Whose College is It Anyway?: Growing government oversight in higher education threatens the unique vision of tribal colleges

Volume 5, No. 2 - Fall 1993

Since the American Indian Higher Education Consortium was first formed in the 1970s, accreditation has continually resur­faced as a conversation topic, study issue and general thorn in the side of tribal colleges. Many felt strongly tribal colleges were unique institu­tions that defied objective evaluation by mainstream higher education or mainstream American society, for that matter. Indeed, the birth of trib­al colleges was at least partly based on the refusal of the United States to recognize native peoples’ right to exist. As a result, many thought the tribal colleges should take on accred­itation of its own institutions as a pri­mary mission.

This, however, did not occur and as the years drifted past, individual institutions began to—successful­ly—jump through the hoops of the regional accreditation agencies. And as more colleges went through the process, viewpoints changed some­what as these outside agencies acknowledged the quality of colleges found in “Indian Country.” Now with the accreditation of Fort Belknap College and Stone Child College this past summer, there are 24 colleges out of 27 that are fully accredited.

Accreditation has not always been a pleasant experience for the tribal colleges and horror stories abound. Repeatedly, colleges have had to justify courses, teaching methods, administrative structures and intrinsic cultural values to visit­ing evaluators who are often unfa­miliar with American Indian com­munities. However, most college officials found the process to be invigorating and begrudgingly admitted that the process helped to improve their institution.

Does this mean accreditation is a moot point? Does the tribal college consortium still have an abiding concern with this issue? The answer is yes, but not for the traditional rea­sons. Events have come to pass that, ironically, have thrown tribal col­leges fully on the side of the regional accreditation agencies.

In 1992 the Higher-Education Act was reauthorized. This re-autho­rization came about after twelve years of antagonism between two successive Republican administra­tions and the higher education community as a whole. While the Republican administration allowed the country to be looted by the sav­ings and loan industry, they were loudly complaining about the default rates on government guaran­teed loans (paid in full to the bank­ing industry by the government) to college students.

While this problem was to a great extent caused by the lack of adequate financial support for low income stu­dents and by proprietary schools which were ripping students and the government off at an amazing rate, the blame was laid on American higher education as a whole.

In order to correct these prob­lems, political appointees decided that accreditation as it was currently structured in the United States was not working properly. Joe Malik and John Peterson have just published a definitive article on the subject in the August/September 1993 issue of the Community College Journal. Explaining the problem, they say:

In 1965 Congress passed legisla­tion assigning to a triad of agencies the responsibility for monitoring the quality of higher education in the United States. Within the Higher Education Act of 1965, each of the players—the federal government, state agencies and accrediting bod­ies—assumed specific roles in the determination of educational quali­ty. Specifically, the legislation stated that a postsecondary student would be eligible for federal funds only if the institution attended held mem­bership status with an accreditation agency recognized by the U.S. Department of Education. Consequently, accreditation became a gatekeeper for access to federal funding. To provide this evaluative service to the federal government, the accrediting community used its own proce­dures and standards, and received no support from state or federal agencies for this expanded responsi­bility.

The 1992 amendments have altered significantly the triad crafted 28 years ago. Under the newly revised Higher Education Act, the Secretary will continue to rely on accrediting bodies to evaluate institutions; however, state agencies will have an increased oversight role with respect to federal funding in post-secondary institutions. The desig­nated State Postsecondary Review Entity (SPRE) in each state will be responsible for reviewing and determining an institution’s continued eligibility for federal funding if that institu­tion’s default rate is high, if there is excessive dependence on funds received from the federal govern­ment, or if there is a pattern of student complaints of misleading or inappropriate advertising, and other similar criteria.

Obviously, this raises serious juris­dictional questions regarding states versus tribal governments. At least one tribal college, Sinte Gleska University, has indicated that it will be working with the Rosebud Sioux Tribe to set up a tribal accrediting agency. For the majority of tribal col­leges, however, a tribal accreditation agency is not feasible. The tribes have neither the resources nor expertise.

Of course, none of the tribal juris­dictional concerns have been accounted for in Higher Education Act amendments. Many tribal col­leges and their chartering govern­ments would be reluctant, to say the least, to have state agencies, which are driven by their own agendas, to have the ability to jerk financial aid from tribal students or accreditation recognition from tribal colleges. New amendments do say that those institutions not requiring a state review must maintain accreditation from a recognized accrediting agency. However, it is almost certain that the schools meant by that pro­vision refer to proprietary or profes­sional schools for which a given state might not provide regulation or licensure.

In addition to the state determi­nation of eligibility, additional bur­dens are placed upon the accredita­tion agency (and, of course, the col­leges). These include:

  • Accreditation standards are to incorporate specific criteria address­ing the assessment of program length and clock or credit hours, default rates in student loan pro­grams, student complaints, compli­ance with Title IV, and more.
  • Accreditation agencies are to conduct unannounced, on-site reviews of institutions that offer vocational education and training.
  • Site visits are to be conducted within six months to institutions that establish branch campuses or that change ownership.
  • Accrediting commissions are required to have one public member for every six representatives from higher education; trustees and con­sultants may not serve as public members.
  • Accrediting agencies must include in their procedures the requirement that a member institu­tion disputing final denial, with­drawal, or termination of accredita­tion submit the dispute to arbitra­tion prior to legal action.
  • Accrediting agencies are to adopt quantitative standards for stu­dent outcomes. This is how it is stat­ed in the draft regulations: “For an institution…that provides pre-baccalaureate vocational education, establish minimum quantitative standards for completion rates, job placement rates, and pass rates on state licensing examinations or other appropriate measures of occu­pational competency.”

These expectations established in law and regulation are clearly designed to control abuses in small, limited-purpose vocational schools. This for-profit segment of higher education is where most abuses of student aid have taken place.

If tribal colleges thought accredi­tation was trying in the past, the future promises to be much more complicated. The major problem is an assumption by the career staff of the Department of Education that all institutions that offer any pre-baccalaureate vocational courses are similar if not identical. Whereas the regional accreditation process has always started with the mission and legal status of an institution and evaluated their effort to meet the mission, this effort relies on Department of Education and state agencies to determine what the mis­sion should be. This development of arbitrary standards seems tailor made to put any college which does not fit “a white American mold” out of business.

Regardless of what assurances are given, tribal colleges, as truly culture-based institutions, have more to lose than any other identifiable group of colleges in the country. What makes the process even more nefarious is that it is not being aimed maliciously at tribal colleges, but at higher education as a whole.

There will be a short period of time when concerted action may prevent these regulations from becoming law. Tribal colleges are urged to read the article in the Community College Journal and respond with all the political clout that can be mustered.

James Shanley is president of Fort Peck Community College in Poplar, Montana.


Leave a Reply