Enhancing Faculty Development at Tribal Colleges

Volume 7, No. 3 - Winter 1996

It is ironic that colleges and universities are among the most labor intensive organizations in the United States but on average spend less than other organizations to maintain a highly effective work force. Even more dramatically, businesses in the United States spend less than businesses in virtually every other industrialized country in the world for on‑the‑job training. In this respect, tribal colleges are like most other post-secondary institutions and businesses in America. And yet, to ensure that our students are taught with the most recent pedagogies and information, we need to have a faculty development program in place that has demonstrable goals and attainable objectives.

The goals of faculty development are threefold:

  1. To improve teaching;
  2. To enhance the curriculum, and
  3. To improve student learning.

As with anyone who has investigated faculty development (e.g., Eble and McKeachie, 1985), we are aware that these goals are inevitably intertwined with other factors such as student ability and motivation. Hence, a single faculty development activity is only one ingredient of many that affects student learning. However, it must be studied and evaluated to ensure that it is as excellent as possible.

Over the last two years we visited 12 tribal colleges with faculty development programs funded by the Bush Foundation. We had three tasks. First, we surveyed faculty attitudes about faculty development at each institution, including a cross‑site comparison. Second, we analyzed various documents such as accreditation reports, Bush Foundation proposals, and yearly budgets in order to determine how the institutions operated and how much emphasis was given to faculty development. Third, we interviewed approximately 20 individuals at every site, including the president, the academic vice president, the chair of the Bush faculty development committee, various faculty, and tribal representatives, such as the education officer for the tribe.       It is difficult to determine the effectiveness of any faculty development program. How do faculty members’ attendance at a conference or workshop improve their teaching or the curriculum?  We did not assume that a conference automatically makes people better teachers. Through our interviews, however, we learned what people felt they learned from participating in faculty development activities.

We did not evaluate any individual college program, but rather the idea of faculty development in general. We recommended to the Bush Foundation ‑ and they accepted ‑ that the program be continued. As with any program, there is room for improvement. We first consider the strengths and weaknesses of faculty development at the tribal colleges and then recommend how it could be improved.

Tribal Colleges and Faculty Development

Although specific projects vary from institution to institution, three categories of activities take place. First, monies are used for in‑service training and workshops that all faculty are able to attend. Second, individual faculty members may apply for small grants for travel to professional conferences that deal with curriculum development, teaching techniques, or subject matter. Third, individual faculty also may call on the funds for graduate training.

At all of the colleges the grants are administered by a Faculty Development Committee whose explicit purpose is to disburse the funds and evaluate the success of each activity. Faculty are elected to the committee. How the committee functions varies from weekly meetings at one institution to one meeting a year at another college. All full‑time faculty are able to use the funds, but some colleges exclude part-time faculty from the program.

Eight of the twelve schools received $25,000 per year from the Bush Foundation; three schools received $30,000; and Navajo Community College received $40,000 per year. Grant size is determined by the number of full‑time faculty at each college. The grants are made in three year allotments, and the colleges may apply for renewal. The most funding that an individual faculty member received in one year was $1900, and the norm was closer to $400/individual. Some colleges augmented the Bush program with their own funds, but in general, individuals thought of faculty development as synonymous with the money they received from the Bush Foundation. Virtually everyone is aware of the availability of the grants, and satisfaction is quite high.

Evaluation depends upon a yearly report to the Bush Foundation by the Faculty Development Chair, which outlines the activities, expenses, and impact on the individual and/or college. Workshop activities range from a weekend meeting to discuss tribal culture, to an evening seminar about writing across the curriculum. Some individuals have attended the Bush

Foundation’s annual conference in Minnesota, and other faculty members have gone to professional conferences. A nurse, for example, went to a seminar about AIDS education; an instructor of diesel mechanics learned about the latest techniques and changes in his field at an industry sponsored training session.

The vast majority of conferences that individuals attended related to disciplinary area and subject matter content. While all colleges have supported graduate study, they differ in their enthusiasm and financial commitment to this activity. One college, for example, has supported several faculty pursuing masters degrees. However, since most left the college after receiving graduate degrees, they have become less enthused. Another college, on the other hand, has found that the support of graduate study has enabled it to “grow its own” faculty from tribal members with a commitment to continue at the college.

Characteristics of good program

There is not a great deal of literature about the evaluation of faculty development. Nevertheless, various researchers have identified characteristics of a good faculty development program. Eble and McKeachie (1985), for example, list the following:

  • The faculty have ownership of the program, rather than a  program that is imposed on them by the administration;
  • The administration strongly supports the program;
  • Local expertise is valued more than outside consultants;
  • Training is continuous rather than one time; and
  • Faculty assumptions about good programs don’t necessarily correlate with what best serves student learning and curricular development.

Faculty development should be a continuous process that is based on these ideas (Hynes, 1984). It should also be a community‑wide issue that concerns everyone (Angelo, 1994; Tierney, 1992). Three key elements of an institution must be analyzed: an institution’s mission and goals, the characteristics of the faculty, and the academic plan for the institution (Young, 1987).

We have used these points as the basis for our analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of tribal college faculty development. We do not suggest that all institutions are similar. Nevertheless, because of similar histories and contexts, we found certain common characteristics that affect faculty development programs at all the tribal colleges studied.

Strengths of the programs:

The study found several strong points in the tribal college faculty enhancement programs:

1.  All colleges were committed to improving teaching to improve learning. The availability of Bush funding for faculty development has encouraged thoughtful dialogues that otherwise may not have occurred. One institution, for example, had an “All‑College Day” where the entire faculty discussed what had been learned at a faculty development seminar, which several of the faculty attended. At another institution a reading group on teaching formed as an outgrowth of a workshop that the faculty attended.

2. The colleges were committed to developing faculty expertise. Research has shown that one essential facet of teaching excellence is the expertise of the faculty. Tribal colleges are among the most isolated institutions in the United States. Faculty attendance at conferences with faculty from other institutions has upgraded their skills. One person, for example, went to a conference on environmental issues which helped her develop a new curriculum in environmental science. A nurse incorporated tribal healing practices into the curriculum as a result of a Bush‑funded workshop that acquainted her with tribal culture. Another individual learned about team teaching at a workshop, which led to her creating an integrated studies program.

3. The advancement of faculty degrees. Pursuit of graduate study represents more than a strengthening of expertise. In most fields it provides a foundation of understandings that workshops and conferences can build upon. Moreover, obtaining advanced degrees is essential to institutional accreditation. Those faculty who have received such  support and who have remained on the faculty have strengthened the instructional programs. One person, for example, overhauled the business education curriculum as a result of an advanced degree. Another became actively involved in changing teacher education, and at a third institution a person helped implement a new program emphasizing biology and the environment. Support for pursuit of Masters degrees in subject areas (such as business or nursing) has been most appropriate, but it has been less accessible than programs in education.

4. Faculty governance. All of the tribal colleges have committees that provide the faculty with a sense of “ownership” of the program. Interviews suggest that for most of the colleges, the Bush grants stimulated the emergence of a faculty voice. Faculty at one college held meetings about how best to spend Bush funds when previously the faculty had never met as a group. The contrast between Indian college administrators and non‑Indian faculty, however, complicates the emergence of faculty governance. It adds a new dimension to the inherent tensions between administrators and faculty. In such a context, faculty should be especially concerned with connecting their activity to the institutional mission and the tribal community.

5. Skill development. When faculty attended conferences or workshops about the improvement of teaching they were able to return to the classroom with demonstrable techniques that improved their teaching. One group of faculty, for example, attended an assessment workshop and implemented new ways to assess teaching. A second group  went to a seminar on writing across the curriculum, which they then tried to implement at the college. A third group of faculty improved the way they conducted small group discussions after a seminar about pedagogy. Another person went to a faculty conference and learned how to integrate films and video more effectively in class.

Weaknesses of the programs

The problems that the colleges face and the weaknesses that result are:

1. Administrators are often unable to commit institutional funds or programmatic support to these programs beyond that provided by the Bush Foundation. We obviously appreciate the fierce competition for limited funds within the institutions, but we suggest that faculty development is not a luxury. It is a core activity necessary to improve the quality of education for students.

2. Programs goals are vague. Faculty development is loosely defined and even more loosely evaluated. It is often unclear how the specific seminars, workshops, or activities actually improve teaching or the curriculum. Faculty activities need to be more closely tied to institutional goals.

3. Programs have depended largely on outside expertise rather than local expertise. While in some cases the cultural knowledge implicit in the colleges’ missions has been addressed in workshops involving local tribal elders, most programs have relied heavily upon professional consultants on other issues, such as writing across the curriculum. Faculty learn disciplinary information rather than information that pertains specifically to the teaching and learning of Native American students. They make contact with other people in their fields at professional association meetings, or they have attended workshops conducted on campus by outside consultants.  Faculty of the various tribally controlled colleges have rarely met with one another to discuss their unique challenges and mutual interests. Faculties of other tribally controlled community colleges must be invited to participate in seminars and discussions. Although activities for specific disciplines are certainly worthwhile and necessary, we would like to see a greater balance between on-reservation and off- reservation training.

4. There is not enough follow up. Too few opportunities are provided to systematically disseminate information, either for individuals who traveled to a conference or for all‑college workshops. Writing across the curriculum, for example, might have been discussed for one day and never discussed again. A faculty member may have traveled to a conference to learn about a specific topic such as teaching techniques for the adult learner, and no one else at the college heard about the activity through any follow‑up presentation.

5. There are few institutional policies about the use of grants. The grants are generally not specifically tied to the institutional mission statement. Guidelines are not always clear. The administration of grants by faculty committees sometimes leads to conflict between faculty and administrators about how the grants should be used. The most serious policy concern is support for graduate study. At colleges that give funding for faculty to pursue advanced degrees, some of those individuals have left upon receiving their degrees, taking their new expertise with them.

Overall, we were quite impressed with how faculty development functions, and we feel that some overall goals have been attained:  Students have gained access to a faculty with more advanced training, less isolated from the broader higher education community, more attuned to the students’ distinctive learning characteristics, and more united in their focus on student learning. These programs have improved faculty retention and morale, which inevitably has enhanced the quality of the instructional program. Now the colleges can improve on what has been built.

Recommendations

We offer four possible ways to improve faculty development:

1. Develop more regional tribal college interaction. The tribal colleges in a region might pool a portion of their resources in order to have on‑going faculty interaction. We see great need, and great promise, if the business faculty from tribally controlled colleges in North Dakota, for example, could develop sustained relationships with one another.

2. Create an academic strategic plan. Because funding is so precarious, any sense of long‑range planning often seems fruitless. However, it is undoubtedly better if the institutions have an academic strategic plan with clearly delineated goals and plans for achieving those goals. Without such a plan, faculty development becomes individualistic rather than cohesive.

3. Demonstrate institutional commitment. As we said, we appreciate the fiscal problems of the tribal colleges. At the same time, some institutions have committed a portion of funds for faculty development, and others have not. If faculty development is a priority, then institutional budgets should reflect such a concern.

4. Develop institutional policies for all individuals to follow. We do not suggest a heavy layer of bureaucracy. The institutions, however, have grown to a point that decisions should be made according to well established policies instead of on a case by case basis. Such policies would answer questions such as whether a part-time faculty member should be able to utilize Bush funds, how such funds should be utilized, and what responsibility, if any, an individual has to the institution upon completing advanced study. In particular, we feel that any individual who uses faculty development funds (Bush or otherwise) for further study should be asked to stay at the institution at least one year beyond the grant or reimburse the institution.

Bibliography

Angelo, Thomas. From faculty development to academic development.  AAHE Bulletin 46(10): 3‑7 (June, 1994).

Eble, Kenneth & W. McKeachie. Improving undergraduate education through faculty development.  San Francisco: Jossey Bass, 1985.

Hynes, William. Strategies for faculty development. In Leadership roles for chief academic officers  ed. D. Brown. New Directions for Higher Education, no. 47. San Francisco:  Jossey Bass, 1984.

Tierney, William G. Official encouragement, institutional discouragement: Minorities in academe – the Native American experience. Norwood: Ablex, 1992.

Young, Robert. Evaluating faculty development programs. In Evaluating administrative services and programs. eds. J. Wergin & L. Braskamp. New Directions for Institutional Research, No. 56. San Francisco:  Jossey Bass, 1987.

This study was conducted with the support of the Bush Foundation and in particular, the guidance and advice of Stanley Shepard, former Senior Program Officer at the Foundation.

Tierney is Professor of Higher Education at the University of Southern California; Ahern is Professor of History at the University of Minnesota, Morris; Kidwell is Assistant Director for Cultural Resources, The National Museum of the American  Indian, Smithsonian Institution.


Leave a Reply