On March 30, 2020, New Mexico governor Michelle Lujan Grisham warned that tribal nations could be “wiped out” by the coronavirus. In a more recent interview, Navajo Nation president, Jonathan Nez, stated, “We framed this virus and compared it to monsters that have plagued our people, in our creation stories, our traditional stories. The Navajo people have fought monsters throughout time; that’s our view and our perspective. Today, we are fighting modern day monsters. Now we have a new monster, COVID-19.”
Dikos Nitsaaígíí-19, has threatened the lives of people of color and Indigenous communities at a higher rate. A recent survey conducted by U.S. News and World Report concluded that, “In the United States, people of color have been disproportionately impacted by the coronavirus pandemic, and Native Americans are no exception” (McPhillips, 2020). The publication compared coronavirus case rates and death rates among American Indians and Alaska Natives with those of Whites in 31 states that report race data consistent with Census Bureau classifications. Within the hard-hit Navajo Nation, there were 3,624 cases per 100,000, more than 15 times as high as the rate of 234 per 100,000 among Whites. Similarly, coronavirus death rates were higher among American Indians and Alaska Natives in 15 states (McPhillips, 2020).
Across the Navajo reservation, these emergencies have motivated Diné communities to step up and help their people as quickly as possible by distributing care packages to families; providing computers, laptops, free internet access, and food packages; or contributing through research, science, and contact tracing efforts. However, the total impact of the tragedy extends beyond the scope of caring for basic needs and trying to slow the spread. The virus threatens principles at the very core of Navajo identity. Diné families are considered incomplete without parents, children, and grandparents. In fact, Navajo traditional lifestyles—joint families, cluster and multigenerational housing—are a true source of resiliency. But ceremonies and gatherings in traditional Navajo hogans are factors that put our people at risk—and our elders are at the top of the list. Fortunately, leaders in academia, healthcare, and the greater Diné community have stepped up to lead the Navajo Nation’s COVID-19 response, setting an example for state and local governments across the United States.
TAKING ACTION
On December 21, 2019, an outbreak of a novel form of pneumonia was first reported in Wuhan, China, which on January 7, 2020, was determined to be caused by the emergent virus SARs-CoV-2. (Zhu, 2020). Following this report, on January 8, Diné College’s dean of STEM, James Tutt, along with microbiology professor J. Angel de Soto and virology professor Shazia Hakim, began discussions concerning the SARS- CoV-2 virus. This was followed by a report that a patient in the United States was diagnosed with COVID-19 on January 20 (Holshue, 2020). The following day, Tutt informed Diné College president Charles Roessel that there was a real possibility this new virus could cause a pandemic in the United States and come to the Navajo Nation.

Anticipating a possible pandemic, Diné College president Charles Roessel appointed a special committee in the first week of February 2020 to prepare the college community.
In the first week of February, President Roessel appointed a committee to evaluate the best way to prepare for COVID-19. The committee consisted of Tutt, Hakim, and de Soto, along with Scott Bender (a professor of biology) and Mark Bauer (a professor of epidemiology and public health). By the end of the month, this committee recommended to President Roessel and Provost Geraldine Garrity that social distancing, masks, temperature checks, and handwashing should be immediately implemented. On March 16, 2020, as per Garrity’s directives, Dr. Hakim gave an online presentation to share facts about COVID-19 and to recommend procedures for faculty, staff, and students. The recommendation for the use of facial masks occurred almost five months prior to the official CDC recommendations (CDC, 2020). Within days, an executive team that included President Roessel, Provost Garrity, Bo Lewis, Glennita Haskey, Marie Nez, and Merle Dayzie implemented a command center led by Velveena Davis, executive director of the Office of Institutional Planning and Reporting (OIPR). Diné College’s marketing department, headed by George Joe and Bernie Dotson, launched a campaign to educate the college community and the Navajo Nation about COVID-19, including information on signs, symptoms, and how to prevent transmission.
On March 14, the first case of COVID-19 was reported in the Navajo Nation. Soon thereafter, New Mexico, Arizona, and Navajo Nation officials began warning the Trump administration of the threat that the virus posed to Indigenous populations in general and the Navajo Nation in particular. Their calls fell on deaf ears.
From the first day when the first case was reported on the Navajo reservation, Diné College’s president, provost, deans, faculty, and staff resolved to not let their guard down. All face-to-face gatherings and programs were postponed, and instructors immediately transitioned to online classes using all possible resources available to both faculty and students, including email, the college’s learning management system, the telephone, text messaging, Zoom, YouTube, Facebook, etc. It proved a real challenge for the faculty who worked around the clock to contact and respond to their students—sometimes from the top of the hill, or from the parking lots at local stores or schools, or late at night when internet connectivity was much better. Joy Thompson, director of information technology, oversaw laptop distribution to students who needed them for classes. The school knew some students would require assistance completing assignments, so internet hotspots were developed immediately.
Through the early spring, the situation became dire. Navajo Nation President Jonathan Nez and other officials asked for help to cope with the surge in cases due to a lack of basic facilities, healthcare workers, testing and, of course, funding. But the Trump administration remained silent and the medical community was at a loss to provide efficacious treatment. The situation remained the same until the Navajo Nation was declared a hot spot in the region, with even more cases per capita than New York. The Navajo Nation began to receive aid in the form of healthcare workers, testing kits, hand-washing stations, and emergency treatment sites from neighbouring states and NGOs throughout the U.S. In May of 2020, the Navajo reservation reported the highest rate of infection in the United States. Strict precautionary measures, lock downs, and a 57-hour weekend curfew were implemented to flatten the curve.
At the same time, staff from President Roessel’s office were busy making sure that all eligible Diné College students could pick up emergency stimulus checks at three campus sites in Arizona and New Mexico. The checks arrived under a $1.3 million grant, secured via the U.S. Department of Education’s Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act. In the third week of May 2020, 300 checks were distributed to students at the college’s main Tsaile campus. “Overall, 1,034 students met the grant’s eligibility criteria,” says Velveena Davis, head of the incident command center. The check amounts ranged from $474 to $697 and OIPR secured the grant.
Preventive measures were implemented throughout all campuses and centers before the fall 2020 semester. COVID-19 screenings were conducted at main entrances on all six of the college’s campuses. A few classes were still face-to-face with extreme precautionary measures, and the students who joined these classes must have noticed a number of changes. Aside from safety measures in place and reopening guidelines available for faculty and staff, each of the libraries at Diné College installed specialized ultraviolet machines to disinfect books. They also installed hand-washing stations near all entrances and Plexiglas sheets in classrooms, libraries, offices, and laboratories.
After the Thanksgiving break, all face-to-face classes transitioned to online instruction, and the same practices continued during the spring 2021 semester in an effort to keep students, faculty, and staff safe. Additionally, members of the Diné College faculty began enrolling in an 11-week quality matters teaching program, whereby they could obtain online teaching certification. At the same time, the college started its first cohort in a one-year, certified medical assistant program in collaboration with the Tuba City Regional Healthcare Corporation. This initiative elicited a positive response from communities throughout the Navajo reservation for considering the importance of locally trained healthcare workers.
The college also organized a GoFundMe page to assist students in need with finances for computers, food, and COVID-related healthcare. Donations to the fund are tax deductible. Currently, the college hopes to resume student internships sometime during the summer, depending on how the pandemic unfolds in the preceding months.
UNDERSTANDING THE NAVAJO NATION’S VULNERABILITY TO COVID-19
In April of 2020, Diné medical scientists Hakim and de Soto published the first paper explaining why Indigenous people may be biologically more susceptible to the coronavirus (de Soto, 2020). This was followed by one of the earliest comprehensive papers on the pathophysiology of the virus (Hakim, 2020). The Navajo people, along with other Native Americans, are vulnerable to COVID-19 due to both genetic and environmental reasons. Scientists de Soto and Hakim reported that Indigenous people have an elevated ACE2 receptor, which serves as the entry point for the SARs-2 virus into the lungs, beginning the process that can lead to pulmonary and often cardiac failure (de Soto, 2020). While it is true that Navajo people suffer from high rates of obesity, diabetes, hypertension, lung disease, and autoimmune conditions, this is just one factor. In addition, it is hard to practice proper hand hygiene when there is a lack of running potable water, as over 50% of housing in the Navajo Nation lacks rudimentary plumbing. Many people must haul water, but as the more physically mobile members of the family get sick, they are no longer able to do so. Others do not have the income to purchase soap, hand sanitizer, or even food. This is only exacerbated when they must drive an hour to the closest store only to find that such supplies are out of stock. Reportedly, there are only 13 grocery stores throughout the reservation where shoppers can find fresh fruits and vegetables (Kreider, 2019). Moreover, many homes do not have a physical address where UPS or FedEx can deliver items.
There were reportedly only 170 hospital beds, 13 ICU beds, 52 isolation rooms, and 28 ventilators on the entire reservation. The Navajo Nation needs more allied healthcare workers, laboratory technicians, technologists, nurses, medical assistants, and physician assistants to help Diné communities. To fulfill this need, it is important to train a local workforce—the Navajo youth, who are knowledgeable in community needs and cultural sensitivities. It is vital to offer more training programs to prepare a local workforce in STEM and applied biological and health sciences.
Collectively, most healthcare facilities on the reservation are providing general diagnoses at a primary level. There are no molecular diagnostic laboratories at any healthcare facilities that can be utilized for quick diagnoses of presumptive COVID-19 patients. For all critical testing, samples are sent off-reservation to state laboratories— not only because of a lack of facilities but also because advanced level testing requires highly skilled laboratory technicians and technologists or medical laboratory scientists, who are all in short supply. The resulting time lag is dangerous because delayed results can have a detrimental outcome and increase the care and cost burden on the medical facility and the patients, their families, and the community. This situation can be improved by expanded diagnostic capabilities and a locally trained healthcare workforce within the Navajo Nation.
LOOKING AHEAD
On January 7, 2021, it was reported that COVID-19 had affected more than 87,654,861 individuals around the world as the count continued to rise at unprecedented rates. Although the pandemic has posed a terrible health crisis, it is time to consider the deficiencies and lessons learned. Health facilities in tribal communities do not have all the required tools and equipment that are needed for rapid diagnosis and treatment of infected individuals. For most of the services they must look to neighbouring states and border towns. Patients’ samples are sent outside the reservation and that takes time. Further, patients must be transferred to large cities because the right resources are unavailable.
Now is the time to discuss what we have learned from this outbreak and what we must do to prevent such situations in the future. The team at the Diné College School of STEM was able to secure a grant from the American Society for Microbiology to conduct a conference entitled “Emerging Infection & Tribal Communities: What We Learned From the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Held on February 19, 2021, experts and tribal leaders from the U.S. and Canada were able to come together at the same forum to share their views and experiences. They discussed how different tribal communities and minorities were dealing with this monster, what they were lacking, and what they need. That conference was an eye opener, and the hope is that it will be a steppingstone for the development of advanced research and scientific facilities within tribal communities—especially within the Navajo Nation.

Diné College professors and medical scientists, J. Angel de Soto (left) and Shazia T. Hakim (not pictured) published the first research papers examining the pathophysiology of the SARs-CoV-2 virus in the Navajo Nation.
At Diné College, there is a strong STEM faculty with commendable backgrounds in medical science, microbiology, molecular biology, public health, biochemistry, chemistry, mathematics, and the physical sciences. Within the last couple of years, the college has developed a number of public health-related programs, recently incorporating the certified medical assistant program to that list. Looking forward to developing more programs in biomedical sciences, medical laboratory science, and medicine, the college is now working to build more technologically advanced and well-equipped facilities needed to provide innovative diagnostic capabilities and training for our Navajo youth and communities. The college seeks to train its own local workforce to combat situations like the current pandemic. We want to bring infrastructure like telemedicine to our communities, which can improve access to appropriate care. This is why the college is working hard to identify scientific grants. Diné College’s grant office has remained helpful in securing these opportunities and guiding the college community throughout the process.

When the first COVID-19 case was reported in the Navajo Nation, Diné College moved all classes online. Only after implementing a variety of precautionary measures such as Plexiglass sheets in classrooms, social distancing protocols, and mask requirements did face-to-face classes resume on a limited basis.
CONCLUSION
Diné College was among the first institutions of higher education nationwide to implement a comprehensive approach in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Major universities soon afterwards used Diné College as a model on steps to take. Moreover, Diné College medical scientists were at the forefront of medical research to study and understand the pathophysiology of COVID-19 and why Native peoples are especially prone to the disease. They also investigated the best methodologies of treatment. Indigenous and other minority medical scientists and clinicians quietly led the fight against COVID-19, as Indigenous administrators set the example on how to respond to the pandemic.
On December 6, 2020, Diné College medical scientists published the first comparative evaluation of the Pfizer, Moderna, Sputnik, and AstraZeneca vaccines (de Soto, Dec 2020). Additionally, the college’s incident command office continues to work with Indian Health Services and 638 facilities within the Navajo Nation to make sure all Diné College staff, faculty, employees, and students receive vaccinations. The main force behind all of Diné College’s achievements is our dynamic president, Dr. Charles Monty Roessel. “The year was a challenge, and it continues to be a challenge,” he stated. “But we have preserved, and we will all succeed—together.”
Shazia T. Hakim PhD, SCCM (MLS), CRC, is a professor of microbiology in the School of STEM at Diné College; Joseph Angel de Soto MD, PhD, DSSc, FAIC, is a professor of STEM and biomedical science at Diné College; George Joe, MA, MEd (Navajo), is the director of marketing and communications at Diné College; Bernie Dotson, MA, is the public relations officer at Diné College.
REFERENCES
CDC Calls on Americans to Wear Masks to Prevent COVID-19 Spread. (2020). Centers for Disease Control. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/media /releases/2020/p0714-americans-to-wear-masks.html
de Soto, J.A. (2020). Evaluation of Moderna, Pfizer/Biotech. Astrazeneca/ Oxford and Sputnik V Vaccines for COVID-19. Advanced Research Journal of Medical and Clinical Science, 6(12), 365-371
de Soto, J.A. & Hakim, S.T. (2020). Medical Basis for Increased Susceptibility of COVID-19 Among the Navajo and Other Indigenous Tribes: A Survey. Journal of Biomedical Research and Reviews, 3(1), 37-41.
Faulders, K. & Rubin, O. (2020). New Mexico’s governor Warns Tribal Nations Could Be “Wiped Out” by Coronavirus. ABC News. Retrieved from https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/mexicos-governor-warns-tribal-nationswiped- coronavirus/story?id=69884997.
Foust, D., Hakim, S.T. & de Soto, J.A. (2020). Complementary Pharmacological Treatment and Therapeutic Prospects for COVID-19. ACTA Scientific Pharmaceutical Sciences, 4(11), 82-89.
Hakim, S.T., Boyd, F.T., & de Soto, J.A. (2020). The Pathophysiology of COVID-19. Journal of Virology Research & Reports, 1(2), 1-7.
Holshue, M.L., DeBolt, C., Lindquist, S., Lofy, K., & Wiesman, J. et al. (2020). First Case of the 2019 Novel Coronavirus in the United States. The New England Journal of Medicine, 382, 929-936.
Kreider, M. (2019, December 10). 13 grocery Stores: The Navajo Nation Is a Food Desert. Planet Forward. Retrieved from https://www.planetforward.org/idea/13- grocery-stores-the-navajo-nation-is-a-food-desert
McPhillips, D. (2020, October 7). COVID-19’s Tragic Effect on American Indians: A State-by-State Analysis. U.S. News & World Report. Retrieved from https://www.usnews.com/news/healthiest-communities/articles/2020-10- 07/a-state-by-state-analysis-of-the-impact-of-covid-19-on-native-americans
Zhu, N., Zhang, D., Wang, W., Li, X., Yang, B., et al (2019). A Novel Coronavirus from Patients with Pneumonia in China, 2019. The New England Journal of Medicine, 382, 727-733







Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.