First-Generation Workers in Indian Country

Volume 29, No. 3 - Spring 2018
LLTC ASSOCIATION FOR THE TUTORING PROFESSION

First generation workers benefit greatly from mentoring. At Leech Lake Tribal College, the Association for the Tutoring Profession facilitates connections between tutors and learners.

When you go to a tribal college, you learn the language, and you learn the values. You implement that. It literally changes you, semester after semester… it’s taught me to be humble, manage my time, don’t feel sorry for myself, wake up the next day, and do it again.

–A tribal college student, College Fund listening session Much has been written about the ways that tribal colleges and universities (TCUs) prepare their students for academic success, but emerging research from the American Indian College Fund identifies how TCUs are positioned to prepare a population of first-generation workers for career success with the potential to contribute to the economic development of their reservation communities. First-generation workers are defined as individuals who are the first in their family to have successful full-time, long-term employment for one or more generations. Similar to first-generation students, first-generation workers benefit tremendously from additional support such as 1) socio-emotional skills development, 2) mentoring, 3) training rooted in cultural identity, and 4) entrepreneurial skills development that is fully integrated into workforce training programs. These types of support allow them to navigate the workforce, on or off the reservation, with the technical training, soft skills, and confidence that is necessary to be competitive.

In the fall of 2016, through research funding from the Northwest Area Foundation, the College Fund began exploring the landscape of workforce education with TCUs in Minnesota, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, and Washington. We identified key stakeholders who have knowledge and experience with workforce training programs on reservations: TCU presidents, staff, and students; reservation-based community development corporations (nonprofit organizations focusing on community revitalization); and national grant-makers, both private foundations and corporations, who make investments in this area.

Research methods included a series of one-on-one interviews, four group listening sessions, a survey, and a literature review that summarized existing research. These activities allowed us to learn about the field of workforce education, get feedback from experts on what we were learning, and, crucially, to be able to center TCU student voices in these conversations—in fact, three of our four listening sessions were devoted to TCU students only.

When embarking upon the project, the College Fund set out to answer two questions: 1) How can the private sector support TCU workforce programming directly? Specifically, which workforce areas are the highest priority and which colleges have readiness, interest, solid academic programming, and support of leadership? 2) How can the College Fund grow in its ability to support TCU capacity building and student services as it relates to workforce training recruitment, readiness, retention, completion, and career success?

Based on the conversations and data collected through this project, the College Fund identified four specific ways that first-generation workers can be supported to successfully contribute to their economic well-being, as well as that of their families and tribal nations. In the following paragraphs, we will explore those emerging themes in more detail.

SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL LEARNING: ON-THE-JOB BEHAVIOR

Graduates of workforce development programs receive technical training and, often, training on soft skills such as writing resumes, tips to interview well, and proper etiquette during business meetings. At the College Fund, we recognized that additional training around what is known as social and emotional learning (SEL) is necessary for first-generation workers.

The Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning (CASEL), a Chicago-based nonprofit organization that specializes in the research and advocacy of SEL for children in preschool through high school, defines SEL as “the process through which children and adults acquire and effectively apply the knowledge, attitudes, and skills necessary to understand and manage emotions, set and achieve positive goals, feel and show empathy for others, establish and maintain positive relationships, and make responsible decisions” (CASEL, 2017). In our student listening sessions, we found evidence for the potential success of SEL training. Many students shared their experiences working in environments where other co-workers or supervisors were unfamiliar with or hostile to Native cultural values. In fact, some students cited racism as an obstacle for them to overcome. Students voiced needs such as help with resolving conflicts at work, communication with supervisors, and building positive relationships with co-workers. For example, many students have personal, family, and community responsibilities outside of work, and a crisis in one of those areas might derail their employment. They sometimes quit their jobs to deal with situations back home rather than working with their supervisors to potentially find a solution where they can keep their jobs. Students do not assume that they will have that type of support in non-Native work environments.

Other examples of SEL skills include leadership, goal setting, adaptability, teamwork, work ethic, and mindfulness. A student in one of our listening sessions shared that her TCU offered a mindfulness class and noted how “we’ve never had the time to relax as Native people.” Through this experience, she was able to take a break, practice being self-aware, and improve her emotional intelligence. These SEL skills will better situate this student and others like her to be successfully employed in a full-time, longterm position.

MENTORS: MODELING SUCCESSFUL BEHAVIOR AND HABITS

Because the key characteristic of first-generation workers is that they are the first in several generations of their family to enter the workforce, mentors become fundamental to providing models for successful career exploration, expectations, and on-the-job behaviors. Mentors might be faculty, advisors, staff, or people in other roles designed to serve students, or they might be supervisors who provide workforce training support through apprenticeships, internships, or job shadowing. On the other hand, sometimes mentors are not formally designated—they are family members, community members, or individuals on a TCU campus who the students feel they can approach for emotional support.

CCCC WORKSHOP

Tribal colleges like Cankdeska Cikana Community College ensure that through classes, mentorships, or apprenticeships workforce students have access to integrated entrepreneurial training so that reservation communities can open up opportunities for self-employment. Photo courtesy of the American Indian College Fund

By demonstrating through their own actions the skills necessary to enter and succeed in the workforce, mentors allow workforce students to envision themselves in those roles. In our conversations with workforce development funders, we learned how mentors are especially crucial for marginalized, first-generation worker populations. They can, informally or formally, provide empowerment training that is holistic and builds feelings of self-worth and confidence. At its essence, mentoring is about providing a model for students so they can imagine what their own life might be like after graduation.

CULTURAL IDENTITY: AN ASSET IN THE WORK ENVIRONMENT

In the first listening session, Wizipan Garriott, chief executive officer of the Rosebud Economic Development Corporation, discussed his personal experiences and his research findings on factors that contribute to success. Garriott noted that these factors are also embedded deeply in Lakota ways, noting:

One is grounding in your identity…You’ve got to know who you are. Second is you have to believe in something greater than yourself; some big purpose that you’re moving towards—making peoples’ lives better or bringing back the buffalo. Third is mentorship and having somebody at all the different stages of your life that you can go to and who is going to help you—an aunt, an uncle, a supervisor who takes you under their wing. And finally [there] is unconditional love; just somebody in your life who is going to say, no matter what you do, no matter how bad you screw up, “I love you.”

For Native first-generation workers, it is necessary to reframe cultural identity as an asset to the workplace, the company, and all employees. The traditional values, behaviors, and beliefs of Native first-generation workers can include concepts such as responsibility to one’s family, diligence, resiliency, creativity, and empathy. The more that a Native first-generation worker can learn—either through a TCU, their family, or the tribal community—to be knowledgeable and confident in their cultural practices and ways of knowing, the more successful they will be at navigating a non- Native environment that is new to them. Education specialist Mathew Makomenaw (Grand Traverse Bay Band) confirms this finding. In his paper, “Goals, Family, and Community: What Drives Tribal College Transfer Student Success,” Dr. Makomenaw concludes that cultural knowledge and connection to spiritualty and identity are important factors in Native student persistence (Makomenaw, 2014).

Unfortunately, many of the Native TCU students who participated in the listening sessions spoke about instances in which they were employed in work environments that were non-inclusive of their cultural identities. Some of those workplaces could be considered hostile or racist. Indeed, many non-Native workplaces lack the cultural competency to acknowledge, understand, and offer solutions to Native first-generation workers who might experience problems with inclusion or racism. Building the cultural awareness of employers may also help create Native-friendly work environments.

ENTREPRENEURIAL SKILLS DEVELOPMENT: CONNECTING TRAINING TO OPPORTUNITY

The desire to earn a degree or certificate and enter the workforce was evident in our listening sessions. In a session about a construction cohort, we found that some of the young adults viewed this as an opportunity to get their foot in the door of employment experience, rather than have a full-time construction position once they completed the internship. They wanted to learn the skill to help grandma make home repairs or build their own home. Some wanted to be teachers, police officers, lawyers, but they all wanted a skill to begin with.

As economic engines of their tribal communities, TCUs create workforce programming that increases the pool of trained and qualified Native people who can either enter into employment or start their own business. From talking with TCU faculty and staff, there is sometimes a disconnect between workforce graduates and the opportunities at home on the reservation.

Take for example a story told by a TCU faculty member who knows that the local tribal college is graduating certified plumbers, but that there still are no plumbers on the reservation. Most people end up calling someone from a nearby off-reservation town. In this situation, entrepreneurial skills development such as training in how to create a business plan, analyze the market and accurately price services, and perform accounting tasks and the general day-to- day running of a business might help to address that gap. Even the language that TCUs and others who work in this field use becomes important. For a first-generation worker, “working for yourself” seems much more accessible than “starting your own business” or “becoming an entrepreneur.” Just as our programs must be designed to create access, so must our language.

Through our survey, 16 TCUs reported that they offered some type of entrepreneurship training, varying from “Indianpreneurship” classes, to entrepreneurship certificates, to general entrepreneurship training as part of a business degree. These classes and training, however, were rarely integrated with workforce education programs. By ensuring that through classes, mentorships, or apprenticeships, workforce students have access to integrated entrepreneurial training, reservation communities can open up opportunities for self-employment.

A SYSTEM FOR LIFE SUCCESS

The College Fund’s strategic plan includes supports offered at each stage of life, from early childhood education to high school partnerships to postsecondary success to meaningful employment. As such, workforce education is a critical piece of that system for life success.

SALISH KOOTENAI COLLEGE NURSING STUDENTS

When these nursing students at Salish Kootenai College enter the workforce, they will have both the necessary skills and cultural knowledge to help transform healthcare for the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes. Photo courtesy of the American Indian College Fund

In Capturing Education: Envisioning and Building the First Tribal Colleges, Paul Boyer highlights that many TCUs were founded to address the workforce and economic needs of their communities, as well as to empower tribes as acts of social justice. The late Stanley Red Bird, community leader and a founder of Sinte Gleska University, stated, “The growth and the development of the tribe depended on skills only available through higher education” (Boyer, 2015, p. 20).

The College Fund hopes to continue building partnerships with other organizations and funders to expand on our knowledge of workforce education, career readiness, and opportunity. Areas for additional research and program development include expanding on first-generation worker support, building stronger partnerships with employers to identify and implement successful training programs, and strengthening the capacity to track graduates as they move into their careers.

Although our research revealed new areas for us to explore, some of our findings reaffirmed what we already knew about TCUs. Through our survey and listening sessions, we heard repeatedly how important it is for TCUs to be responsive to the economic, cultural, and academic needs of their communities. Many TCUs reported that they were adding classes, rotating out classes that had low attendance, and piloting new approaches within workforce education. This show of commitment to centering community voices will become even more crucial in the future, as TCU survey responses indicated an increased demand for workforce education and training. Our findings show that TCU faculty, staff, students, nonprofits, and funders agree that meaningful, empowering employment is an essential goal. With culturally appropriate training, mentors, SEL training, and entrepreneurial development, TCUs are poised to support increased economic development and prosperity on their reservations.

Emily R. White Hat, J.D. (Sicangu Lakota), is the director of strategy and national outreach at the American Indian College Fund. Anna M. Crawford is the principal gifts officer at the College Fund.

REFERENCES

American Indian College Fund. (2016). TCU Workforce Education Opportunities Listening Session Transcripts. Rapid City, SD.

American Indian College Fund. (2017). TCU Student Perspectives: Workforce Listening Session Transcripts. Rapid City, SD.

Boyer, P. (2015). Capturing Education: Envisioning and Building the First Tribal Colleges. Pablo, MT: Salish Kootenai College Press.

Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning (CASEL). (2017). About CASEL. Retrieved from http://www.casel.org/about-2/

Makomenaw, M. (2014). Goals, Family, and Community: What Drives Tribal College Transfer Student Success. Journal of Student Affairs Research and Practice, 5(4), 380–391.


Leave a Reply