
Byron Baker
When Byron Baker was growing up on the Fort Berthold Reservation in North Dakota, he listened to the stories his people (the Mandan, Hidatsa, and Arikara) told of going to the Indian Health Service. “Everybody had a story, sometimes funny and sometimes tragic, but always about physicians who didn’t understand Indian people,” he says.
Often unhappy in the rural setting and sometimes unwelcome, Indian Health Service (IHS) recruits tend to stay on reservations for the minimum time required and then leave, resulting in constant turnover and vacancies. So even as a young boy, Baker said to himself: “I could do better than that, simply because of who I am. I can understand my own people.”
Although nearly thwarted by unexpected obstacles and self-doubt, he is now completing his third year of medical school at the University of North Dakota in Bismarck and plans to return soon to Fort Berthold to practice family medicine.
Baker will be one of a growing corps of American Indian health care professionals. For generations, schools shunted promising Indian students into vocations such as nursing aides. Now, however, more Indian students such as Baker hope to become doctors, nurses and dentists. And with the backing of tribal colleges, more realize their dreams.
Between the census of 1980 and 1990, the number of physicians reporting themselves as American Indian increased by 63 percent (up to 868 doctors in 1990) while the number of registered nurses increased by 92 percent (7,524 RNs in 1990). Based upon their growing enrollment in medical schools, another increase can be expected by the next census: 63 Indian medical students graduated in 1992, and 333 were enrolled in medical school, according to the Association of American Medical Colleges.
Nevertheless, the number of Indian medical students still falls far short of what it should be. While Indian people represent .9 percent of the population as a whole, Indian medical students represented only .5 percent of the medical school enrollment in 1992.
Improving such statistics is important not just because it fills quotas. In remote areas, there is a severe shortage of doctors and nurses. “Rural South Dakota needs nurses. It seems much more reasonable to teach people who live in the area rather than enticing people to come here,” says Susan Hardin Palmer, director of nursing at Sisseton Wahpeton Community College.
But Palmer and others say native American doctors and nurses offer even more. They also build better communication and trust with patients. Indian health professionals also can help non-Indian doctors and nurses provide better care for everyone, they say.
Indians at Risk
Indian health has long been recognized as a serious problem. After I the initial contact with Europeans, disease killed far more of the continent’s original inhabitants than warfare. Although life expectancy has increased considerably over the past several decades, Indian people still die younger from disease and accidents than the general population, according to Indian Health Service statistics for Indian people on or near reservations. Of all American Indian and Alaska Native people who died during 1986-1988, one-third were under 45 years of age, compared to one-tenth of the general population.
They are much more likely than the general population to die of certain causes, according to 1988 IHS statistics: alcoholism, 438 percent greater; tuberculosis, 400 percent greater; diabetes, 155 percent greater; accidents, 131 percent greater. These figures pertain only to the Indian population served by the IHS, which is about half of the whole. The American Association of Indian Physicians believes the death rates are even higher than IHS statistics indicate.
Why should so many Indian people face such dismal futures? Studies often link poverty with sickness and death. According to the 1990 ; Census, Indians are the most poverty-stricken group in America. Several socio-economic indicators have obvious links to health. Indians are nearly five times as likely to live in households without plumbing. Other studies point to the isolation of many reservations, saying rural people often live far from hospitals and emergency care; 18 percent of the nation’s Indian households don’t have access to vehicles, compared with 13 percent of the general population. Several federal investigations have blamed staff shortages at the Indian Health Service and the agency’s alleged misuse of federal funds for aggravating health problems in Indian Country.
A 1991 study by the American Indian Health Care Association found that while many other rural people also suffer from isolation and poverty, cultural and governmental barriers impede health care for Indian people more. The study focused upon eight upper Midwest and Northwest states, a region where, coincidentally, tribal colleges have their greatest concentration.
The report said bureaucratic barriers kept Indian people from getting access to mainstream and Indian Health Service care. Significantly, state health departments reported that their own cultural ignorance stood in the way of serving Indian people adequately. Asked to identify problems for the study, these health departments identified “incorrect judgments by the non-Indian community about what health services should be offered” and “lack of cultural knowledge by health care providers.” Only a small percentage said they provided culturally appropriate health education materials. Non-Indian health professionals polled in the study pointed to an obvious solution—train more American Indian health care workers.
While these responses acknowledge cultural barriers, they don’t recognize the deep level of distrust for Western doctors that exists in Indian country nor how much that distrust has stood in the way of healthy Indian people.
Building Trust
If you grew up on a reservation around an Indian Health system, you did all that you could before you went in,” Byron Baker says. “It was your last resort. Off the reservation, you don’t go through all that. You just pick a health provider and go. That way you shorten the duration of the illness,” he says.
Indian health professionals can break down the mistrust of Indian patients, according to a study conducted by Salish Kootenai College in 1988 to justify the need for its nursing program. “Our survey showed that Indian nurses are more accepted by tribal people as caregivers,” says Jacque Dolberry, director of nursing at the college. “For example, last week one of our students was in a non-Indian hospital taking care of a local Indian who had refused to have blood drawn or to have any care given. He knew she was Indian and from our college She was able to help him accept,” Dolberry says.

Salish Kootenai nursing students Arnissa Fugelberg and Nadeen Dumontier. Photo credit: Salish Kootenai College
How do Indian caregivers break down the mistrust? Non-Indian doctors and nurses sometimes cannot communicate with the Indian patients because of actual language barriers: In some areas of the country, many elderly Indian patients do not speak English.
More often, more subtle cultural communication is lacking. Not knowing what it means to be poor, with no running water, a doctor can’t understand why a patient can’t take soaking baths or can’t buy the prescription. If the doctor is not familiar with religious practices, he or she wouldn’t understand why an Indian patient can’t take birth control pills during sun dance, according to Dr. Lois Steele, a Fort Peck Assiniboine physician now working for the IHS in Tucson.
“We (IHS) have good doctors who try to learn about the cultures,” Dr. Steele says. “But if you have someone who grew up there on the reservation, you just have to teach them medicine,” she says.
Role of Tribal Colleges
Despite being primarily two-year institutions, tribal colleges can play a vital role in preparing Indian students to be doctors and nurses. The colleges have been fighting for years to convince some skeptics of that, however. Some doubt the abilities of Indian students. When Turtle Mountain ; Community College called the dean at another college for help with articulation agreements for health professionals, the dean offered help instead with a nurse’s aide program. She made the patronizing remark to the wrong person.
“Look, dear. We have been aides long enough,” said Pat Gailfus, vocational education director at Turtle Mountain College. Herself an Ojibwe registered nurse, Gailfus has been working since 1983 trying to get a medical program going at the college. “We need our own taking care of our own,” she says.
If the dean had been interested, Gailfus could have pointed to the extraordinary achievements of Turtle Mountain Ojibwe health professionals. Despite the small size of the tribe, she says they boast ten physicians who are members. Anna Albert, the first Indian to be appointed as the director of one of the three Indian medical centers in the country, is also a tribal member.
Tribal colleges offer the same advantages to health care students as to students in other fields: a familiar setting, close to home and families, with a strong cultural foundation. The cultural component can be even more crucial for health care students than for the others.
For Byron Baker, Fort Berthold Community College and an IHS scholarship made the difference between continuing his life as a jailer and becoming a doctor. When he first left the reservation for college, Baker suffered from self-doubt and cultural confusion.
“There was a sense of guilt that maybe I forgot where I came from,” he says. “So many of our students have low expectations set for them by educators. I gave them what they expected,” he says.
After flunking out, he returned to Fort Berthold Community College, the only place that would accept him with a GPA of .46. When he later went to the University of North Dakota, he dropped out again for a semester, which he attributes to “extreme loneliness.”
Then he got the IHS scholarship. With the support of the tribal college, some older Indian students at the University of North Dakota, and the Indians into Medicine program there, he resolved his cultural questions, quit drinking, and raised his grade point average to 2.98.
Patients, as well as students, benefit from tribal college health care preparation programs. During their studies, the colleges place students in nearby clinics, hospitals, and nursing homes. Even though the students have not completed their studies, the patients can communicate with culturally compatible health care workers. “The students have the opportunity to adapt the Western practices they learn in school to what is acceptable in the Indian community,” says Jacque Dolberry of Salish Kootenai College.
Some of the colleges offer health programs for the community, too. A leader in this area, Salish Kootenai College in Montana holds health fairs, provides immunizations, and assesses health at the local day care center. Salish Kootenai faculty are involved indirectly in programs to prevent alcohol and drug abuse, to prevent infant mortality, and to promote positive parenting. The college hopes to establish a health clinic on campus, which Dolberry believes will be the only health clinic on a tribal college campus.
Barriers to Tribal Colleges
Despite such advantages, tribal colleges find it difficult to establish programs for health professionals. The chronic illness of tribal colleges—underfunding—is exacerbated for medical courses. Teaching such courses requires low student/teacher ratios and expensive equipment—such as electrocardiogram machines, instrument sterilizers, incubators for germs, centrifuges, and computers. An EKG machine alone might cost $4,000.
Without high salaries, the colleges have trouble attracting medical professors to remote sites. Sisseton Wahpeton Community College, for example, could not establish its nursing program for several years because it could not find a director. After watching their frustrations, South Dakota State University Nursing Director Susan Hardin Palmer took early retirement in June 1992 to seek a new challenge on the reservation, commuting 90 miles one way each day.
“It’s hard to get teachers when you are competing with hospitals, including IHS, which pay much, much more,” says Judy Gaalswyk, director of nursing at Oglala Lakota College for the past three years. “We have faculty with master’s who have taught here ten years and make $10,000 less than graduates with associate degrees and one year experience here,” she says. The conditions create constant crises. “I don’t have an instructor for pediatrics for two weeks from now,” she says.
Despite the obstacles, three tribal colleges offer registered nurse programs—Salish Kootenai, Oglala Lakota and Sisseton Wahpeton. In North Dakota, two colleges offer associate degrees for licensed practical nurses—Fort Berthold and United Tribes. North Dakota is the only state that requires four year degrees for registered nurses. By adopting this requirement, the state eliminated hospital-based training programs and put more emphasis upon colleges, including tribal colleges, according to Brenda Caranicas, director of nursing at Fort Berthold Community College.
Other tribal colleges tailor their programs to introduce students to the health field. Turtle Mountain offers associate science degrees with emphasis upon certain careers, such as medical technology, radiology, or pre-medicine. With a grant from the Kellogg Foundation, Bay Mills Community College recruits Indian students into health careers, offering a variety of pre-health courses. They are also preparing to offer a terminal degree program in health care (see story, page 11). Crownpoint Institute of Technology provides a sixteen week program for students who want to be certified nursing assistants, emphasizing highly technical skills needed in rural areas. Southwest Indian Polytechnic Institute offers optical technology.
Several colleges, including Dull Knife Memorial College and Salish Kootenai, offer chemical dependency programs to train counselors. Only Salish Kootenai offers a degree for dental technicians. Some have medical technician programs.
Observing the health problems on their reservations, tribal colleges dream of providing more health courses. Those with nursing programs vacillate between deep pride in what they do offer and despair over what they can’t.
On the Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota, for example, five of the seven nursing supervisors at the Pine Ridge Hospital—the tribal health planner, the director of nurses, and the Community Health Representatives—are all graduates of the Oglala Lakota College program. Such people face challenges unheard of for registered nurses with associate degrees in urban areas.
But far beyond offering nurses aides programs, the tribal colleges and their cooperating universities really need to be offering bachelor’s and master’s programs on or near the reservations, Gaalswyk believes. “We struggle for ongoing survival and don’t have our dream, down the road, of getting a high level of professional nursing here,” Gaalswyk says.
Encouraging Prospects
Congress and private funders have begun to recognize the link between poor Indian health and the lack of Indian health professionals, and tribal colleges want to tap into this interest. Under the Indian Health Care Improvement law, Congress authorized the IHS to provide grants to Indian organizations and community colleges to recruit and educate Indian students at various levels to become heath care professionals. IHS also provides scholarships for Indian students.
Since Congress has not provided funds, some of the programs have never been implemented, however, according to Darrell Pratt of the IHS. Two tribal colleges—Salish Kootenai and Oglala Lakota Colleges—are among the six colleges nationwide that received IHS grants for their nursing program.
In North Dakota, the tribal colleges and the University of Mary have proposed a bachelor’s program, with the tribal colleges providing the first two years’ instruction and the university bringing much of the third and fourth years out to the reservations. South Dakota State University offers limited undergraduate degrees in health fields through programs on or near reservations. Another tribal college wants to share its nursing classes through satellite video.
Such initiatives and many of the current course offerings depend upon insecure sources of funding, however. Indian students have gotten excited and motivated about health programs before, only to see funding dry up after one or two years.
One of the most innovative ideas for supplementing tribal college faculty is Oglala Lakota College’s cross cultural sabbatical program, through which experienced teachers would take sabbaticals to work at the tribal college for cross cultural experiences. The dean of the nursing school in New York came out for a year to teach at OLC.
For longevity, students can look to the Indians into Medicine (INMED) program at the University of North Dakota. In its twenty year history, it has produced one-fifth of the nation’s Indian physicians. UND reserves ten of its 60 medical school entry slots each year for Indian students. INMED helps Indian students get IHS scholarships and tuition waivers for summer pre-med university classes.
Healthy Colleges, Healthy Communities
For more than twenty years, Dr. Lois Steele has been thinking I about the ties between reservation communities, Indian students, and health. She directed the INMED program for eight years in the 1970s and 1980s. The INMED staff went to every tribal council in a five state area, working with them to get students into health professions.
“The tribal chairmen were very supportive,” she says. “The students we lost in medical school (who dropped out) were not lost because they were not smart enough to do the work. They were lost because they didn’t get support from the home community and vice versa: Many did better than their grades would indicate because of community support,” she says. “I know of one person who went through medical school with a GED and got the highest scores that had ever been written in that medical school,” she says.
Having tribal colleges in the reservation communities brings the importance of education home, she says, and inspires families and friends to support the students. Most students are the first in their families to get a college degree and need all the understanding they can get. It also creates healthier people; educated people make better choices about diet and lifestyle.
If national support for the training of Indian health care professionals continues, the health of Indian people and the effectiveness of the medical professions may gradually begin to improve. Patients, especially in rural areas, will be served by more Indian doctors, nurses, and dentists who know the community and understand how their people work, not just physically but mentally and spiritually.
For himself, Byron Baker credits both INMED and the IHS commitment to funding scholarships for family practitioners in rural areas. When he asked the IHS recruiter why he had so much difficulty hiring doctors for the Fort Berthold Reservation in northwestern North Dakota, he told Baker that no one wanted to go there. “That surprised me,” Baker said, remembering the open plains and picturesque badlands that he calls home.
Now, when his studies at the UND Medical School become overwhelming, Baker thinks about Mandaree and New Town, the pow wows, and the house he will be building for his family on the reservation after so many years away. He thinks about serving as a doctor for his people and a role model for his son and his nephews and nieces. Then, with new determination, his thoughts return to his studies.
Marjane Ambler is a freelance writer and editor in Colorado and a regular contributor to Tribal College.
Cultivating Good Health
A tribal college in Minnesota is approaching wellness from the ground up. The newest member of the American Indian Higher Education Consortium, Leech Lake Tribal College, sees gardening as the core of its holistic approach to health and wellness—spiritually, mentally and physically.

Leech Lake College's gardening project promotes good health by growing traditional foods. From left: John Morrow, Director of Gardening Projects; Larry P. Aitken, President of Leech Lake Tribal College and Gill Goetz, State Project Director.
As with most Indian communities, the Ojibwe are troubled with high rates of diabetes. Medical research has proven that many traditional crops used by indigenous peoples can be effective in combating diabetes, while high-fat, processed commodity foods tend to exacerbate the disease.
Inspired by this finding, Leech Lake Community College, along with several other native American communities, is sponsoring gardens that produce traditional foods. It is hoped that healthier diets will result.
In the Southwest, for example, the Tohono O’Odham Tribe, working with the Tucson-based Native Seeds/SEARCH and the University of Colorado, use foods such as prickly pear, mesquite-bean flour, cholla cactus buds, chia seeds, and live oak acorns.
Leech Lake Tribal College uses traditional crops and ceremonial plants of the northern Plains—Hidatsa beans, Mandan corn, Bear Island corn, Arikara squash and sweet-grass—according to John Morrow, dean of students and community services. Traditionalists such as Morrow smudge with the sweetgrass for spiritual cleansing and purification prior to ceremonies, sweats, cleaning house—and planting gardens.
The college has funded 109 gardens in the community as well as four college gardens, says Morrow, who identifies his tribal heritage as Anishinabe rather than Ojibwe. The college pays youth workers to help the elderly and the diabetics with their gardening. It also gives tomatoes as house plants to the elderly living in the local nursing home.
By the spring quarter, Leech Lake Tribal College plans to offer an Indigenous Health and Wellness curriculum. As the required lab for the course, students will participate in gardening.
This home-grown approach to community health reaps wide support. A non-Indian concerned about diabetes, Gil Goetz, raised the “seed money” for community gardens at Leech Lake and several reservations in the upper Midwest.
At least one other tribal college hits started its own greenhouse and garden. With binding from the National Science Foundation, Dull Knife Memorial College in Montana will be growing edible, ceremonial, and medicinal plants next year.
“This is a total healing mechanism for the individual, the family, and the community,” Morrow says. -MjA
Resources
Native American Pharmacy Program
North Dakota State University
P.O. Box 5162
Fargo ND 58105
800 488-NDSU
Association of American Indian Physicians
1235 Sovereign Row Suite C-7
Oklahoma City OK 73108
405 946-7072
Indians into Medicine
University of North Dakota
501 Columbia Road North
Grand Forks ND 58203
701 777-3037
American Indian Health Care Association
245 East 6th St. S499
St. Paul MN 55101
612 293-0233
Infant Mortality Study
Indian Health Service, Aberdeen Area
3200 Canyon Lake Dr.
Rapid City SD 57702
800 854-8845 ext. 376
Ask for copies of the regional report or any of the eight state reports that make up the Northwest Area American Indian Health Status and Policy Assessment Project.
Why Indians Shouldn’t be Physicians
“When we encourage our young people to go to medical school, we have to understand what we’re asking of them. They will end up giving and giving. They will be exposed to diseases that can kill them. They will never be done studying. The demands will always be more than they can meet.”
“I wouldn’t trade my life for anything, but we have to be realistic. I tell students, ‘Don’t go to medical school to get rich or famous. Go because you want to know this stuff and want to serve. If you have any other reason, you should be in another field.’ I wanted to know that stuff.”
“Many of our Indian physicians don’t work on reservations because the people’s expectations of them are so high. They get burned out. They see their relatives dying. You expect more of yourself when you’re trying to work for your own people. You just can’t learn it all.”
Dr. Lois Steele, physician, Fort Peck Assiniboine, former director of the Indians into Medicine program at the University of North Dakota.







Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.