreting Historic Photographs of Native Americans.” Hayes Historical Journal, Vol. XIL, No. 4, Summer 1992, pp. 19-35.
Henry, Shannon. Multiplying Indian Casinos Draw Critics’ Fire. The Christian Science Monitor, August 2,1993, p. 12.
Hill, Richard. “The Non-Vanishing American Indian.” Quill. May 1992. pp. 35-37.
O’Neill, G. Patrick. “The North American Indian in Contemporary History and Social Studies Textbooks.” Journal of American Indian Education, Vol. 26, No. 3, May 1987. pp. 22-28.
They’ve Gotten it Right this Time. (A story excerpted from articles by Tim Giago, Mary Cook and Gemma Lockhart.) Native Peoples, Vol. 4, No. 2, Winter 1991. pp. 6-14.
Books
American Indian Media Image Task Force. The American Indian and the Media. Minneapolis: The National Conference of Christians and Jews, Minnesota-Dakotas Region, 1991.
Bataille, Gretchen M. and Charles L. P. Silet. The Pretend Indians. Ames, Iowa: Iowa State University Press, 1980.
Friar, Ralph and Natasha. The Only Good Indian: The Hollywood Gospel. New York: Drama Book Specialists, 1971.
Hirschfelder, Arlene B. American Indian Stereotypes in the World of Children. Metuchen, NJ: Scarcecrow Press, 1982.
For More Information
Tim A. Giago Jr., Indian Country Today, Box 2100, Rapid City, SD 57709. Telephone: (605)341-0011.
Gordon. Regguinti, Executive Director, Native American Journalists Association. 1433 E. Franklin Avenue, Suite 11, Minneapolis, MN 55404. Telephone: (612) 874-8833.
William Roath, Minnesota Civil Liberties Union. 1021 West Broadway Minneapolis, MN 55411. Telephone: (612)522-2824.






Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.