Forty Years of ‘Fire in the Belly’

Volume 24, No. 2 - Winter 2012
SPIRIT LAKE NORTH DAKOTA

Warm summer’s evening on the Spirit Lake reservation in North Dakota during the Fort Totten Days powwow. Photo by M.A. Pember

“Being Indian was like being born with a curse,” recalls Elden Lawrence, former president of Sisseton Wahpeton College (Sisseton, SD). “Even if you managed to get an education and get a good job wearing a business suit you were still viewed as ‘just an Indian’ by mainstream culture.”

When he was a young man, Indians were neither “wolf nor dog,” he says, and it was difficult for him to find his place in the world: “When you are taught that you aren’t able to do anything, you start to believe it.”

When he returned to the Sisseton Wahpeton Dakota reservation in South Dakota—after living for five years as an alcoholic on skid row in Los Angeles—the tribal college represented his only hope.

Lawrence (Sisseton Wahpeton Dakota) arrived at Sisseton Wahpeton College in the early 1980s with a 9th-grade education from Flandreau Indian School, a federal boarding school. “The people at the college believed in me at a time when I didn’t believe in myself,” he says of the tribal college. “The college offered hope, acceptance and the help to move forward. There finally came a time when I realized I didn’t have to think and believe like the white man in order to be successful.”

Lawrence went on to earn a doctorate at South Dakota State University. He served as fulltime president of Sisseton Wahpeton College from 1998 until 2000, and returned again briefly to the tribal college recently as acting president.

DR JOSEPH MCDONALD

DR. JOSEPH MCDONALD. Founding president of Salish Kootenai College. TCJ file photo

Lawrence’s story exemplifies that early dream of the founders of the tribal college movement—a dream of higher education by American Indians for American Indians. That daring dream, however, continues to be a risky endeavor. As in the early days of the movement, tribal, federal, state, and private funding are still scarce. Fortunately, the founders of the movement, as well as those who worked at tribal colleges in the early days, created a template for others to follow. And tribal colleges and universities (TCUs) continue to turn out new leaders who are following the path blazed by founders of the movement. Indeed, for more than 40 years, tribal colleges have changed the lives of thousands of students who might otherwise not have pursued higher education.

Uncertain futures

Since the beginning, tribal colleges have been a study in American Indian tenacity of spirit. The professional lives of the early tribal college leaders were marked by little or no pay, long hours, uncertain futures, and little support from mainstream educational or governmental institutions.

In fact, non-Indian institutions often blatantly discouraged their efforts. Lionel Bordeaux (Sicangu Lakota), president of Sinte Gleska University (Mission, SD) for the past 40 years, recalls asking a South Dakota state representative for support for creating a tribal college. “He said, ‘That is a very noble and honorable idea but you Indians need to stick with the arts and crafts; you are so good with your hands,’” Bordeaux said during an interview for the American Indian Higher Education Consortium’s 1994 film, “TCUs: Origins from Indian Country.”

According to Bordeaux, the lawmaker suggested that if he and the tribal college pioneers really wanted to do something meaningful for Indian Country, they should “flood the reservations with chicken coops and hog pens.”

LIONEL BORDEAUX

PRESIDENT LIONEL BORDEAUX. Sinte Gleska University. Photo by Dennis J. Neumann

Carty Monette (Turtle Mountain Chippewa), president of Turtle Mountain Community College (Belcourt, ND) from 1974 until 2005, recalls a similar experience when he approached a commissioner of North Dakota’s State Board of Higher Education for support. Monette says he was told: “What do you guys think you’re doing? Indians can’t create a college!”

Politicians of the day didn’t grasp the need for tribal colleges, says David Gipp (Standing Rock, Hunkpapa Lakota), president of the United Tribes Technical College (Bismarck, ND) since 1977 and one of the first executive directors of the American Indian Higher Education Consortium (AIHEC). “Native people were benignly overlooked, neglected, or worse by mainstream higher education,” he says. “With TCUs, we created our own path that reflected our lives.”

Such unfair, racist opposition, says Monette, only added kindling to the college leaders’ fire and determination. In 1972, the Turtle Mountain Band of Chippewa was one of the first tribal governments to charter a tribal college. Today, AIHEC includes 38 tribal colleges in the United States and Canada. Tribal college graduates participate at the highest levels of their fields and are actively involved in building strong tribal governments and leadership.

The initial spark for higher education in Indian Country was ignited, in part, by the civil rights movement. The struggle for racial equality in the United States in the 1960s extended across the nation and had an impact on every aspect of American life. “During that era, people were beginning to argue for their rights,” says Monette. “One of those rights was education.”

He was greatly influenced by the political and cultural events of the day and noted that people from his reservation, the Turtle Mountain Reservation in North Dakota, were not taking advantage of higher education. “For years the BIA, Bureau of Indian Affairs, kept pushing people into vocational training, but we needed people with administrative skills to run our tribal government,” he says. “In the early sixties, there were fewer than five people on our entire reservation of 16,000 people who had a four-year college degree.”

JAMES SHANLEY

JAMES SHANLEY. Former president of Fort Peck Community College. TCJ file photo

The chance to do something to improve the standard of living for his people drove him not only to pursue higher education for himself, but also to become a part of the tribal college movement. He adds: “Fortunately, a number of other Indian people around the country were thinking the same way and that inspired a movement.”

Indeed, the wave of hope generated by the civil rights movement helped inspire a grassroots movement in Indian Country that worked to pass the Tribal College Act.

David Gipp, who has written extensively about the history of the tribal college movement, offers a view of the audacious actions of those early leaders. Sometimes referred to as the historian of the movement, Gipp describes those early meetings among tribal college leaders and lawmakers.

For instance, he describes that first meeting in 1975 that established a Congressional record, and became the basis for further legislation creating and supporting the Tribally Controlled Colleges and Universities Assistance Act. Amazingly, during that meeting the acting director of education programs for the Bureau of Indian Affairs, Dave Warren, and officials representing higher education offices within the Department of Health, Education and Welfare (now the Department of Education) testified against the need for the law.

Gipp also describes a meeting in 1975, during which Rep. Shirley Chisholm, D-NY, brought representatives from The Congressional Black Caucus together and listened to delegates from the Indian/tribal colleges. The meeting was held in an anteroom of the House side of the U.S. Capitol. Stanley Red Bird (Sicangu Lakota) from Rosebud, SD, gave a speech in Lakota—translated to English—which moved Chisholm so deeply that she asked her colleagues to endorse Indian college legislation.

By recording this history and describing the palpable sense of importance of these moments, Gipp helps people remember the events that forever changed the future of higher education in Indian Country. Indeed, Monette recalls that those early days were heady times. “We had a real fire in the belly,” he says.

Although today’s leaders aren’t building the tribal college movement from the ground up, the mission and motivation behind the work is still the same. Tribal colleges offer American Indian students the chance to hope. “When our students see what they can accomplish, their confidence builds. Then they carry that same baton forward to others,” notes Gipp.

Today, many of those tribal college pioneers have passed on, retired, or are at an age when retirement is no longer a distant dream. And as some leaders look back over their careers, they wonder if the current mission of the tribal colleges can ignite that essential fire in the belly for future leaders.

DAVID GIPP

PRESIDENT DAVID GIPP. United Tribes Technical College. Gipp is also a former executive director of AIHEC. Photo by Dennis J. Neumann

Challenges, today and beyond

Securing reliable funding continues to lead the list of challenges for tribal colleges and universities. But leaders within the tribal college movement have a whole list of concerns for the future, including changes in Native populations; maintaining and growing ties with culture, language, and traditional values; keeping up with technology; protecting and managing natural resources; encouraging entrepreneurship; finding a true niche in higher education; and instilling passion within students and future tribal college leaders.

While all TCUs offer some culture and language classes, some have made it a higher priority than others. With more funding available for science and technology, it is sometimes difficult to find resources to support culture classes. Dr. Joseph McDonald (Salish/Pend d’Oreille/Kootenai) was the founding president of Salish Kootenai College (Pablo, MT), serving for more than 30 years in that role and serving as president of AIHEC and chair of the American Indian College Fund board several times.

For him, maintaining and growing Indigenous languages is an essential part of keeping in touch with culture and tradition. Fluent speakers of Native languages are dwindling, he says. “It is hard to understand our religion and culture without the language,” he adds. “In looking back, I wish we had paid more attention to the language.”

Meeting the challenges presented by new and changing technology will also continue to be a major concern for TCUs. As mainstream institutions such as Harvard begin offering courses for free online, TCUs must keep pace with technology if they’re going to remain relevant to the populations they serve. “It’s going to take another major growth spurt for TCUs to ensure our students have the best technology,” says Monette.

More mindful attention to technology will play into the additional challenge of learning to effectively manage tribal natural resources. American Indians control about 60 million acres of land—and many of those lands are rich with natural resources that are in high demand. Everything from housing to transportation will be impacted by the extraction of natural resources, says Gipp. “How do we prepare our people for this?” he asks.

VERNA FOWLER

PRESIDENT VERNA FOWLER. College of Menominee Nation. Photo by Dale Kakkak

The key lies in continuing to train Native people in natural resource protection— as well as in the science of those industries that are seeking to exploit them.

As the demand for water and energy increases, the natural resources in Indian Country will be up for grabs, says Gipp, who adds: “I’m not sure we’re prepared enough for this.” Tribal colleges, he suggests, could become think tanks in this area. Creating plans of action regarding the use and preservation of natural resources could benefit tribes economically and culturally in the future.

For Jim Shanley (Assiniboine Sioux), president of Fort Peck Community College (Poplar, MT) from 1984 until 2011, the growth of technology presents another challenge. “We are going to have to confront a new learning paradigm presented by technology,” he says. “We will have to decide between passing information along to students or giving them problem-solving skills.”

Shanley also predicts that tribal colleges will need to develop more data showing that Indian-controlled schools do indeed provide Indian students with a better foundation than mainstream universities. Along these lines, Gipp says that increasing tribal college-based research will help provide accurate data about Native schools and communities. “We need to find time and resources to invest in our own research at tribal colleges,” he says. “If you control your own research, you control your destiny. We need to share this research among ourselves.”

Gipp adds that demographic shifts within Indian Country will affect tribal colleges too. Increasing numbers of Native people are moving away from their homelands and into urban and other areas.

“Nationally, 70 percent of our population live off and away from tribal communities,” says Gipp, noting that this change can be attributed largely to a lack of economic opportunities on reservations. “More and more of our children are growing up off the reservation,” he says. “Our people want things we didn’t have when we grew up. I’m not sure we have adequately dealt with this issue.”

Tribal colleges could help stem this off-reservation flow, says Monette, by offering more entrepreneurship training and by helping the community to create and develop policies to protect investment. For instance, the lack of zoning ordinances on many reservations may deter investors from setting up businesses. But tribal colleges can play a role, he says, in training people who can create new ordinances and plan for the future.

ELDEN LAWRENCE

ELDEN LAWRENCE. Former president of Sisseton Wahpeton College. Courtesy photo

One of the greatest challenges facing tribal colleges is echoed by several leaders— sustaining leadership.

“Sustaining our leadership is our greatest challenge,” says Dr. Verna Fowler (Menominee), who founded the College of Menominee Nation (Keshena, WI) in 1992 and still serves as president.

Sustainability will be a challenge as long as tribal entities continue to exert political pressure on college presidents. Leaders agree that tribal politicians and college board members sometimes try to exert influence on tribal college leadership. This political pressure sometimes results in high turnover rates among college presidents.

McDonald jokes that he used to record a seating chart during AIHEC meetings because some institutions’ presidents changed so frequently. While some presidents like Shanley, Bordeaux, Gipp, Fowler, and McDonald held their seats for many decades, others have lost their positions with shifting political winds.

With constant changes in leadership, says Fowler, institutional stability is difficult to maintain—and both Monette and McDonald agree. “We need to stabilize our turnover in leadership,” says Monette. “We lose passion with so much change,” he observes.

In a nutshell, many of the leaders of the tribal college movement offer an admonition for tribal and college leaders to remember tribal colleges’ roots and their essential mission of offering hope and confidence to Indian students.

They agree that the most important gift that tribal colleges offered in the early days is the same gift they offer today: hope. “When our students see what they can accomplish, their confidence builds,” says Gipp.

Advice for tomorrow’s leaders

Today, Elden Lawrence worries that tribal colleges may be moving away from serving that essential role of offering hope and empowerment for Indian people. He advises future leaders to rekindle that mission.

Toward that mission, Shanley advises future leaders to use their tribal college presidencies as bully pulpits, encouraging integrity in government, empathy toward others, and the basic values that Native people represent. “If we don’t permeate those values, integrity and holistic world view through everything that we do, then there is no reason for us to be here,” he says. “Leaders should also realize that money isn’t always the answer, especially if you don’t stick to your guns on terms of Native philosophy.”

Overall, leaders encourage a return to the essential driving force that motivated that first scrappy, grassroots dream of building higher education by Indians for Indians.

Other tribal college leaders add that it is important for effective presidents to know their tribe’s culture, history, politics, and treaties—and understand that their roles go beyond those who lead mainstream colleges or universities.

Knowing the history and background of the college and community will also help prevent future presidents from “leading us in circles,” says Fowler. Having a passion for education is essential, according to Fowler. She adds: “You can’t be lukewarm.”

She also believes it is important to know why one wants to be a college president. “It’s a very stressful job,” she notes. “You will make enemies and have to be prepared for that.”

Leaders advise future presidents to reignite their passion for tribal colleges and the mission of the movement. “Too many leaders just seem to be along for the ride, thinking things are just going to happen,” says McDonald. “You have to make a concerted effort for progress.”

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, Shanley advises future presidents to always try to “be nice” to the students. “They are the reason we’re here.”

A regular contributor to Tribal College Journal, Mary Annette Pember (Red Cliff Tribe of Wisconsin Ojibwe) is an independent writer and photographer based in Cincinnati, OH.


Leave a Reply