In Business for Ourselves: Northern Entrepreneurs

Volume 4, No. 4 - Spring 1993

BUSINESS BOOK COVERFifteen Case Studies of Successful Small Northern Businesses
by Wanda A. Wuttunee
McGill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal. 312 pp.

Review by Schuyler Houser

Whose Business?

Economic development in tribal communities has, until recently, been a fairly mysterious process. Some tribes succeeded, some tribes didn’t, but the conditions which yielded success or failure were rarely clear enough to provide helpful lessons for other communities.

Scholars and analysts, during most of the 1980s, paid little atten­tion to issues of development in tribal communities (or rural areas generally); little research was con­ducted, and not much was written or published on these topics. In the absence of any useful theories or guidelines, therefore, most tribes and individual entrepreneurs had to make it up as they went along, eco­nomically speaking, and trust their own judgments and skill.

Some of those judgments were sound. Over the past decade, adverse federal attitudes and inhos­pitable business climates notwith­standing, some tribes chose policies which clearly enhanced local devel­opment, and some individual busi­nesses on reservations survived and flourished.

Researchers are now beginning to explore the learning which has accumulated as tribes created and implemented their own policies, and as tribal business people built viable enterpris­es. Useful general statements about these processes are still difficult to make—not enough data has been assembled to provide com­prehensive national, or even regional, descriptions of economic development in Indian country. But specific stories are beginning to emerge, and these, when combined with thoughtful analysis, can help governments and entrepreneurs to make prudent and informed choices.

In Business for Ourselves describes fifteen such success stories in north­ern Canada. Offered as case studies, each is examined in close detail and treated as a model for aspiring entre­preneurs.

Wuttunee, a research associate at the University of Calgary’s Arctic Institute of North America, interviewed the owner/man­agers of a diverse range of business­es—including an in-home translation ser­vice, a game farm, a con­struction compa­ny operated by an Indian govern­ment and a moder­ately-sized new car dealership—in the Canadian far north. She used several basic criteria to select the enterprises included in the study: each had survived for at least four years; each was profitable at the time of the study; each provided local employment; each operated in “cul­turally and environmentally sensitive ways.”

The cases provide considerable detail about the day-to-day manage­ment of each business. The entre­preneurs speak directly and candidly about what worked and what didn’t in their original plans, and about the surprises they encountered as their businesses grew. Wuttunee is especially successful in describing how individual managers made par­ticular business decisions.

The profile of successful northern Canadian business people which emerges from these cases is a famil­iar one on many reservations in the United States. These entrepreneurs appear, contrary to popular stereo­types, to be somewhat risk-averse, cautious not to over-extend or over­build, careful not to borrow more than can be easily repaid, mindful of quality and reputation in the local community, adaptable and innova­tive within clearly defined limits, and likely to involve family and trusted friends in the business.

Not all of the entrepreneurs in Wuttunee’s study were Native (the Canadian term which includes Indian, Metis and Inuit people). By including both Native and Non- Native entrepreneurs, the author implies that geographical conditions—isolation, difficult climate, small populations—may be at least as important as ethnicity in deter­mining conditions for businesses in the north. The detail and candor of the cases also allows for compar­isons between successful native and non-native approaches to business development.

Wuttunee chose to omit from her book material which is easily avail­able elsewhere, such as standard instructions on how to develop busi­ness plans. Instead, she systematical­ly encouraged the entrepreneurs to speak in plain and personal language about their experiences. Many of the business people included straightforward advice to readers who might consider setting up simi­lar enterprises.

The discussions, therefore, cumu­latively resemble the kinds of con­versations which occur within bor­rowers’ circles in peer-group lending programs, as individuals report on their own issues and successes, and work with each other to identify and solve business problems. The checklists on business development decisions included in the appendices are models of their kind—clear, direct, and accessible to readers who lack formal training in business, but who may nonetheless become suc­cessful entrepreneurs.

Schuyler Houser is on the faculty of Saskatchewan Indian Federated College in Regina, Saskatchewan. He has written exten­sively about tribal economic issues and was director of the Institute for Economic Development at Sinte Gleska University. In the next issue, he will review What Can Tribes Do? which looks at economic development from a tribal perspective.


Leave a Reply