Factors Contributing to Post-Secondary Achievement of American Indians

Volume 4, No. 2 - Fall 1992

This study investigated the family and educational history of American Indian college graduates to determine what identifiable characteristics are factors in their success. The sample included ten American Indians from three tribes. The investigation used a case study design. The guide had two sections, one addressing family socioeconomic, educational, and cultural back­ground, and a personal history of elementary and secondary education, including personal opinions. This study revealed these successful graduates generally came from low socioeconomic and educational backgrounds. Eight subjects were primary English speakers, and all maintained ties to their Indian culture. The educational history reported by the majority told of a poor educational record and negative experiences in the educational system. The graduates attributed their success to family encouragement, though family expectation did not extend to college attendance. In seven cases a single family member was credited by graduates. They also credited their personal desire for betterment.

Journal articles, television reports, and entire issues of popular magazines are devoted to the crisis in the public education system. There are frequent reports on dropout percentages and the rate students in elementary and sec­ondary schools are falling behind their grade level. Because of “insufficient numbers of Indian students surveyed” or the “need for more studies in this area” the majority of the infor­mation does not include American Indians. When the reports do include American Indian students, the statistics are the most dismal of all racial/ethnic groups. The 1991 Indian Nations at Risk Task Force reports “35.5 percent and in some places 50 to 60 percent of American Indian and Alaska Native students leave school early” (p. 7).

There are fewer sources of information on American Indian college students. The reports available from research with American Indian college graduates are pessimistic. Bobby Wright stated in the Journal of American Indian Education (1985) that 6 percent of American Indians have completed college compared to 23 percent of white Americans and 12 percent of black Americans. The number of Indians who go on to higher education is gradually increasing, but the number who leave post-secondary institutions is the highest percent­age of all groups. Raymond (1986) reports that “drop-out rates in traditional four-year institutions have been estimated to be as high as 93 percent.”

Purpose of the Study

The problem of retention and success in post-secondary education is often a result of factors that develop before the student enters college. Only recently have researchers looked at family and other personal factors that contribute to American Indian academic success.

It should be a goal to recognize, maintain and strengthen positive experiences, performances and aspirations of Indian students. Parents armed with the knowledge that certain fac­tors or characteristics contribute to the academic success of their child may foster those attributes. Teachers of Indian children in the primary and secondary schools can be an important influence on their students by recognizing and pro­-moting factors that promote success in college.

Many Indian students enter college with the same back­ground and the same problems as Indians who leave college, but they persevere and graduate. Why do some Indian stu­dents succeed in post-secondary education and others fail?

Method

This study was initiated to examine the background characteristics of ten successful American Indian col­lege graduates. A qualitative design was chosen over a comparison of statistical information because a case study design tells not only what, but why, and “has the potential for providing insights not obtainable with other methods” (Gay, 1987, p. 213). While statistical data is generally trusted to be accurate by researchers, it has not led to changes that have increased the American Indian academic success rates.

A two-part interview guide was used to examine, first, the subject’s socioeconomic, educational, and family cultural his­tory. The second section of the questionnaire addressed per­sonal experiences and opinions of the graduates.

To obtain the information, a four-step process was employed. Initial contact was made with possible subjects who were asked to participate, a second contact to arrange an interview, and a third for the interview itself. The last step was analysis of the information.

The survey and interview were completed in one meeting except when clarification of information was desired. The interview sessions took from one to two hours, running like a conversation, allowing the subjects to pursue areas of interest that allowed the interviewer to gain insight into the family and personal background of the subjects.

The analysis of the information included classifying and comparing the quantitative data, but the qualitative answers required reviewing responses and categorizing information. Many responses fit in more than one category. This descrip­tive information was helpful in revealing the affect the family and educational background had on the educational success of the graduate.

Subjects

The subjects for this study were ten American Indian college graduates. They were enrolled members of the Crow, Northern Cheyenne and Blackfeet tribes. There were seven females and three males interviewed for the study. This is comparable to the breakdown of Indian stu­dents, by gender, in post-secondary institutions (Boyer, 1989; McIntosh 1987). The median age of the subjects was 33 years.

The ten graduates earned a total of twelve degrees: one associate of applied science, four associate of arts, six bache­lor’s and one master’s. One subject was completing his doctor of education degree at the time of the study.

Only two graduates attended a single institution while earning a degree. One student attended a tribal college to complete an AA degree, and the other, a state university for a bachelor of arts degree. Students attended a wide variety of institutions, including two tribal colleges, five public two and four year institutions and one private university.

Results—Socioeconomic History

The first portion of the investigation was a survey of the graduates’ family background, including their cultural, socioeconomic and linguistic history.

Of the graduates interviewed, only two did not spend all of their early years on a reservation; none were “urban” Indians. Several subjects were raised by extended family members for various periods of time, and one graduate was raised by grand­parents from early childhood.

Parents of four of the subjects were divorced and two were widowed. Alcoholism was a disruptive force for seven of the graduates in this study. Those seven graduates mentioned alco­hol abuse as a factor that changed their traditional family struc­ture, leaving single mothers and grandparents raising children.

The median income for Montana families in 1979 was $18,416 (American Demographic Editors, 1984). Only three of the Indian college graduates reported being raised in families with an income over $ 15,000. Three of the families reported an income of $10,000 to $15,000 and four an income of under $10,000. None of the graduates had their post-secondary edu­cation financed by parents, although in several cases they were able to contribute to their children’s education. As Julie said, “I always knew that I could go home to live, and they were there and would help me as much as they could.” For Julie, and three other students, attending college at the tribal college while liv­ing with family and working on the reservation kept the educa­tional process flowing when they did not have funding to attend public or private institutions.

The parental occupations and educational level reflected the families economic situations. Seven of the successful stu­dents were raised in families where the mother was in a skilled occupation as a teacher, elementary school or Headstart aide, or, in one case, a licensed practical nurse (LPN). Mothers of two subjects were employed as cooks and maids, with one a full time homemaker. None of the grandmothers who were prima­ry caregivers were employed outside the home. The families with the father employed in an unskilled trade or as laborer/agricultural worker had an income below $ 15,000. For the three families with an income over $ 15,000, the father was in a skilled trade or, in one case, worked for the BIA while ranching and the mother was also employed.

Thirty-eight percent of white high school graduates enter college while seventeen percent of Indian high school gradu­ates enter college (Kidwell, 1986). The 40 percent college attendance for the Indian parents of this cohort exceeds the national average. Mothers of two graduates earned bachelor’s degrees in education, one completed vocational training, and several attended some college classes. One father (who was not involved in raising his children) earned an AA from a tribal college. Four fathers and three of the female primary caregivers (one was a grandmother) had up to six years of schooling; five of the fathers and four of the mothers had six to twelve years of education.

FAMILY BACKGROUND TABLE

Cultural History

The language history is a factor when studying the aca­demic success of any ethnic group. Four language groups were represented by the subjects in the study. In seven of the homes, English was the primary language (although one subject reported a three-fourths English and one-fourth Cheyenne mixture). One grandmother always spoke Cheyenne and required the children to respond in English “so they would be able to speak English—to get along on the outside.” One student came from a home where Cheyenne was the primary language; one came from a Crow speaking home. Both of these graduates started school unable to speak English. The Blackfeet language was not used in the home of the Blackfeet tribal member.

In both instances where a tribal language was the primary language for the subjects, the subjects vividly recall their first school experiences. Katherine related her experiences:

The teacher didn’t speak Crow and when she talked it sound­ed like the teacher’s voice in the Charlie Brown TV shows— just sounds. I had no idea what she was saying and when the Crow kids tried to help each other and figure out what we were supposed to do, she always bawled us out and told us to get to work. The kids were divided into groups A, B, C, D and F. The Crow kids were all in D and F groups. There was never any effort to help any of us.

Catholic boarding schools were typical of the boarding school experiences of many Indian students:

When I started my education in a Catholic boarding school at the age of six, 1 knew only my native tongue. I was discour­aged from speaking Cheyenne forcibly. I remained at this school for extended periods of time and had only little contact with my parents. Education was a way of destroying my tra­ditional beliefs and values. These methods must have been extremely effective since I hated my own skin color. I would be little my parent’s traditional beliefs and values, since I was taught to view my parent’s ways as bad. This has had a tremendous negative effect on my life.

Gerald dropped out of an off-reservation community col­lege and, only after several years, returned to a tribal college to complete his AA degree.

Terri, whose grandmother wanted her grandchildren to speak English correctly, said, “I heard only Cheyenne and spoke English, so I had trouble knowing some of the words. Even today I have to figure out what words I mean to use.” Language was a negative factor for these graduates.

Like the native language, family attachment to tribal values and culture is part of a student’s history. Six of the graduates were raised in families they considered partially acculturated. Other graduates said their families valued tribal traditions and they followed some traditional ways. Four of the families were considered “modern” or totally acculturated by the subjects in spite of the fact that the individuals had traditional grandpar­ents who they considered very influential in their lives.

Educational Background of Subjects

In addition to the socioeconomic and cultural characteris­tics of families, the elementary and secondary educational experiences of successful Indian graduates were examined to identify characteristics they may have contributed to their academic success.

The type and number of schools the subjects attended were examined for this study. Only four of the graduates attended preschool or kindergarten.

The types of schools attended varied, and only two subjects attended the same school their entire elementary and sec­ondary school career. One student attended a Catholic mis­sion school, and the other attended a former BIA boarding school on the Northern Cheyenne Reservation. It was typical for students to attend elementary school, either a public or mission school on the reservation, and move to a public high school on or near the reservation. Terri spent kindergarten through grade five at a mission school, transferred to the reser­vation public school for junior high, and went through four years of high school at an off-reservation public school.

Nine of the ten students graduated from high school; one female married in the spring of her senior year and earned a General Education Diploma (GED). Five students graduated from off-reservation public high schools, two from a Catholic mission school and two from reservation high schools.

After high school graduation six students enrolled in col­lege immediately and three others enrolled soon afterward, or took occasional classes at a tribal college. Although the initial enrollment figures are high, only two students completed a two-year degree without “stopping out”.

The elementary and secondary school careers of the Indian graduates did not foretell their success. Six of the subjects said their high school teachers did not encourage them in school or urge them to go on to college. Only two students were told by one or more teachers they were good students. Gerald said, “I was good in math and got high scores on tests. Some teachers let me know I could go to col­lege, but I still thought I had to be white to succeed.” Jan was always at the top of her class at a Catholic school and said, “I learned to fear the nuns, but they didn’t prepare me for college. I didn’t really have to try, and I didn’t have any study skills.” Laurie was never encouraged or expected to go on to college by high school personnel. “It was like high school was the end— all there was. We were never told when we went in to set up classes at the counseling center, ‘you’ll need this for college.'” The teacher who did encourage Indian students was an excep­tion; Terri remembered:

Mrs. Johnson (pseudonym) was always pushing, and told the Indian kids, “You can do anything you want, and I respected her because she was my coach and positive. Other teachers just marked all over my papers. I was told 1 was ter­rible in math, so I was. I had to learn to write in college. When I got to Eastern [Montana College], the professors took the time to teach me. I was so happy I could do math.

Six other graduates felt they did not have one teacher who made them feel they could succeed in high school or expected them to go to college. The classes offered to Indian students were basic, not college preparatory classes. Most graduates echoed Laurie when she reported, “It seemed liked there was no life after high school.”

What was encouraged in school were the extra-curricular activities, especially sports. Nine of the ten people inter­viewed participated in some activity, eight in sports. Mike said, “Sports (and girls) kept me in school;” Jonathan went to college “to run track,” and Terri succeeded academically only during basketball season. For four of the seven females, cheer leading and basketball were the important activities in school. Only one of the ten graduates did not participate in any extra­curricular activities while in high school.

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND TABLESchool itself had no real meaning for eight of the students. Only two graduates reported the desire to succeed academical­ly while in high school. Jonathan was “too busy worrying about my family. School was secondary.” Mike graduated fourth from the bottom of his high school class, but said, “My mother went to Catholic school and she respected authority and made me sit down and do my work. But it was just enough to get by.” This was reiterated by seven of the subjects. Parents did not tell them to do homework. “We just played outside or watched TV until we went to bed,” Katherine reported. Terri, a public school teacher today, said, “I would be called ‘at risk’ today. I was never pushed or did homework.”

Although the subjects were not encouraged by their teachers and were not pressured to compete for grades, eight graduates stated their families “strongly supported” education. And, while there was a respect for edu­cation, only Jan’s family expected her to go to college. One college graduate, who was not part of this study, stated, “My family was just happy I finished high school.” The typical fami­ly attitude was, “If you want to go to college, we know you can do it.” Nine of the ten people interviewed stated they were supported and encouraged by their families when they attend­ed college.

Personal Opinions

Even though there were many people involved in the col­lege experience, each person immediately knew who they felt was the significant factor for their personal achievement.

Sarah’s family was unusual in that they did not encourage her in education.

Today, they (my family) are still depending on me to help them when 1 am having problems going to college. But, they were proud of my AA. It was the first time my brothers hugged me in their lives. I did it on my own, for my kids, so they’d have a better life.

Sarah is the only person who reported a family who did not encourage her educational activities. Julie had “encourage­ment from my parents and Grandpa Henry to get a good edu­cation.” Laurie found support from her mother. “I had the abil­ity because of my mother’s encouragement,” she said. Victoria’s mother was also a source of strength. “She, my mother, was very good at tactfully pushing us through school. My family encouraged me very, very much.” ^Catherine’s fami­ly did not expect her to go on to college but she reported, “My father taught me to have good self-esteem and confidence and my mother taught me the importance of education.” Jan’s fam­ily always expected her to go to college, but she rebelled, mar­ried, and is now divorced with two children to raise. She feels that “with kids it’s different, but I’ve always had a goal. It’s not the thought of making a lot of money that drives me. It’s more of an internal drive. My dream drives me.”

Mike went to work after high school graduation but soon realized, “There was more to life than pulling boards off a stack. I didn’t know where to write for funding on my own. My mother made me write to the head of the Browning boarding school.” Until that time there was no response. He wrote letters and in two weeks got tribal and federal grants that made it possible. When asked why he went to college, Mike answered, “To please my mother—and because of the grants—and I wanted a profes­sional job.” Jonathan had two brothers with college degrees and said he “saw the respect they got when they came back to the reservation. Edward (pseudonym) was at Haskell then and he got me into Haskell.” Gerald’s parents did not expect him to attend college, but were still supportive. “Anything I did must be right. My family encouraged me very much.”

Discussion – Family Background

This study presents information that is contrary to the typical picture of families of successful college gradu­ates. These graduates were not from stable, financially comfortable, well-educated families.

The results of this study were compared to Rindone’s 1988 study of Navajo graduates and the work of Huffman (1990), and Huffman, Sill, and Brokenieg (1986) with Sioux college students.

Only four of the parents of the graduates had a history of achievement in post-secondary education. This agrees with Rindone (1988) and Huffman, Sill, and Brokenieg (1986), both of which found that parent’s level of education was not an influential factor in the educational success of Indian col­lege graduates.

The same pattern was true for family income of Indian stu­dents. None of the graduate’s college careers were financed by their families. While the “stopping out” factor was related to uncertain funding for two students, no graduate stated that finan­cial problems were the only cause for the stopping out period.

In contrast to Rindone’s study where 78 percent of the Navajo graduate’s parents were married, 60 percent of the Montana graduates came from broken homes.

The parental occupations were consistent with their educa­tion levels, with one notable condition. Five of the graduates were raised in a family where the mother was involved in teach­ing or, in a sixth case, as a dorm mother at a boarding school.

A low socioeconomic and family educational background is commonly associated with low academic success. This was not true for these successful students. The results agreed with Uffman, et.al. (1986) in their study of Sioux students, show­ing there were fundamental differences in factors that have a relation to success for white and Sioux students.

While 80 percent of the parents “strongly supported educa­tion,” only one of the ten graduates stated their family expected them to go to college. Rindone’s (1988) study with Navajo’s stated that family support of education was related to success in post-secondary education. In this study of Montana Indians, appreciating the value of education and supporting the individ­ual, not expectation of college attendance, were factors that were important to the success of the Indian graduates.

While the Montana graduates were not primarily speakers of their tribal language, they all have some degree of attachment to Indian culture. Huffman’s (1990) work included the descrip­tion of the process of “transculturation, the ability to enter and interact in the milieu of another culture without the loss of the person’s former cultural identity”(p. 16). These graduates were able to retain their Indian culture, to be Indian, and to be a suc­cessful student in the white middle class system.

Educational History

The early educational history of the subjects is not what is expected of successful college graduates. Only two were considered “good students” by their teachers while in high school. Their high school grade point averages were not predictive of future success. This is consistent with Huffman’s (1986) findings that high school GPA’s were not related to college achievement for Sioux students. Earning high grades, being an honor student, competing against others academically or trying to win scholarships was not important for the majority of these successful college graduates.

The final area of pre-college history addressed the attitude of the school system and of teachers toward the Indian stu­dent. Many reported “benign neglect” as the best behavior of their teachers. The only encouragement during secondary school was in extra-curricular activities. The emphasis placed on the students’ athletic abilities was not a factor in their col­lege careers. None of the students reported teachers or school counselors helping them choose classes that were necessary for college entrance. “No one expected us to go” was the gen­eral consensus of the graduates.

The majority of these graduates succeeded without the sup­port of the elementary and secondary school system or their individual teachers.

Recommendations

The lack of research material on Indian students does not allow for comparison, verification, and generalizability of information. The subjective perceptions of American Indians will, however, provide important insights into characteristics that promote success in education. Three other specific areas to investigate are motivation at specific degree levels, the influence of tribal colleges on continuing education, and the “stopping out” factor common to Indian college students.

The traditional extended family structure is culturally dif­ferent from the white nuclear family and is undergoing changes due to influences and pressures from the white major­ity society. It is important to investigate the relationship between types/levels of identification with “tradition” and “assimilation,” and specifically how a person adapts to bicultural and multicultural settings.

Judging Indian students by white, middle class standards is inappropriate, and the classroom teacher should be trained to understand and value Indian students and their culture in order to make informed evaluations. Teachers base their expectations of student behavior and accomplishment on their own personal and cultural standards, to the disadvantage of the culturally different student. Teaching in the multicul­tural classroom requires training teachers so they understand their students from a culturally based perspective.

Family support was a major factor in the graduates’ success. Family involvement in the school system, or even one mem­ber of the extended family who works in the school system as a teacher, teacher-aide or counselor, becomes an example to many people on a reservation.

The sense of alienation for non-white students should be a matter of concern for all academic institutions. These gradu­ates succeeded in the white world while retaining a degree of their cultural and ethnic values. It was not necessary to give up their cultural attachment to achieve academically. But, for other Indian students who are not assimilated or are not transculturated, who feel alienated from the system, the academic institution can promote success by providing Indian students with a non-threatening and accepting environment.

Five of the successful students had educators as role models. The continuing need for native teachers and counselors is important, not only to provide Indian students with educators who are familiar with the culture, but to be an example to the students. A college graduate is a role model who raises aspira­tions and expectations for every child in a relatively closed reservation culture of interacting extended families.

Summary

The key factors contributing to the success of the Montana Indian students was the value the family placed on education and the desire to please a family member, although there was no pressure on the students to succeed academically. The graduates’ families encouraged the students in whatever they chose to do, even though there was no expectation of a col­lege education for their children. The successful graduates reported a desire to better themselves through education.

The elementary and secondary educational history was generally disappointing and unpromising for these Indian graduates. But they succeeded in spite of their early educa­tional and socioeconomic background.

Judith Davis earned a master’s degree from Eastern Montana College. She is currently teaching at Dull Knife Memorial College.

Bibliography

American Demographic Magazine Editors. (1984) State Demographic. Homewood, IL: Dow Jones-Irwin, 190.

Boyer, P. (Ed.) (1989). Tribal colleges: Shaping the future of Native America. Princeton, NJ: Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.

Gay, L.R. (1987). Educational research: Competencies for analysis application. Columbus, OH: Merrill

Huffman, T.E. (1990). The transculturation of Native American college students. Proteus: A Journal of Ideas, 7(1),. 8-14-

Huffman, TJE., Sill, M., & Brokenieg, M. (1986). College achievement among Sioux and white South Dakota students. Journal of American Indian Education. 25(2), 32-38.

Kidwell, C. S. (1986). Motivating American Indians into graduate studies. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 286 703).

McIntosh, B. J. (1987). Native American academic, financial, social, psychological, and demographic implications for education: A challenge to community college administrators. (ERIC Educational Document Reproduction Services No. ED 284 597).

Raymond, J. (1986). American Indian education and the reservation community college. (ERIC Document Reproduction Services No. ED 276 489).

Rindone, P. (1988). Achievement motivation and academic achievement of Native American students. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 302 370)

U.S. Department of Education. (1991). Final report: Indian nations at risk. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

Wright, B. (1985). Programming success: Special student services and the American Indian university student and persistence in a teacher preparation program. Journal of American Indian Education, 23( 1), 1-7.


Leave a Reply