No Easy Money: An interview with Cris Stainbrook

Volume 4, No. 2 - Fall 1992
CRIS STAINBROOK

Cris Stainbrook

Cris Stainbrook has served as senior program officer of the Northwest Area Foundation since 1989. He is responsible for foundation programs in affordable housing, sustainable develop­ment of natural resources and economic diversification.

Prior to joining the foundation, Stainbrook directed the Northwest office of the First Nations Financial Project, where he coordinated economic development assistance to Indian tribes in Alaska, Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Montana and Wyoming. Under his supervision, his office helped tribes develop resources, create financing mechanisms, conduct economic impact studies and initiate economic development planning.

From this and other work as a businessman, Stainbrook has observed both the barriers and opportunities in tribal economic development. We asked him to share some of his observations.

He was interviewed by Schuyler Houser, a member of the faculty at Saskatchewan Indian Federated College. Houser also directed the Economic Development Institute at Sinte Gleska University and writes frequently on tribal colleges and tribal economic development.

Houser: When you look across economic development activities in Indian country over the past few years, what kinds of suc­cesses have you seen? What seems to work?

Stainbrook: There are many economic development successes that one could point to in Indian Country and to sum­marize those in a few sentences would he difficult if not impossible. But I think there are a few characteristics that have made the successes what they are and that other tribes should consider when they develop their own approach.

Probably the most important of these characteristics is inherent in the defini­tion of economic development. The tribes who have been successful have planned for and considered the many aspects of what goes into a fully devel­oped economy and not limited their thinking to the creation and placement of a single business or industry. The community infrastructure, the schools and other programs preparing those who will be in the work force, the appropriate mix of tribal enterprise and individual business ownership, how entrepreneurs can be assisted, tribal regulations and laws that have an effect on commerce, and what leakages in the current econo­my could be stopped are examples of the things that need to be incorporated and coordinated in an economic develop­ment strategy.

Another characteristic that seems to be vital to success is a firm understanding by the tribe and tribal members that the development process is relatively slow and that a commitment to pursue any given direction of economic develop­ment must be maintained over an extended period of time. In reality it is a process that will never end— market demands, the economic climates, the availability of local raw materials and the labor force will all change over time. In order for an economy to stay vital, it must adjust to these changes.

Houser: What have you seen that doesn’t work? Are there any approaches that tribes or Indian governments try repeatedly which don’ t seem to bring much success

Stainbrook: The tribes have had some experiences like those of non-reserva­tion communities. Many have attempt­ed to find and recruit or develop that one big business that will provide jobs for all of the tribal members. Some of the tribes that have been successful in getting a large employer to locate on the reserva­tion have found that beyond the increased payroll, very little in terms of real economic development occurred— there were not the goods and services on the reservation to capture the dollars and continually roll them over before leaving the local economy. The old EDA pro­jects were classics in this sense.

Also, I can’t begin to count the num­ber of businesses that I have seen tribes go into under the guise of economic development that were projected to be breakeven at best but were going to pro­vide tribal members with jobs. Invariably the businesses fail or require ongoing subsidy from the tribe. Rather than increasing the size and effectiveness of the reservation economy, the majority of these projects just speed the flow of funds to outside economies.

Houser: You make a distinction between economic development and business devel­opment. Could you explain what you mean by those terms? And what do those differ­ences imply for tribal governments and development within tribal communities?

Stainbrook: Economic development con­sists of fostering all of the transactions that involve the transfer of a good or ser­vice whereas business development will focus on a specific enterprise and its pro­duction and trade of its products The businesses and the industries, formal and informal, form the economy. Too often communities will hire a person to do eco­nomic development and really expect that person to spend their time helping start new businesses one at a time. All of the other pieces, such as the role of goveminent, educational institutions and community groups, that will facilitate the development of the economy are then unattended to.

This should not be construed as mean­ing business development is unimpor­tant. Rather, it is a part of economic development and not synonymous with it. In fact, there are many instances where tribes have undertaken business development for a tribal enterprise as the first step in their economic development strategy. The profits from the enterprise became a way to fund the further work.

Houser: This brings up the whole issue of gambling as a technique for economic devel­opment. Doesn’t this bring with it all the problems of short-term, quick hit schemes?

Stainbrook: It certainly could and it is an example in the difference between eco­nomic development and business devel­opment. If the tribes with gaming indus­tries don’t utilize some of the revenues before the market turns to expand into other industries, broaden their economic base, and plan for how the reservation economy can turn the money over sever­al times before it leaves the economy, then it will be another boom and bust with little left to show for it. In fact, if they don’t do this type of planning and expansion soon, it may be too late. We are already seeing tribes in the Northwest and Midwest competing heavily with one another for gambling revenues and, of course, the states have no intention of hacking off their pursuit to limit or elimi­nate Indian gaming.

On the other hand, for some tribes gaming provides relatively high amounts of revenue that could be used to finance virtually any economic development strategy that the tribes would want to pursue. How it turns out remains to be seen and I would guess we will see a con­tinuum of outcomes.

Houser: One other objection sometimes raised against gaming (and a copy of other approaches to economic development on reservations) is that it isn’t culturally appro­priate for tribal communities. What are your thoughts on these arguments?

Stainbrook: This is one of those things that has always amazed me. Usually you hear these objections from a non-Indian who is walking around with the “noble savage” image in their head or an Indian person who has decided that only they have the true definition of what the cul­ture is and how it should be maintained. Invariably they’re thinking that Indian people should all be pursuing something in arts, crafts, beadwork, and smoked fish! There is a complete neglect of the Indian person’s role as consumer and producer of contemporary goods and ser­vices that also shape the culture of today.

I always think back to an incident a few years ago when I hear this. The head of an organization that I was working with ques­tioned whether the fuel oil company that I was helping a native village in Alaska to establish was culturally appropriate. I relayed the conversation to one of the local folks and his reply was, “It is not outside of my culture to keep my butt warm in the winter time.” Clearly there are goods and services that are part of an Indian’s culture today that historically were not. Whether it is appropriate for the tribe or tribal members to pursue or include certain sectors and businesses in their economic development approach is not for me or anyone else from the outside to say.

Regarding gambling specifically, some of my first experiences with gambling were stick games at pow wows and impromptu horse races on several reservations. Now I can’t be sure, but these activities seem to have been around Indian Country for awhile and weren’t just devised to set a precedent for casino gambling.

Houser: Given your overall assessment of what’s happening, and what’s likely to happen, with economic development in Indian Country, what are the implications for tribal colleges? What might the colleges take into account in their institutional planning and curricula?

Stainbrook: I think that economic development on reservations will continue to become more complex as tribes expand into new areas of development and enterprise. This will require the future managers and business owners to have not only the more traditional good management and business skills but they will also need a good amount of flexibility and adaptability. The trib­al colleges can play the critical role in economic development in Indian Country by thoroughly preparing the next generation of managers and entrepreneurs. It looks as though they are moving to meet that challenge. The new business administration degree program at Sinte Gleska is a good example of this.

One of the most critical things that could occur at any reser­vation is for the tribal leadership to formulate an overall eco­nomic development strategy and then clearly articulate the strategy to the tribal college. The college would then be in a position to judge its curriculum relative to the tribal goals. For instance, if a tribe chose to emphasize businesses owned by tribal members rather than tribal ownership, the college might offer more entrepreneurial programming. The college could be a much more effective resource if it is kept in the planning loop.

Houser:What kinds of things might they want to avoid?

Stainbrook: Generally speaking, the tribal colleges are relatively young institutions and need some time to fully develop and solid­ify themselves as educational centers. Yet one of the disturbing patterns that is emerging is that outside entities go to the colleges with all types of ideas about what the colleges might undertake. I suppose this is because the outside groups are comfortable with the college structure and do not understand tribal governments or the traditional community structures that exist. If the colleges allow themselves to get pulled into a myriad of community issues and projects before becoming solid educational institutions, I think we will see politics begin to take a toll.

Houser: Some of the tribal colleges have gone beyond being just teach­ing ins- titutions to also having some research capabilities. Is there a role for this research capacity in a tribe’s economic development?

Stainbrook: Certainly there is. As a tribal council and reserva­tion community begins to lay out the direction it would like to go in developing its economy, the colleges could pull together some very useful research on economic trends, demographics, infrastructural requirements, etc. Good, complete information will help tribal leaders make wise decisions.

Also, this should not be considered a static process, that once the initial research is done the college no longer has a research role in the reservation development. Rather, the college could provide a very valuable tool to the leadership by continually analyzing the economic trends and other factors that will influ­ence the tribal economy. This would help the community avoid one of the most common pitfalls where a community sets a development plan in place. It then proceeds to follow the plan for the next 20 years despite the fact that changes in and around the community have made the direction obsolete after the first five years.

One other related item that I think the colleges should avoid and not be expected to carry out would be analyzing individual or specific business deals. This would eventually place the col­leges in an untenable political situation.


Leave a Reply